Have the printed book? Since the book was printed finds any page of a printed copy and lists what has changed in the book since that copy was printed.
This page lists every claim on the site that we have corrected or withdrawn, newest first. Each entry gives the old statement, what we now know, the date of the change and the record that prompted it, with links to the sources. If you cited an earlier version of the site, or an email or a family-tree entry from before a correction, you can find the change here. The rest of the site always shows the current state of the research; this page is its history. Ordinary edits and new findings are on the changelog.
Entries are tagged major when the revision changes a public-facing conclusion, minor when it corrects a transcription, date, or attribution, and withdrawn when a hypothesis was retired without a replacement.
2026
Pension witnesses: Henry Stoll was a shoemaker, not a Battery L soldier; Nolan, Meyer and Hitzenberger corrected.
Henry Stoll was identified as the Swiss butcher and Battery L corporal, and Nolan, Meyer and Hitzenberger were given the wrong wives, families or namesakes.
Stoll’s address reads 2326 S. 3rd St., the shoe shop of Henry Stoll (b. c. 1842, Germany); the Battery L butcher lived elsewhere and is eliminated, so only Derr and Meyer were soldiers of the regiment. Nolan was a Pennsylvania-born watchman (b. 4 July 1853, d. 1914, never married), Meyer’s wife was Mary Pelikan, and A. J. Hitzelberger of Maryland was dead by 1889.
Charles’s first doctor was Dr. Charles Reiss, not Dr. Charles Hess.
The site called him Dr. Charles Hess (from 10 Oct 2026 “Reis (or Hess)”) and said no St. Louis physician of that name could be found.
Both mentions in the pension file (pp. 28 and 30) read Reis. He was Dr. Charles Reiss, physician at 3101 Carondelet Ave., at the end of Charles’s Gate Street block, a former Acting Assistant Surgeon, U.S. Army, who later moved to Washington, Mo., as Charles said. The profile keeps its old address, people/dr-charles-hess.html.
August Kreichelt joined Battery B in January 1864, not October 1861; and neither he nor his father is named at the 1866 wedding.
August was said to have joined Battery B on 1 Oct 1861, to have been at the 1866 wedding where Georg “walked his daughter down the aisle”, and to have sponsored Erwin Carl in 1875.
August served as a private in the 2nd U.S. Reserve Corps (June–Aug 1861), the 15th Missouri Infantry (Sept 1861–May 1862) and Battery B from 21 Jan 1864, thirteen months after Charles; convicted in June 1864 of selling a stolen watch, he escaped from the Rolla post prison and was carried as a deserter. The marriage register names only Herweck, Weber, Goetz and Lehm as witnesses, so the “aisle” claim is withdrawn. His only Gannsen sponsorship is Auguste’s in 1872, and his FamilySearch ID is L5FW-572.
The 1866 sponsors were two married couples; the godmother was Pillmann’s wife, not Wilhelmine Leue.
The 1866 godmother was identified as the widow Wilhelmine Leue née Ebling and the godfather as the unmarried young butcher Frederick W. Pillmann.
The register reads “Friedr. Wm Pillmann, & s. G. Wme geb. Ebeling; & Georg Kreichelt, & s. G. Henriette geb. Weiß”: the godmother was Wilhelmine Pillmann née Ebeling, and the married elder Pillmann was probably Frederick W.’s father. “Amalia Muenke” (1870) is only possibly Maria Emma Mincke, Babette Kreichelt was 14 in Feb 1874, and the 1868 baptism was by Braschler with four sponsors.
Köster letters: corrected readings (address, prices, remittance, dates, image numbers, port).
Several readings of Johannes Köster’s letters were wrong, and some pages said he sailed from Bremerhaven.
His 1862 address was “N. 64. an der 8ten und Moundstraße”; potatoes cost about 1¼ dollars for three Metzen and coffee nearly ½ dollar a pound; the 15 Thaler sent at Christmas 1861 cost him 30 Thaler; the planned departure was “Ende März 63”; the dateline reads “St.L. Mo. 12/8 62.” He sailed from Bremen.
Pension witnesses: dates, addresses and Derr’s birthplace corrected.
Several pages dated the comrade affidavits to 1891, misread Meyer’s and Derr’s addresses, called Derr “likely Saxon”, and read “saloon-keeper” as an 1880 trade.
Meyer swore on 5 May 1890 (aged 43, 1003 Allen Ave.); Derr on 14 May and 29 Sept 1890 (1852 S. 9th St.), born at Heilbronn; Nolan and Niemeier on 7 Oct 1890. The War Department puts the battery at St. Louis, not New Madrid, on 30 Sept and 30 Nov 1863. “Saloon keeper” describes his work since the war; the documented saloon years are 1867–70.
Not at New Madrid during Price’s Raid; the Battery B guidon; the Hunter-Dawson house.
Pages said Charles served a second, eleven-month New Madrid tour and “stayed behind” there during Price’s Raid, that the Battery K flag shown was identical to Battery B’s, and that the Hunter-Dawson house was Pope’s headquarters.
Battery B was at New Madrid once, 5 Dec 1863–24 Apr 1864; in Sept–Oct 1864 Charles was absent on Brig. Gen. John McNeil’s expedition, very probably with the section at Jefferson City. Battery B’s own guidon has not been found, and the Hunter-Dawson headquarters story is a family tradition, not documented.
Place facts, map pins, two candidate details and the 1866 baptism church.
Friedrichsfeld was called a 1755 Huguenot colony west of Trendelburg; several town dates and map pins were wrong; two candidates were marked untraced; and the 1866 baptism was placed in the old frame church.
Friedrichsfeld was founded in 1776 by Protestant settlers from around Limburg and lies east of Trendelburg; Trendelburg’s town-rights date is uncertain and Hofgeismar was a town by 1223. Map pins now follow OpenStreetMap. Karl Konze was confirmed at Deisel in 1853, Heinrich Ludwig Gans of Gieselwerder was buried as an infant in Nov 1835, and the Sept 1866 baptism probably did not take place in the frame church, pulled down that spring.
The firstborn Friedrich Wilhelm (“George”) died on 30 October 1867, not 26 October.
The site gave his death as 26 October 1867 and treated the parents’ notice for their son “George” as conflicting.
He died on 30 October 1867 at 1501 Closey Avenue and was buried on 31 October in the family lot, Block 10 Lot 7, Old St. Marcus; at home he was called George. The 26 October date came from a misread index row for another man on the same register page, so there was no conflict and no unknown son.
Surname canon: the 1867 picnic notice “Charles Gannsen” is admitted (20 attestations / 11 spellings).
The 23 Aug 1867 Westliche Post picnic notice was cited in the life history but not counted in the canon of nineteen attestations.
By Jed’s decision the notice (“bei dem Unternehmer, Charles Gannsen, in Schnerr’s Brauerei”) counts once as a printed attestation, bringing the canon to twenty attestations and eleven spellings (now 24 records, 11 spellings; see surname records).
The “Adam Herweck recruited Charles” tradition is removed; only the documented facts remain.
The site said, as fact or as family tradition, that Adam Herweck recruited Charles into Battery B.
By Jed’s decision the recruiter story is dropped. Herweck and Charles were sworn in at St. Louis on the same day, 2 Dec 1862, both rose to sergeant, Herweck was on recruiting service in December 1863, and he was the first witness at Charles’s wedding on 7 Jan 1866. Story 02 is retitled “Sworn in the same day”.
Herweck letter re-dated to 1863; S.O. 92 received 11 Nov 1865; Roth portrait dated by its mount; Konze women and the Jewish-Gans route settled.
Capt. Sutter’s letter about Herweck was dated 1862 and taken as proof he recruited Charles; location pages still described two New Madrid tours; and the Konze women and a Jewish-Gans reading of the Y-DNA were left open.
