Charles Gannsen Research/The Surname Puzzle

The Surname Puzzle

Was Charles born a Gans, a Konze, or under another name?

From the book as built on 19 November 2026. This page is written from it at every build.

The question

Where it stands

The name he used fits two German surnames, Gans and Konze. Konze has more of the evidence, and neither is proven. The leading candidate was born a Hofedietz, and a Konze family possibly took him in.

Gans has the better evidence for the spelling: his own handwriting, above all the 1862 signature. But the spelling a man writes is not always the name he was baptized under. Konze has the better evidence for the place and for what his family said. But other people recorded a spoken name from what they heard, and a pastor who knew Konze families could have spelled it that way.

From the chapter “The Name He Used: Gans, Konze or Another Name”
In the records

His name with a K

In five of the twenty-eight counted records of 1862 to 1900 his name was recorded with a K or a C as its first letter. None of the five is in his own hand. All twenty-eight counted records are on the Name wall.

The counted records of his name with a K or a C as its first letter
YearAs recordedRecordRecorded byName wall
1875KonsenSt. Marcus baptism of Erwin Carl, 3 OctoberPastor Julius HoffmannOn the wall
1890KonzenSt. Marcus death register, 5 May: his daughter Maria Josephine Herr, “geb. Konzen”Register keeper, from the familyOn the wall
1890KonzenSt. Marcus death register, 31 December: his daughter Auguste Somers, “geb. Konzen”Register keeper, from the familyOn the wall
1896ConsonSt. Marcus death register, 19 December: his wife AugustePastor E. H. EiltsOn the wall
1900KoncenGould’s St. Louis directory, 168 Sidney StreetDirectory canvasserOn the wall
From the book

Evidence for each name

This table was in the printed chapter until 28 October 2026. It does not repeat the twenty-eight attestations, which the chapter “The Name He Signed” lists; it shows what each main piece of evidence bears on and how much it weighs.

Evidence for each name
Record and dateFormWho supplied the nameBears onWeight
Enlistment signature, 2 Dec 1862 [Paleographer's letters, 2026]Gannsen, in KurrentOriginalCharles, in his own handG; aStrong for the spellingwritten before any clerk fixed a form
Marriage register, 7 Jan 1866 [MAR66]GonnsonOriginalCharles, spoken; Pastor Wall wrote itG; oModeratehis own voice, another man's ear
Signature on his pension declaration, 15 Jan 1890 [PEN]Gannson, Latin letters with the long sOriginalCharles, in his own handG; aStrong for the spellingbut written after the army's rolls had settled on Gannsen
Signature on a probate petition, 15 Sep 1900 [GUARD]GannsonOriginalCharles, in his own handG; aModeraterepeats his 1890 form
Kreichelt family notices, 1883 and 1894 [SURN]GansenOriginal (print)His wife's familyG; aModeratepeople who heard him for decades
Voter register, c. 1899–1900 [VOTE]GansenOriginalCharles, to the registrarG; aModeratehis own statement late in life
Daughters' deaths, St. Marcus, 1890 [DTH90]Konzen, twiceOriginalThe family, reporting the deathsK; o; the z fits KonzeModerate for Konzethe only z forms
Directory 1874, baptism 1875, directory 1900 [D1874] [BAP75] [D1900]Konsen, KoncenOriginalThe householder, to canvassers; a parent at the font (Pastor Hoffmann wrote it)K; oWeakstrangers’ hearings of what the household said
Wife's death, St. Marcus, Dec 1896 [AUG96]ConsonOriginalProbably Charles; Pastor Eilts wrote itK; oModerate
Konze surname survey, 36 parishes, June 2026 [SWEEP]KonzeDerivative: a survey of the registersNot applicableK; placeModerate for the place; not independent of the choice of Konze
The Deisel Gans family, 1829–1835 [DBAP] [OSB759]GansOriginal register; published family bookNot applicableG; placeAgainst Gansthe family had left for the Weser by 1835
Y-DNA, Big Y-700 [BIGY]NoneTest resultNot applicableNeither nameDoes not decide

The table is from the chapter “The Name He Used: Gans, Konze or Another Name”.

Read on

Three ways further