Status (28 October 2026): Open — the leading candidate. The book now makes the case that Charles was possibly Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, in the chapter “The Boy from the Goose Corner”, which also gives the evidence against it and the DNA tests that could settle it. He is the leading candidate, not the only one: seven other Carls of the three parishes are still open (Open Leads). No record yet links the name Hofedietz to Gannsen; the name Konze is possibly that of the family that took him in, which is a hypothesis.
| Born | 13 November 1837, Deisel (Dornette birth row 14243; baptism re-read October 2026) |
|---|---|
| Father | Ricus Hofeditz (Hofedietz in the register), Kutscher (coachman), b. 10 Oct 1789 Deisel — d. 19 July 1843, Deisel |
| Mother | Amalie Florentine Weller, b. 27 Jan 1809 Langenthal — d. 3 Nov 1844, Deisel |
| Confirmed | Deisel, 11 April 1852 (Archion 218836, Bild 941, Nr 14, read in the image) |
| Siblings | Sophia, b. 4 Jan 1831, d. 2 Oct 1854 at Deisel; Amalie, married at Witten in 1863; Maria, b. 2 Jun 1835, married at Lütgendortmund (Dortmund) in 1865. Half-brother Andreas Hofedietz (1809–1884) of Deisel. |
| His own fate | Unknown. No marriage or death record found after his confirmation. On 23 February 1900 the court at Karlshafen summoned him as missing, saying he had emigrated to America at the beginning of the 1850s; the application was made by his curator, the Deisel innkeeper Heinrich Konze (Deutscher Reichsanzeiger, 1 March 1900, item 8) |
| Obstacle | The surname. Hofeditz has no known path to Gannsen; the book weighs the house-name, nickname and foster-family explanations in “The Boy from the Goose Corner” |
| His family in full | The Hofedietz family back to a Deisel master tailor of the 1700s, the grandparents on both sides and the half-brother’s line: the fuller online version of the chapter |
Why he leads
He is a Carl Ludwig, and Charles enlisted as “Charles L. Johnsen”. He was born at Deisel, and Charles named “Deisse” in 1866. The ages Charles gave fit a birth in November 1837: the 1900 census says November 1836, the Soldiers’ Home “about 1837”, and an 1891 record gives his age as 53. He was orphaned at six, in a landless household, and there is no trace of him after his confirmation until the court at Karlshafen summoned him in 1900 as an emigrant missing since the early 1850s, with a Konze as his curator. Against all this stands his surname, which no record yet links to Gannsen.
His family stayed at Deisel
In October 2025 this boy was crossed off because “the Hofeditz family went to Kansas”. That was a family-level statement, and it does not reach him. His own household died at Deisel. All three deaths are read in the original register, Deisel Beerdigungen 1830–1876 (Archion KB 218851):
| Bild 1859 Entry 403 | “Ricus Hofedietz … verheirathet mit Amalie Weller”, of Deisel, Gänsewinkel Nr. 146; born Deisel, 10 October 1789; died 19 July 1843, buried 21 July. |
|---|---|
| Bild 1864 Entry 434 | “Amalia Florentina, Wittwe des verstorbenen Kutscher Ricus Hofedietz, geb. Weller”, same house; born Langenthal, 27 January 1809; died 3 November 1844, buried 6 November. |
| Bild 1930 Entry 853 | “Sophia Hofedietz, eheliche ledige Tochter des verstorbenen Ricus Hofedietz und dessen gleichfalls verstorbenen Ehefrau Amalia, geb. Weller”; born Deisel, 4 January 1831; died 2 October 1854 in the Gemeindehaus, the parish poorhouse. |
The Kansas Hofeditz turned out to be a different family. “C. L. Hofeditz” of Mound Valley, Labette County, Kansas, is Conrad Ludwig Hofeditz, who came to Baltimore in 1848, aged eight, with his living parents Johann Christian (1811–1873, buried at Marine, Madison County, Illinois) and Gertrude. He married in Madison County in 1866/67 and was in Kansas by 1880. The Civil War private “Lewis Hofeditz” of Co. F, 10th Illinois Cavalry, mustered at Marine in 1861, belongs to the same Madison County family (research note, 9 Oct 2026).
The “Kansas” remark of 30 October 2025 was Jed’s own Ancestry lookup, reported to the Trendelburg researcher, who agreed (“we can forget Hofeditz”). It was never a German-side finding.
Karl Ludwig’s godparent is entered as Ludwig Rohmann, “Bruder der Mutter”, though the mother is a Weller. The entry is right. Ludwig Rohmann, born at Langenthal in 1815, was the son of Johann George Rohmann and Anna Gertrude, born Strecker, the widow of a Weller — Amalie Florentine’s own mother. So he was her half-brother. This fixes the mother as Amalie Florentine Weller, born 1809 at Langenthal, and the burial entry above agrees.
Searches that found nothing
- Marriage: the Deisel marriage register read groom by groom for c. 1850–85, and the civil marriages for Deisel 1874–1901 and Trendelburg 1886–1901: no marriage of his (research note, 9 Oct 2026).
- Death in Hesse: 16 Hofeditz men born 1832–42 died in Hesse; none is a Karl, Carl or Ludwig (research note, 9 Oct 2026).
- Emigration: the full LAGIS detail sweep (2,227 records) has no Deisel Hofeditz of his age. The “Koehler; Hofeditz, Karl Ludwig” of Sielen (1857) is Karl Ludwig Köhler, a different man (Köhler; research note, 9 Oct 2026).
- U.S. records: no Karl, Carl, Charles or Louis Hofeditz born 1835–39 outside the Madison County family. Find a Grave has 125 Hofeditz memorials in the United States, none in Kansas or Missouri; the seven of the immigrant generation are in Iowa, Indiana, New York and Washington.
- Kassel marriages: the Kassel civil marriage registers of 1874–1900 hold no marriage of his.
Notes on the Dornette data
- His missing death record in the Dornette corpus means little. For the 324 Deisel births of 1835–45, only 68% have a death signal in either the death file or a birth-file note, so about one child in three has none. The death file also has whole-alphabet gaps (no surnames beginning N, O or T). Names-DB method-note row 97540.
- Ricus Hofeditz’s birth row carries the note
1971847(19 July 1847); the register reads 1843. - Several Dornette rows carry
38200in a name field (an Excel date-serial corruption), and the death file’s birth-year column is corrupt in places (a Ludwig Hofeditz “b. 1896” for 1796). Any match on birth date in the death file needs a name check alongside it. - Pre-1832 Deisel birth rows are partly duplicated, once in archaic spelling (Henricus) and once modernized (Henrikus).
How to re-check this
- The household: in
data/kunze-geburten-original.csvselect rows with a Hofeditz father and a Weller mother (the father appears as Ricus, Henricus and Henrikus); then look up each person indata/kunze-tode-original.csv. The three deaths are in Archion KB 218851 at the images above. - The Kansas exchange: email (30 Oct 2025); the Trendelburg researcher's chart images on the sweep log page; correspondence with a fellow researcher, Aug 2025 to Dec 2025.
- Names DB: Dornette birth row 14243; row 97489 (the withdrawn elimination). The Hofeditz family page covers a different thread, the Hofeditz × Andreas Konze marriages.
Related. The Vanished Karls ledger · All candidate research pages · Negative results audit · Names database · Sweep log (fam-steitz) · Hofeditz × Konze page