The letter is of 9 December 1863, and S.O. 92 reached the regiment on 11 Nov 1865. The portrait’s mount (2006 S. Broadway) dates it c. 1889–1904. Louise Wist and Minna Hansen are proved daughters of J. C. L. Konze and not Charles’s kin by any record; no Jewish Gans household lived at Trendelburg or Deisel in 1823 or 1858, so the Y-DNA is neutral between Gans and Konze. Bertha’s 1894 confirmation is probable, not documented.
Service pages rewritten; CSR keyed to Fold3 image ids; Meyer, Nolan, Andreas Konze and Justus Ernst corrected.
The service pages still told the old two-tour New Madrid story, the CSR transcription had several misreadings, and Meyer, Nolan, Andreas Konze and his son Justus Ernst were misdescribed.
The service pages now give the corrected stations, and every CSR card carries its Fold3 image id; the muster-out reads “Served as Sergt. until Mar 15, 65, when reduced to ranks. Age 28.” (Corrected 17 Nov 2026: this entry first gave the age as 23; two blind reads of the full-resolution image agree on 28.) Meyer was American-born (Nov 1845) and Nolan was a civilian workmate. Andreas Konze left his children between mid-1837 and May 1842, Justus Ernst married at Trendelburg on 21 Nov 1858, and the 1870 sponsor Catharina Albrecht is Martin Albrecht’s daughter.
Surname canon: Charles’s pension signatures read Gannson; three captures admitted (19 attestations / 11 spellings).
The site said he signed his pension papers Gannsen, cited a “Seligmann Ganß” on the 1740 Trendelburg list, and credited the Freundburg = Trendelburg reading to the Trendelburg researcher alone.
All five of his own pension signatures (1890–1898) read Charles Gannson; only the clerks wrote Gannsen. Gannson, the 1868 “Charles Gansen” advertisement and Auguste’s 1896 death notice were admitted, making nineteen attestations. The 1740 list reads Seelmann (Seligmann) Gandt, probably the Seeligmann Ganß of the 1731 list; the Low German “fricative G” argument is plausible but unsourced. Jed first proposed Freundburg = Trendelburg in writing on 23 Mar 2018; the Trendelburg researcher reached it independently in Dec 2025.
The pension-file transcription had misread names, dates, numbers and page mapping.
The transcription misnamed the doctors, witnesses and notary, misdated the affidavits, misread several figures and addresses, and said the file gave a birth date and held Kreichelt affidavits.
The doctors were Emile Seemann, Charles Reiss and Frank W. Wessler; the witnesses included John P. Hurlebaus and John Hitzenberger; the notary was Fred. W. Fout Jr.; all comrade affidavits are of 1890. The 1890 board recorded 129 lb and age “about 64”, and his address was 2408 DeKalb throughout. The file has no Kreichelt affidavit and says nothing about his birth date or birthplace.
Battery B’s stations 1863–65 and Charles’s whereabouts were wrong on the Civil War pages.
The pages put the battery at New Madrid in Sept–Nov 1863 and had Charles detached there for eleven months, “staying behind” during Price’s Raid.
The battery was at St. Louis on 30 Sep and 30 Nov 1863 and reached New Madrid on 5 Dec 1863. In Oct 1864 his card reads “absent on Exped’n under Com’d Brig. Gen. John McNeal”, the march to Jefferson City, very probably with the section that helped defend it (not proved). Four CSR cards were relabeled.
Auguste died in 1896 (not 1897); 1880 census family 34; Helen Fletcher adopted; Bertha’s death place; Lot 8; death-certificate fields.
Auguste’s death year was left in conflict, Helen L. Fletcher was called Louise’s probable daughter, Bertha was said to have died at Warrenton, and Charles Jr. was placed in Lot 8.
Auguste died 19 Dec 1896 and was buried 22 Dec 1896. The 1880 census entry is family 34. Helen was adopted in 1915 and is not a blood descendant; Bertha died at 1524 Wellston Ave., Wellston (cert. 59-031048); all ten family burials are in Lot 7. On Charles’s death certificate, 10619 is the burial permit and “40 years” is his time in St. Louis.
Historical-context and ledger corrections.
Story chapters and context pages had several wrong background facts (fares, pay, population, conscription terms), and the Deisel ledger had two wrong death dates.
The Trendelburg–Bremen fare was 1 Thlr 2½ Sgr; Köster sailed on the Rubens; Trendelburg confirmed at Whitsun; sergeants earned $20 from 1 May 1864; Deisel’s 1,118 is the 1885 count; Hessian service was four active years plus one in reserve; the release is Entlassung aus dem Unterthanenverband. Deisel ledger 420 died 13 Feb 1917 and 459 on 21 Feb 1929; Aderholz 209 and 314 are probably traced at Hörde.
The 718 Gate directory entry is from the 1871 book, not 1870; the 1434 Collins “Johnson Charles” is probably someone else; “Koehler; Hofeditz” is not an alias.
The site dated “Johnson, Charles, conductor, … r. 718 Gate” to 1870, treated an 1870 “Johnson Charles, r. 1434 Collins” as probably him, and called “Koehler; Hofeditz” an alias.
Page 352 is in the 1871 directory, so it places him at 718 Gate in late 1870 or early 1871; the 1870 book does not list him there. The 1434 Collins entry is probably a steamboat mate, Chas. Johnston, enumerated there in July 1870. The Hofeditz in the Köhler file is most probably his uncle by marriage; Köhler has been eliminated since July 2026.
Karl “Jansen” is Karl Person; the pension witness Henry Niemeier was a Hanoverian co-worker; the 1868 naturalization is not Charles’s signature; the service cards are not all “Gannsen”.
Deisel Nro 263 was read as a candidate “Karl Jansen”, Niemeier was taken for a Westphalian sawmill worker, the 1868 naturalization was said to carry Charles’s signature, and every service card was given as “Gannsen”.
“Jansen” is Person: Karl Person died at Kassel on 31 Oct 1898. The witness was Henry D. Niemeier, born about 1837 in Hanover, a street-railway conductor at Charles’s company and his neighbor. Both names in the 1868 naturalization are in the clerk’s hand (Gausen or Gansen), and the service cards carry several forms, the earliest six reading Gaunsen. Carl Wilhelm Henze was born 8 Jan 1835 and Aderholz 5 Jan 1838.
The Working conclusion is reframed: Gans and Konze are equal; Trendelburg is the confirmed birthplace and Deisel the probable last residence; the birth year is uncertain.
Much of the site ranked Konze first, treated Trendelburg and Deisel both as confirmed residences, and used 26 January 1835 as the fixed birth date.
Gans and Konze are equal hypotheses: his own G-initial signatures and the pastors’ -s- spellings point to Gans, the Konze families of the parishes he named point to Konze, and only the German baptism or a Y-DNA test can decide it. Trendelburg is his confirmed birthplace (his signed 1862 statement) and Deisel his probable last residence (1866 marriage record). His birth date is 26 January, probably 1835, but the year is uncertain (c. 1833–1841), so no candidate is eliminated on birth year alone.
The Kreichelt death notices of 1883 and 1894: the spellings had been swapped, and the brother-in-law is Ravotski, not Rabuske.
Taken from FamilySearch Memory comments, the 1883 notice was given as “Ganssen” with a “Rabuske”, the 1894 one as “Gansen”, and neither was counted.
Read in the images: the 1883 notice has “Charles Gansen” and “Herbert Ravotski”; the 1894 notice has “Karl Ganßen”. Both now count in the surname canon as Gansen.
Special Order No. 92 reached the regiment on 11 (not 10) November 1865, and that is not the day Charles rejoined Battery B.
Two pages read the endorsement as “Novbr 10/65” and said Charles returned to Battery B that day.
It reads “Novbr 11/65” and dates the order’s receipt at headquarters. The day he rejoined the battery is not recorded, so that sentence is withdrawn.
Nine statements corrected: the surname-puzzle informant claim, the source of the birth date, the Y-DNA test’s power, Card 2’s heading, a misprinted date, the “L. Carl Konzen” label, Heisebeck’s digitization, the 1896 informant and the naturalization wording.
Pages said every record where Charles was informant sounds like “Konsen”, that the pension file gives his birth date, that a Konze Y-test would be decisive either way, and that the Heisebeck baptisms were not digitized, among other slips.
His own signatures read Gannsen or Gannson; only spoken captures sound like “Konsen”. The full birth date’s only source is St. Marcus burial register #3393. A Konze Y-match would confirm a Konze patriline, but a non-match would not rule Konze out. Heisebeck’s 1830–87 baptisms are on Archion (219175) and were read in June 2026; the 1896 “Conson” entry names no informant; a letter from the Trendelburg researcher is dated 6 May 2026; and the 1868 renunciation of the King of Prussia was standard court wording.
Carl Wilhelm Konze (b. 15 Sep 1831, Trendelburg) did not die on 30 October 1869. The margin note on his baptism is a list of his three marriages.
From April 2026 the remark on his baptism was read as “gestorben am 30ten October 1869”, and he was eliminated as dead at Trendelburg.
Re-read, the remark lists three marriages (“Cop.” = copulirt): 30/10/[5?]9, 4/4/69 and 1/3/85; the “death” joined the first marriage’s day to the second’s year. He lived at Trendelburg to at least 1885 and remains eliminated as Charles because he stayed.
Deisel’s position and parish, and two Civil War orders, were still misstated on several pages.
Pages placed Deisel south or east of Trendelburg inside its parish, and confused the orders that reduced Charles in rank and detached him.
Deisel is its own parish (registers from 1633; KB 218842 is its own baptism book), about 2.3 km NNW of Trendelburg. He was reduced to the ranks on 15 March 1865 by a battery order, Co. O. No. 1; S.O. No. 82 detached him to Rolla, and S.O. No. 92 (4 Nov 1865) relieved him from service at Department Headquarters, signed “by command of” General Pope.
Trendelburg entry 185b is Johann Heinrich Konze, not “Johann Heinrich Berger”.
A page-by-page read on 2 Aug 2026 recorded entry 185b as “Johann Heinrich Berger”, son of Carl Ludwig Berger, and added a note warning future readers not to re-read it as Konze.
He is Johann Heinrich Konze, born 1 March 1837 at Trendelburg Nr. 34, son of Carl Ludwig Konze, Ackerbürger, and Wilhelmine née Albrecht, as the names database had recorded since April 2026. The same household appears six years earlier in the same register, and there is no Berger at Trendelburg at all. He was never a candidate for Charles, so the search result is unchanged; the lesson is that a note closing a question needs the same checking as one opening it.
Friedrichsfeld keeps its own church register. The coverage page said it did not and marked the parish covered.
Search coverage marked Friedrichsfeld Covered, saying it “kept no own register” and that its baptisms fold into Deisel and Trendelburg.
Friedrichsfeld has its own register, Archion 218959 (Kirchenbuch 1830–2011), with baptisms 1830–1868; only the confirmands fold into Deisel and Trendelburg. At the time only Oct 1830–May 1835 had been read, and only for the surname Konze. The rest of the window, June 1835–Feb 1842, was read the same day (research note, 8 Aug 2026); the finding that there is no Konze baptism there in January 1835 stands.
Baptism 108 (Friedrichsfeld, April 1843) does not say its parents married at Trendelburg on 27 February 1848; that is the date the pastor signed the legitimation note.
The line “zu Trendelburg am 27. 2. 1848” under the legitimation note was read as the wedding of Heinrich Hartgen and Elise Schöneberg, and used to argue there were two Heinrich Hartgens.
The only Trendelburg wedding that day belongs to another couple, and Friedrichsfeld records just three weddings in 1848 (January, July, August). The Hartgen × Schöneberg marriage is not found. The two-Hartgens conclusion still stands on baptisms 108 and 109, ten days apart with different mothers.
Trendelburg baptism 270, “Carl Wilhelm August”, died at two months; he is not an open candidate.
He was listed as open, with “remarks: none recorded” and the mother as “Wilhelmine Dorothea”.
He was born 23 Nov 1839 and baptized 1 Dec; the mother is Wilhelmine [Dröbel?], a surname. The remarks cell, never actually looked at before, reads “starb den 23. Januar 1840”. He is eliminated, and a claim that a remarks cell is blank now has to come from seeing it blank.
Deisel Entry 195 is closed: a Köster boy born 21 January 1835 who lived two days. “Justus” was never his name.
The names database held conflicting readings (“possibly Justus”, “child survived”), and the May and June errata said he died unbaptized with no burial.
The name cell reads “Männl: Köster” (sex, no forename), parents Joh. Heinrich Köster and Wilhelmine Hillebrand, Gänsewinkel Nr. 1. He was emergency-baptized on 23 January, died that morning and was buried on 25 January. He is not Charles Gannsen. The burial had been missed because it was filed as “not Konze” before the surname was corrected; the Gänsewinkel house-name link is not affected.
Deisel had eight illegitimate births in 1833–35, four of them boys, not one girl.
A coverage note said 1833–35 held “one illegitimate birth only, female”, and this was used to rule out a surname-less Charles for January 1835.
Read entry by entry, the births are Nros 104 (M), 115 (M), 117, 134, 140, 150 (M), 160a (M) and 229; none falls in January–February 1835, and no child was born at Deisel on 26 January 1835. Seven were given a surname; the eighth died unbaptized. Leaving a child with forenames only begins around 1837, which produced the five surname-less boys of 1836–41 now listed on The Vanished Karls.
The 1948 “Johnson, Katie” burial in Lot 7 is Katherine Misch, not Kate Ruddy.
A July transcription of the lot roll annotated row 9 “Johnson, Katie (Kate Ruddy)”, confusing Charles’s daughter with his daughter-in-law.
Katherine Misch (1875–1948), wife of Charles’s son, died 3 May 1948 and was buried at Old St. Marcus on 6 May. Kate Ruddy, Charles’s daughter Katherine Carolina (1870–1949), died 4 Nov 1949 and is buried at Resurrection Cemetery. The published roster was right; only the annotation was wrong.
Katherine Misch’s undertaker was Thomas Kutis & Son, and her son found her on 3 May 1948, not 4 May.
Her burial card was read as naming “Reinhardt” as undertaker, and Henry was said to have found her on the morning of 4 May.
The death certificate names Thomas Kutis & Son, 2906 Gravois, the firm that also buried her son Fred in 1947 and her husband in 1950. She died at 6:55 a.m. on Monday 3 May; the coroner signed on 4 May. Henry’s letter agrees: she spent Sunday at his house, and he called the next morning.
Carl Wilhelm Henze, promoted as a new candidate on 2 August, had already been ruled out on 21 June 2026: he was born in Trendelburg.
Found on the 1849 Trendelburg confirmation leaf, he was promoted as a likely incomer because no birth record turned up in the Dornette database, with a suggested sound link from Henze to Konzen.
His baptism had been found on 21 June: born 1 January 1835 at Trendelburg Nr. 18, son of Johannes Henze and Wilhelmine Scheele (the confirmation gives 8 January; the baptism is preferred). The same entry had once been misread as “Ganzen”. He is not an incomer, and the project now checks its own names database before promoting a name.
The 1849 Trendelburg confirmation leaf was never missing from the film.
From 20 July the project recorded that Seite 84/85, the first nine boys of the 1849 class, had not been filmed, ranked it the top lead and drafted a letter to the EKKW archive.
Image 2269 is Seite 82/83 (1848) and image 2270 is Seite 84/85 (Pfingsten 1849, entries 1–9), in sequence and legible. The letter was never sent. The nine names hold no Gans, Konze or any variant, so this is now a recorded negative.
Two “he stayed” verdicts named the wrong men, and being “unaccounted” in the Dornette database is normal, not a sign of emigration.
Carl Ludwig Lucas (b. 1835) was matched to an 1862 Trendelburg death and Johann Heinrich Austermühle (b. 1834) to an 1891 Lamerden death, on name and town alone.
Checked by birth date, those deaths belong to a Lucas born 1799 and an Austermühle born 1850, so both verdicts are withdrawn; only Johann Carl August Graff of the nine is accounted for. Of 110 Trendelburg births of 1830–40 in the corpus, 79% have no matching death or marriage, so “vanisher” status is a worklist filter, not evidence.
The 1880 census gives Charles’s age as 39, not 45; it does not confirm an 1835 birth.
The abstract and the Ancestry birth fact said 1835 was “corroborated by the 1880 census (age 45) and the 1900 census (b. Jan 1835)”; the 45 had been calculated from 1835, not read.
Only the St. Marcus burial register lands on 1835, and 26 Jan 1835 is a working anchor until a German baptism is found. The other records disagree: 1880 census age 39 (about 1841), 1900 census Nov 1836, 1862 enlistment age 23 (about 1839), pension declarations 1833–38.
The 1879 “Johnson Charles, baker, rear 1623 Jackson” is a different man.
Withdrawn 31 Oct 2026. The line is now graded probably Charles’s. This entry rested on the baker Charles Gantz, who kept his own addresses from 1882 to 1901, none on Jackson Street. The 1879 directory numbered the Kreichelt rear house 1623 instead of 1621, and the tailor Theodore Siemens, who lived there, moved with the number. See Addresses and occupations.
The entry was a possible match because rear 1623 and Charles’s 1880 address, rear 1621 Jackson, are the same alley building.
The baker is Charles Gantz, a settled St. Louis baker traced at other addresses through 1901, and Charles’s 1880 household has no baker. The 1884 candlemaker at 2409 DeKalb stays probable but unconfirmed. The “1870” directory entry cited here is in fact the 1871 book (see the 9 Oct entry).
Auguste Somers died at 3401 South Second Street, her married home, not at her parents’ 2408 DeKalb.
Her page and life sketch placed her at 2408 DeKalb in 1890.
Her death notice gives the funeral “from the family residence, No. 3401 South Second street”. It does not say whose family, so it may be the Somers family home.
“George Gansen d. Oct 1867” in the lot ledger is the firstborn, Friedrich Wilhelm.
The ledger entry was carried as a loose end, possibly a separate George Gansen.
The burial card reads “Infant Gansen, George,” 31 Oct 1867, 1 yr, Block 10 Lot 7, lot owner Gansen, Charles. He is Friedrich Wilhelm, whose burial opened the family lot.
There are two 1890 “Konzen” records, not one, and Maria Josephine did not die unmarried.
Auguste’s 1890 death record was called the single American “Konzen”, and Maria Josephine was said to have died unmarried at 22.
Maria Josephine married Eduard Herr in 1886, and her own 1890 St. Marcus death entry reads “Josephine Herr geb. Konzen”, cause typhoid, five months before her sister’s. The register gives her birth as 22 Feb 1867; her baptism, 20 Feb 1868, is preferred. (Since 8 Oct 2026 Gans and Konze are weighed equally.)
Auguste Kreichelt was eighteen at her January 1866 wedding, not twenty-six.
Born 12 May 1847 at Clausthal (FS LZKV-9F5), she was eighteen at the wedding, about six on arrival in 1853, and 49 at her death. This replaces the ~1840 birth given in the 17 May entry. That entry cited the marriage register and the 1853 emigration record, so those records still need a re-check against 1847.
The Derr and Meyer pension affidavits are one drafted account signed twice, not two independent memories.
Meyer’s affidavit was said to corroborate Derr’s independently, placing Charles’s deafness and rheumatism at New Madrid.
Both were drafted by the same claim agent, Fred. W. Fout, in near-identical Pension Bureau phrases (“heavy cannonading”) and sworn before the same notary. Henry Niemeier, a civilian who met Charles in 1865, swore the hearing loss was already there, which is the closest the file comes to separate support.
Battery B fought no engagement at New Madrid.
Story chapter 4 called autumn 1863 at New Madrid the combat that deafened Charles, with “Napoleons firing from a river emplacement”.
Dyer credits Battery B with no fight at New Madrid; its first listed combat is Moreau Creek, 7 Oct 1864, and the Official Records show nothing there in autumn 1863. The river-emplacement detail is withdrawn. Years of firing the guns, including salutes, explain his hearing loss better. The battery’s stations were settled later (10 Oct entry).
The smallpox-hospital detail: three overstated claims withdrawn or downgraded.
The page said Curtis issued the order personally, that a shared federal–city hospital on Quarantine Island explained it, and that Charles was probably a smallpox survivor sent as an immune nurse.
Department special orders were the routine way to move enlisted men, so “personally” is withdrawn. The Quarantine Island source describes the site after the city bought it in 1866, so the facility is now a working hypothesis. War Department General Order No. 36 (1862) let hospitals keep convalescent soldiers as nurses, which fits a man sick since December without any smallpox diagnosis.
54th or 64th Illinois: two transcriptions of the same declaration disagreed.
One transcription of Charles’s 1890 declaration read “54th Ill. Inft.”, the others “64th”; the pension-file page now reads 64th. Neither regiment was at Rolla in 1865, and the declaration’s date of July 1862 is impossible because Charles enlisted in December 1862. The declaration is unreliable on detail throughout.
The $100 federal bounty was paid on honorable discharge, not at signing.
Cash in hand at enlistment, an advance, a month’s pay and a small premium, came to about $40. The chapter now says so; its conclusion that enlisting was “not obviously the worse bargain” stands on steady pay, board and clothing instead.
Georg Andreas Kreichelt never served in Battery B; the Battery B service belongs to his son August.
Georg was called a Battery B veteran who served beside Charles at New Madrid and Vicksburg.
Georg served 101 days in Company B, 2nd U.S. Reserve Corps Infantry, 7 May–16 Aug 1861, and has no artillery record. His son August, Auguste’s brother, was the Battery B man. The idea that Henriette Kreichelt’s 1864 intelligence office was a wartime livelihood is withdrawn, since Georg was home from August 1861.
Ancestry, U.S., Civil War Soldier Records and Profiles, record 1163407; U.S., Union Soldiers Compiled Service Records. The index line giving August a Battery B start of 1 Oct 1861 was wrong; he joined on 21 Jan 1864 (see the 10 Oct entry).
Karl Ludwig Hofeditz (b. 1837) and Karl Schildknecht (b. 1840) are open again.
Both were ruled out on family-level remarks: the Hofeditz family “went to Kansas”, and the Schildknechts “emigrated too late, in 1866”.
Karl Ludwig’s own parents and sister stayed and died at Deisel, so the Kansas party was another household; the Kansas note was Jed’s own Ancestry lookup, not the Trendelburg researcher’s research. Schildknecht births and deaths continue at Deisel through the 1860s and later, so there was no 1866 exodus. Both are reopened, neither promoted.
A stale list of the seven children on the Service timeline named three children who never existed.
It listed Carl Heinrich, Emma Rosalia, Catharina Auguste and Charles Frederick, with wrong years.
The seven are Friedrich Wilhelm (1866), Maria Josephine (1868), Friedrike Catharina Carolina Amalia (1870, later Kate Ruddy), Auguste (1872), Louise (1873), Erwin Carl Konsen (1875, later Charles Johnson Jr.) and Bertha (1880).
Old St. Marcus Cemetery is at 6638 Gravois, not 6800.
Two maps placed the cemetery at 6800 Gravois Avenue.
Both now read 6638 Gravois, matching the cemetery page and the city’s record for St. Marcus Commemorative Park.
The Köster scans are public domain, and there are 119 of them, not 121.
The site treated the Gotha scans as restricted to personal use, following the library’s order form, and counted 121 images.
An archivist of the Forschungsbibliothek Gotha wrote on 20 July 2026 that its scans are now public domain and need no permission; the form was out of date. All 119 scans are published, credited to the library as a courtesy. Images 0001–0052 are mostly typed, not Kurrent as first noted.
The 1900 directory lists the household at 168 Sidney as “Koncen Charles” and “Koncen Charles, jr.”
The canon stood at eleven records and nine spellings, 1862–1896.
Koncen made twelve records and ten spellings, 1862–1900 (now 24 records, 11 spellings; see surname records). It sounds the same as Konzen and is the only Konze-root form from a civil source. The same volume has no Charles Johnson on Sidney; Koncen is also an unrelated St. Louis surname, so the match rests on the address, the father-and-son pair and the occupation.
Karl Konze, born at Deisel on 7 June 1839, is not Charles: he died in Hesse in 1920.
After his baptism was read in the image on 2 July (Deisel Taufen KB 218842, S.75, Nro 398), the site briefly called him the strongest candidate yet, overlooking an earlier elimination.
The baptism confirms only his birth. He died on 23 September 1920 at Homberg an der Efze, aged 81, “born at Deisel, Kreis Hofgeismar”; a man who lived and died in Hesse cannot be Charles (d. St. Louis 1903). His elimination removes one man; it does not affect the wider Deisel pool.
The German surname is no longer concluded as Konzen: it is Gans or Konze, and the site calls him Charles Gannsen.
The Claims Dashboard concluded the surname was Konzen, and the site called him “Charles Konzen.”
In the local dialect both families’ names lead to the American forms: Gans gives Gansen / Gannsen, and Konze (K heard as G) gives Gannsen or Konzen. His own 1862 signature, Gannsen, fits both, so the site now uses Charles Gannsen and searches both name pools. Since 8 Oct 2026 Gans and Konze are weighed equally.
Where Charles lived, Deisel and Trendelburg, is Confirmed; the parish of his baptism is a separate Working claim.
“Parish of origin is Trendelburg” and “village of origin is Deisel” were both Working, each resting on a decoded spelling.
Two records in his own words settle residence: the 1862 enlistment says “born in Trennelburg in the State of Kurhessen,” and the 1866 marriage register gives “Deisse, Churhessen” (Deisel). A stated home is not always the parish of baptism, so that question is now its own Working claim, tied to the open search for his baptism.
The 1862 “Farmer” now rests on Charles’s own sworn enlistment, not only the clerk’s copy.
The 1862 “Farmer” was sourced only to the Regimental Descriptive Book card and rated Moderate.
His Volunteer Enlistment, sworn and signed by Charles (“born in Trennelburg … by occupation a Farmer”), is now the lead source, rated High; the Descriptive Book card follows as the clerk’s copy. Whether “Farmer” was his real trade or a default answer is still open.
Charles’s 1862 signature reads Gannsen, not Gönssen.
The first reading of his 1862 signature, on 2 July, was Gönssen, with an umlaut.
A German paleographer reads the initial as “without doubt a G” and the ending as -nssen with the nn written out; the mark over the third letter is a u-bow or a stray stroke, not an umlaut. The signature is recorded as Gannsen (alternative Gunssen), which left the trail at ten records and nine spellings (now 24 records, 11 spellings; see surname records).
Heisebeck and Liebenau baptisms are online after all: Heisebeck gave a new lead, Liebenau is eliminated.
The parish map listed Heisebeck (after 1831) and Liebenau (1835) as not digitized, readable only in Kassel.
Both are on Archion (Heisebeck reg. 219175; Liebenau reg. 219745). Heisebeck entry 76 is Carl Friedrich August, illegitimate, b. 29 Jan 1835, mother Dorothee Henriette Charlotte Wehmann, with an empty remarks column: a lead, not an identification. Liebenau’s 1835 baptisms hold no match.
The 1895 city directory’s “Gannsen” is added to the surname trail.
The trail counted eight spellings in eight records, 1866–1896, and did not count his own form Gannsen inside that window.
Gould’s 1895 directory lists “Gannsen Charles, watchmaker, r. rear 2407 DeKalb,” with a son Charles Jr. at the same address, so the trail rose to nine. It was the first trace of Charles Jr.
Carl Wilhelm Konze (b. 15 Sep 1831) stayed in Trendelburg and is not Charles.
Earlier the same day he was added as a strong lead, because his FamilySearch profile had no sources and he seemed to vanish after baptism.
The FamilySearch profile was simply incomplete: he married, had a son Karl (b. 1857, whose 1882 marriage names him as father) and stayed in Trendelburg. The death date given here, 30 Oct 1869, came from a misread marriage list and was withdrawn on 7 Oct 2026; he married three times and was alive in 1885 (er-2026-10-07).
Andreas Konze (b. 1795) and Anna Christina Konze were brother and sister.
Anna Christina Konze’s father was not securely identified, and Andreas’s father was recorded without dates.
The FamilySearch tree places both, with Ludwig Karl (1804–1862), as children of Johann Friedrich Kontze (1763–1823) and Dorothee Elisabeth Jordan. It also raised Ludwig Karl’s son Carl Wilhelm (b. 1831) as a candidate, set aside the same day (above). The tree is user-built, so key links are checked against the registers.
All 236 Archion citations on the site were checked; none was wrong.
The page and image numbers cited from Archion had never been checked together in one pass.
Every apparent mismatch turned out to be correct, usually because combined registers restart their page numbers in each section. Register 220096 was checked live at eight points. No text changed.
St. Louis Genealogical Society indexes searched; a wider “any Carl” search begun.
Several StLGS indexes had not been searched, and the German search looked only at the Konze name.
The StLGS indexes were negative except one weak hit, “Conson, James & Sophie” (1804–1876 probate index, vol. 1 p. 30). A new search for any boy named Carl or Karl born 1833–1841, of any surname, was opened.
The “Doc O” card has no age or birthplace; those are on the Descriptive Book card.
The page transcribed the card as Company G, age 23, born “Freundburg, Kurhessen.”
It is a Missouri Adjutant General’s abstract card for “Gunnsen, Chas. L. or Gannsen, Chas.”: age blank, Sergeant, Battery B, enlisted 2 Dec 1862, promoted 7 Nov 1863, reduced to the ranks 15 Mar 1865, mustered out 20 Dec 1865. The age and birthplace come from the Regimental Descriptive Book card.
The 26 January 1835 birth date comes from the burial register, not the pension file.
Pages credited the date to his pension affidavit and dated his first pension declaration 16 Jan 1890, age 53, before “Capt. J. J. Setzer.”
The day and month come from the St. Marcus burial register, entry 3393; the pension gives only ages. The declaration is dated 15 January 1890, sworn before clerk Philip H. Zepp, with his age in the mid-50s. A new page, Charles’s birth date across the U.S. records, compares every record.
Deisel had two men named Johann Christoph Konze.
Bürgermeister Christoph Konze (b. 1784) was shown with two wives, Hillebrand and Schrage, having children by both in the same years.
Two 1808 baptisms, two months apart, name different mothers. The Bürgermeister was the husband of Maria Elisabeth Schrage; the husband of Anna Margaretha Hillebrand was another man of the same name.
Two Deisel husbands: Kloppmann, not Heggemann; Sasse, not Paffe.
Charlotte Konze (b. 1814) was said to have married “Adam Heggemann” and Amalie Konze (b. 1818) “Johannes Paffe,” conflicting with their burial entries.
Re-read, the grooms are Adam Kloppmann (1838) and Johannes Sasse (1837). Each woman married once.
The Friedrichsfeld “[?]ard Kontze” colonist never existed, and Heinrich Wilhelm Konze is eliminated.
Candidate lists included a “[?]ard Kontze, Colonist,” Konze women who might be behind that entry, and Heinrich Wilhelm Konze (b. 1832) as untraced.
The entry is Maria Sabina Kontze (b. 10 Jan, d. 18 Feb 1834), daughter of Andreas Kontze and Maria Sophia née Hofeditz, so the colonist and the unread Konze mother disappear. Heinrich Wilhelm died in Germany on 19 Feb 1858. This replaces er-2026-05-31.
There is no St. Marcus membership roll before 1877.
The surname page listed a “St. Marcus pre-1866 membership roll” as a record that might show a former name.
The church’s earliest communicant book is a Register of Communion, 1877–1897 (FHL roll 1503035), a list by date that cannot answer the question. The reference was removed; the Hessian emigration file remains the lead.
Charles’s wife Auguste Kreichelt was born 12 May 1847, not about 1840.
Her birth was estimated as about 1840, making her about 13 at immigration and 56 at death.
The St. Marcus death register gives “born 12 May 1847 at Clausthal,” matching the city death register’s age of 49. She came in 1853 aged about 6.
Several pages that contradicted each other were brought into line.
Pages disagreed on daughter Auguste’s age at death, Bertha’s surname, Charles’s discharge date and rank, and the source of his birth date, and one citation of the Trendelburg researcher carried a future date.
Daughter Auguste died aged 18; “Jansen” is Bertha’s baptism surname, not a married name; service ran 2 Dec 1862–20 Dec 1865, highest rank Sergeant, reduced to Private 15 Mar 1865; the birth date is sourced to the burial register; the citation is 6 May 2026. The enlistment card’s “Company G” is kept as read, noting every later record says Battery B.
Christian Ludwig Kontze and Anne Gertrud Temme stayed in Stammen.
Because neither appeared in the burial index, we assumed they left Stammen after 1835.
The burial register records Anna Gertrude Kontze née Temme, “wife of the day laborer Christian Ludwig Kontze,” Haus Nr. 21, d. 31 Jan 1869, so he was still living there. He died 11 Apr 1883, apparently not at Stammen.
Christian Ludwig Kontze was born in Stammen, not Gottsbüren.
His 1833 marriage says he was born in Gottsbüren, so Gottsbüren carried a possible Konze tie.
His baptism is at Stammen, b. 20 Nov 1806 (KB 220063 img 1988). The family married, baptized twelve children and buried both parents there; the father, Andreas, was a son of Arnold Philipp Konze of Trendelburg. The Gottsbüren claim is refuted.
Four Deisel questions settled from the registers.
The Küster Andreas Kontze I was said to have married “Maria Elisabeth Brandt” and died 2 Mar 1791; Ludwig Konze (b. 1836) was given to the Bürgermeister and a third wife; and two Heinrich × Thiele households were listed.
The Küster married Elisabetha Temme (1739) and Maria Guthmann (1773) and died 21 Mar 1791. Philipp Konze was born 20 Nov 1825. Ludwig’s parents were the younger Joh. Christoph Konze and Maria Drönner. The two Thiele households were one. Heinrich Konze V. married Philippine Charlotte Amalie Schildknecht on 9 May 1880.
Ten readings that disagreed with the FamilySearch tree re-read in the registers.
Our readings included the bride “Maria Brümmer,” the groom “Johannes Paffe,” a birth on 11 Aug 1834, “Brandt” as Konrad Konze’s mother, two Thiele households, and Heinrich Wilhelm Kontze as never married.
The bride is Maria Drönner; the groom is Sasse; the birth is 8 Aug 1834; Brandt was Konrad’s divorced first wife; there was one Thiele household; and Heinrich Wilhelm married Ulrike Melusine Pappenheim at Stammen on 15 Jun 1856. The tree was right on the groom Doenges and on Friedrich Kontze dying at Hümme in 1873, not New York.
Deisel had two adult men named Andreas Konze; the morning’s merge is withdrawn.
The 24 May 1828 burial was assigned to Klaus Andreas Kontze (below).
Klaus Andreas, son of Johann Heinrich Konze, b. 11 Oct 1774, died 20 Feb 1847. The 1828 burial is the other Andreas, husband of Catharina Elisabeth Loßin. The Andreas Kontze × Marie Elisabeth Garland couple was the Stammen swineherd’s family.
Deisel corrections: two Wilhelmines, Konrad’s death month, Klaus Andreas’s children.
One Wilhelmine geb. Konze (b. “20 May 1800”) was thought to have married twice; Konrad Konze died “22 Nov 1841”; Klaus Andreas had a “Catharine 1799” and a son Johannes b. 1810.
There were two Wilhelmines: Klaus Andreas’s daughter (b. 20 Feb 1800) died as Ludwig Köster’s wife about 1843, and the Schildknecht wife is another woman. Konrad died 22 Dec 1841. “Catharine 1799” does not exist, and Johannes was born 26 Oct 1813. (This entry’s merge of the 1828 burial was withdrawn the same evening; see above.)
Three Trendelburg corrections in the earliest generations.
The elder Johann Henrich Kontze was a farmer with a wife née Wilhelm; the Lotz couple had no children; and Andreas Kontze (b. 1787) had four children including an Anna Maria and a Joh. Henrich.
His widow’s 1787 burial names her Anna Margretha née Uffelmann and him a distiller, already dead. The Lotz couple had at least three children. Andreas’s children were Joh. Christoph (1808), Joh. Friedrich (1810) and Johannes (1814). Arnold Philipp Kontze’s baptism, 4 Mar 1708, was also found.
Jungkonze family: five readings corrected; no candidate for Charles.
The readings were “Einrod Jung-Konze,” a birth on 10 Jan 1831, an illegitimate son of April 1827, two sons born about 1833–34, and a godfather “Knecht zu Stammen.”
The name is Eduard (b. 26 Apr 1822); Maria Wilhelmina was born 7 May 1829 and died 10 Jan 1831; the illegitimate son was born 22 May 1825 to Maria Elisabeth Konze; the sons were born 12 Feb 1833 and 18 Jun 1835; and the godfather was a “Weißbindergesell.” The branch has no Charles candidate.
Trendelburg marriages re-read: Johann Friedrich Kontze (b. 1763) was the son of Andreas the town councilor, not the Deisel Küster.
The index was read as “Johan Georg Kontze,” the Lotz marriage dated 1781, and Johann Friedrich Kontze made a son of the Deisel Küster, with a bride “Jonas.”
The index names Johann Henrich Kontze; the Lotz marriage is 17 Feb 1774. Johann Friedrich (b. 11 Dec 1763) married Dorothea Elisabeth Jorden in 1795, and both his marriage and his 1777 confirmation name his father as the councilor Andreas Kontzen of Trendelburg. The 1797 marriage is a Jungconze’s.
Gottsbüren: a claimed Konze tie, not a confirmed Konze village.
Gottsbüren was listed as having no Konze presence, based on its 1830s baptisms.
An 1833 Stammen marriage says Christian Ludwig Kontze was born in Gottsbüren, but Gottsbüren’s own earlier books (KB 219040) hold no Kontze. Two days later his baptism was found at Stammen, refuting the claim (er-2026-06-08).
The 1835 Stammen Kontze baptism is a stillborn boy, not “Rudolph Kontze, b. 20 March.”
Stammen Taufen (reg. 220069) Seite 20 entry 73 was read as “Rudolph Kontze, born 20 March 1835.”
At full zoom it reads “Männlich: — Kontze, todtgeboren”: a stillborn boy with no name, born 14 March 1835 at Haus Nr. 21, son of Christian Ludwig Kontze and Anne Gertrud née Temme. Still not Charles.
The Entry 195 retraction reached our main working file late, so the eliminated candidate kept coming back.
The public pages showed Entry 195 as retracted (er-2026-05-04), but our main research document still called it the “strongest candidate,” and a 4 June check briefly revived it.
The working file now agrees with the site: Entry 195 is a male Köster infant, not Charles. We also retired the inference “no burial found, so he emigrated,” which never followed.
The Friedrichsfeld “[?]ard Kontze, Colonist” could not be found in the register.
The candidate chart listed a fourth Konze father, “[?]ard Kontze, Colonist,” from a January 1835 Friedrichsfeld baptism (“Entry 28,” KB 218959), read uncertainly in April 2026.
A full read of the Friedrichsfeld baptisms for 1832–35 found only the two sons of Andreas Kontze and Maria Sophia née Hofeditz (Heinrich Wilhelm, 1832; August, 1834). On 8 June 2026 “Entry 28” was identified as Maria Sabina Kontze, Andreas’s infant daughter, so the “[?]ard” card is withdrawn.
DNA results added; the deep paternal origin reopened as an open question.
After the 25 May set-aside, the site reported no genetic results at all.
The new DNA page reports the Big Y-700 result (haplogroup I2, I-M223, terminal subclade I-Y38863, formed about 1400 CE) and the autosomal results. The closest Y matches are documented Ashkenazi-Jewish lines, which points to a deep Jewish origin for the male line beneath a documented Hessian Protestant family. This does not settle his surname or home village, and it does not revive the old surname-Gans argument.
New “Interpretive” grade; the “named for the Elector” reading moved into it.
The idea that the firstborn Friedrich Wilhelm (b. 1866) was named after the deposed Elector of Hesse-Kassel was graded Working, as if a record could prove or disprove the parents’ intent.
A fourth grade, Interpretive, now covers readings of motive that fit the evidence but can’t be tested. The Elector reading is graded Interpretive; the plainer reading, that he was named for his godfather Friedrich Wilhelm Pillmann, is given first.
The identity claim split in two: a Confirmed American life and a separate, weaker German identification.
One dashboard row joined the well-documented American chain (the 1862 soldier, the 1875 informant and the 1903 decedent are one man) to the German identification as “Konzen of Trendelburg,” so the strong part lent confidence to the weak part.
The American life is Confirmed; the German identification is a separate Working claim, no stronger than the surname and origin evidence under it. The birth-year row now notes that its four records all have Charles as informant. Since 8 Oct 2026 Gans and Konze are weighed equally, and his German baptism has not been found.
Three pages that had missed earlier fixes were brought into line.
The home-page map still dated Charles’s reduction in rank to November 1865, three family trees gave Bertha’s birth as 20 Dec 1880, and one story cited the 1866 baptism as “#41.”
The reduction is dated 15 March 1865 under Co. O. No. 1 (the November order, S.O. No. 92, relieved him from special service); Bertha’s church date, 25 Dec 1880, is used throughout; the baptism is cited as entry №5201 (running 372).
Profile tables that contradicted their own pages, and some overstated headlines, corrected.
Josephine von Delian’s and Henry Stoll’s fact tables still gave readings their own pages had replaced; an evidence card read the 1890 record as “Konsen”; and several headlines said “confirmation” or “rules out” where the evidence only supports “consistent with.”
Josephine’s table gives the Belgian-Flemish “van Delien” reading; the 1890 record reads Konzen; the sponsor pattern is “support for,” not proof of, his arriving alone (15 sponsors in 17 slots); Erwin Spraul’s 1875 baptism is 3 October (born 27 August). Stoll’s Battery L identification made here was itself withdrawn on 17 Oct 2026 (er-2026-10-17-witnesses).
Dates and ages on the children and Civil War pages made consistent.
Bertha’s birth showed as 20 Dec 1880 (age at death 79), Maria Josephine’s baptism was cited as both 5867 and 5857, and the Rolla posting ran “24 Mar – 4 Nov 1865.”
Bertha: 25 Dec 1880, died aged 78. Maria Josephine’s baptism is entry 5857. Charles was at Rolla 27 March – 1 July 1865, one of two postings outside St. Louis (New Madrid and Rolla). Auguste Kreichelt was born about 1840 at Clausthal, Hanover.
The source viewer still called the retracted Entry 195 the leading hypothesis; summary pages overstated several claims.
The source viewer called Entry 195 “the leading-hypothesis baptism record,” and summary pages called the 1835 birth date “Confirmed” and the Trendelburg reading of “Freundburg” certain.
Entry 195 is shown as retracted (4 May 2026). The 1835 birth date and the Trendelburg reading are graded Working, and the 1859 emigration is cited to the 1900 census, with no passenger list yet found.
Candidate-family headlines toned down to match the evidence beneath them.
The Quentin page called its Cincinnati baker identification “definitive,” the Konze page said “eliminated as biological line” on one emigration-list check, and the Bremen sweep claimed “exhaustively cleared.”
The Quentin identification is strong but Working (Quentin is still ruled out as Charles). The Konze line was eliminated only as a legitimate line, with illegitimate descent and Justus Ernst Konze (b. 1829) left open, and the Bremen result is limited to the names it searched. Since 8 Oct 2026 Gans and Konze are weighed equally.
Stale readings, two confidence labels, a marriage citation and a Civil War date corrected.
Auguste’s page argued from both the “Konsen” and “Konzen” readings of 1890; the 1835 birth and 1859 arrival were badged Confirmed; the 1866 marriage was cited as both No. 676 and #674; and the reduction in rank was dated November 1865.
The 1890 reading is Konzen; the birth and arrival are Working; the marriage is entry No. 676 (FamilySearch image 72); the reduction was 15 March 1865 under Co. O. No. 1. Theodore Gottlob’s two Civil War records are held as possibly two different men.
Birth date and immigration year lowered from Confirmed to Working: every source for them is Charles himself.
The 26 Jan 1835 birth date and the 1859 immigration year were “Confirmed” on some pages and “Working” on others.
Both are Working everywhere. The four birth-date records (1866 marriage, 1880 and 1900 censuses, 1891 pension) and the immigration records all trace to Charles as informant, so they agree without being independent. A German baptism would confirm the date; a passenger list or emigration record would confirm the year.
The Y-DNA / Jewish paternal-line inquiry set aside.
Several pages called the Y-DNA thread the “active pivot” or “leading hypothesis,” while the main pages concluded on a Lutheran Konze family and did not mention DNA; the result was also wrongly described as “Charles’s” test.
The thread was set aside and its pages kept as a closed line of research; the Quentin elimination now rests on four documentary grounds. On 30 May 2026 the paternal-origin question was reopened on a Big Y-700 result (er-2026-05-30-dna-integration); the surname-candidate eliminations here still stand.
Entry 195 retraction carried through, surname count settled at eight, evidence cards toned down.
A dozen pages still gave the retracted Entry 195 reading, “six” and “seven” spelling counts survived, two cards read 1890 as “Konsen,” and Cards 4 and 5 treated the Friedrich Wilhelm naming and the renunciation of the King of Prussia as proof of a Kurhessen origin.
Entry 195 is shown as retracted everywhere; the count read “eight American spellings” (now 24 records, 11 spellings; see surname records); 1890 reads Konzen; Cards 4 and 5 call those details consistent with Kurhessen, not proof. Also fixed: Rolla dates (27 Mar – 1 Jul 1865), arrival year 1859 on the Hebbeler page, and the registers KB 218842 and 218824 (Deisel) and KB 218959 (Friedrichsfeld).
His 1862 height was 5′5″, not 5′10″; sponsor count, enlistment date and family poster corrected.
Seven places gave his 1862 enlistment height as 5′10″, several pages counted “twelve” baptism sponsors, two narratives gave the enlistment as 27 December 1862, and the family poster showed Bertha as 1879–1959.
The 1862 descriptive book gives 5′5″, fair complexion, blue eyes, blond hair, age 23, farmer; 5′10″ is from the 1890 pension declaration and 5′6½″ from the 1890 medical exam. The seven baptisms had 17 sponsor slots filled by 15 people. He enlisted on 2 December 1862; recorded age 23 against a calculated 27 is flagged. Bertha is 1880–1959.
Old spelling counts cleared, and the death date tied to the right source.
Fifteen places still counted six or seven American spellings, and three pages cited the death certificate for 16 December 1903, which in fact gives 17 December.
He died on 16 December 1903 per the St. Marcus burial register (#3393); the death certificate (no. 10619) says 17 December, and he was buried on 19 December. His age is given as 68 (calculated; both records say 69). Deisel is his stated home village, from the 1862 enlistment and 1866 marriage.
Civil War timeline labels made readable in dark mode; search bar moved off the theme button.
In dark mode the year and event labels on the Civil War service timeline showed dark text on a dark background, and the search bar sat on top of the light/dark switch.
The timeline labels now use light coral and cream in dark mode. The search bar now sits at the upper right, just below the site menu.
Light-colored boxes now turn dark in dark mode on every page.
About 400 boxes with built-in cream, gold or pink backgrounds stayed bright in dark mode on the standalone pages, because the dark-mode rules only reached the old tabbed home page.
The rules now apply site-wide, so these boxes switch to the dark card color with light text. Banners that are meant to be dark in both modes are left alone.
“The Konsen Puzzle” became “The Konzen Puzzle”, with the 1890 “geb. Konzen” record as its key record.
The surname page, at germany/konsen-puzzle.html, was built around the 1875 baptism of Erwin Carl Konsen as the only American record of the Hessian -en form.
Once the 1890 death record of Charles’s daughter Auguste was read as “Auguste Somers geb Konzen” (with z), that record became the page’s anchor, and the 1875 Konsen was described as its phonetic s-form sibling. The page now lives at germany/surname-puzzle.html; the old address forwards there. (Since 8 Oct 2026 Gans and Konze are weighed equally.)
An independent site review: surname counts brought into line, a broken link fixed, evidence cards linked, stories split into pages.
After the 1890 re-reading, several main pages still said six or seven American spellings while others said eight, one archive table linked to a page that did not exist, and the evidence-card pages had no links pointing to them.
The count was made consistent at eight spellings (now 24 records, 11 spellings; see surname records). The broken link now points to the marriage evidence card, the evidence cards are linked from the evidence pages, and the long stories page became nine separate story pages. People pages gained a short plain-English opening, and a skip-to-content link and glossary links were added site-wide.
A duplicate scan was replaced by a link to its Fold3 source; the 1868 naturalization image was kept.
Three uploaded files were judged to be duplicates and removed, including the only copy of the 1868 naturalization image.
The naturalization image (the record in which Charles renounces “the King of Prussia”) was restored the same day, and no page lost it. The one-page Civil War scan now points readers to its source, Fold3 image 303326269, from its viewer page; the same scan is in the service record and pension file.
Auguste’s 1890 death record reads “geb Konzen”, with a z, not Konsen.
From 5 May 2026 the record was read as “Auguste Somers geb Konsen”, and the site said Konsen was attested twice, in 1875 and 1890.
A fresh look at the image shows Konzen; z and s are easy to confuse in this German hand. The record became the only American example of the z-form found in the Trendelburg registers from 1773, and the American spellings rose from seven to eight (now 24 records, 11 spellings; see surname records). Konsen (1875) and Konzen (1890) are now treated as two variants of the same name.
“Konsen” with an s is not found in any Hessian parish register.
The site listed Konsen among the Hessian register spellings and said the 1875 baptism “preserves the original Hessian spelling”.
The Hessian registers spell the name Konze, Kontze, Kontzen, Contze, Konzen, always with z, c or tz, and the Trendelburg register itself adds “siehe auch K. Contze, Cortze, Cordes, Contz”. Konsen appears only in American records. It is the American spelling closest to the Hessian forms, not one of them.
“L. Carl Konsen” is a reconstruction, not a name found in any record.
The home and hub pages gave “L. Carl Konsen” as Charles’s birth name, as if a record said so.
No single record carries that name. It was put together from “L.” (1862 enlistment), “Carl” (1866 marriage and the children’s baptisms) and “Konsen” (1875 baptism), and the pages now label it as a reconstruction. The records themselves read “L. Charles Gannsen” (1862) and “Carl Gonnson” (1866).
Charles died on 16 December 1903 and was buried on 19 December.
Several pages, including the abstract, gave 19 December 1903, the burial date, as his date of death.
He died on 16 December 1903 and was buried three days later, on 19 December, at Old Saint Marcus Cemetery (burial No. 3393). The death certificate gives 17 December, a one-day difference noted on the source crosswalk.
Bertha was born in 1880, not 1879.
Some pages gave Bertha’s dates as 1879–1959.
She was born on 25 December 1880 and lived to 78. Charles’s 1898 pension declaration gives 20 December 1880.
Hessian conscription began at age 20, not 18.
Some pages called the missing conscription roll (Stammrolle) Charles’s “1853 record at age 18”.
Liability for service in Hesse began at 20, so a man born in 1835 belonged to the 1855 class. All pages now say so.
Konzen briefly removed from the list of American spellings, then restored.
The methodology and FAQ pages listed Konzen among the American spellings.
It was removed in the morning on the belief that no American record used it. That evening the 1890 death record was read as “geb Konzen”, so Konzen went back on the list.
Candidate families: 13, not 21.
Two pages still spoke of a “21-candidate-family” family tree chart.
The count is 13, as in the abstract and the negative-results list, which names each family and why it was ruled out.
Charles’s wife Auguste Kreichelt was born about 1840 in Clausthal, Hanover.
Three pages said she was born in Hesse-Cassel in 1843.
She was born about 1840 in Clausthal, Kingdom of Hanover; the marriage register says “aus Clausthal, Hannover”.
The 1890 “geb Konzen” quote belongs to daughter Auguste, not to Maria Josephine.
The interactive tree put Auguste’s 1890 death-record quote in the biography of her older sister Maria Josephine.
Maria Josephine’s biography says she died unmarried at 22, and the quote now sits with Auguste (FS L5N2-M8Y).
The 1890 death record was read as “geb. Konsen” (later reversed to Konzen).
Earlier site copy read Auguste Somers’s 1890 death record as “geb. Konzen”.
On 5 May the reading was changed to Konsen, to match the 1875 baptism. On 17 May a third look at the image restored Konzen, which is the current reading; see the 17 May entry.
Surname conclusion of May 2026: Konzen, of the Trendelburg-area Kontze/Konze family.
Until May 2026 the site treated Charles’s German surname as an open question among Konzen, Kontzen, Konze, Konsen and Conzen, with thirteen candidate families.
On the strength of the surname trail, the Trendelburg researcher’s family charts, and a negative search of the nearby Catholic parish, the site concluded the name was Konzen. This has since changed: from 8 Oct 2026 Gans and Konze are weighed equally, and the German baptism has not been found.
Withdrawn: the idea that Charles was baptized Catholic.
One explanation for the missing Lutheran baptism was a baptism in the Catholic parish across the Weser near Wehrden, which served Deisel’s five Catholic households.
The Trendelburg researcher searched that parish’s records and found no matching entry, so the idea was withdrawn. The search then turned to Heisebeck and Schöneberg, then thought undigitized (Heisebeck was later found online; see 21 June 2026).
The 1890 pension witness is named as the clerk wrote it: “John Heitzenberger”.
The site called the witness “John Hitzelberger”, treating a guess from a St. Louis family of that name as fact.
The site now uses the clerk’s spelling, Heitzenberger. A link to the Hitzelberger family was kept only as a working idea and was later dropped: A. J. Hitzelberger was dead by 1889 (see 17 October 2026).
The 1880 census spells the name Gonson, not Gannsen.
A draft summary treated the 1880 census spelling as Gannsen, the same as the 1866 marriage.
The enumerator wrote Gonson, at 2125 Jackson St. The 1866 Gonnson, 1880 Gonson and 1896 Conson are three separate spellings by three different writers.
Withdrawn: “Freundburg, Kurhessen” as a real village.
The birthplace in the marriage register, “Freundburg, Kurhessen”, was searched for as a village of that name.
The Trendelburg researcher showed that “Freundburg” is the clerk’s mishearing of Trendelburg, and confirmed it again on 6 May 2026. The search has centered on the Trendelburg parishes ever since.
How this page is maintained
Errata are added when (a) a public-facing claim on the site is revised, (b) a transcription is corrected, or (c) a hypothesis is withdrawn. Trivial copy edits and stylistic revisions are not tracked here — the Changelog covers those. If you find an unrecorded error, please submit a correction with the page URL and the source for the correction.