The Adoption of Helen Louise Fletcher, Tacoma, 1915–1917
Compiled October 2026. All newspapers quoted are US publications from before 1929 and are in the public domain.
This is a companion study to the page on Charles Gannsen's daughter Louise (Johnson) Fletcher. Helen was Louise's adopted daughter, not a blood descendant of Charles. In line with the project's privacy rule, the study names no one born after 1925 and no living person.
Abstract
Helen Louise Fletcher (Johnson family tree, FamilySearch LY8P-RKV) was not a biological child of William and Louise (Johnson) Fletcher of Tacoma. She was born Frances Elizabeth Barr, probably in November 1909, the daughter of Frank W. Barr and Elizabeth J. (Bowdon) Barr, who later became Mrs. Charles M. Darst. In February 1915 the mother was arrested for shoplifting while addicted to morphine. While in jail she signed her five-year-old daughter over to the Washington Children's Home Society. The Society placed the child with the Fletchers, who adopted her and renamed her Helen Louise. Over the next two years the mother went to court four times to get her back:
- a habeas corpus suit, denied by Judge Ernest M. Card on 23–24 June 1915;
- a motion for a new trial and a notice of appeal to the state supreme court, summer 1915;
- a petition based on the Fletchers' written offer to return the child for $600, denied by Judge Chapman on 16 January 1917;
- a petition to annul the adoption, alleging cruelty, heard in private and denied by Judge Dykeman of the King County (Seattle) Superior Court on 6 March 1917.
After that ruling the Fletchers were "declared to be the legal parents of the child."1 In 1919 Louise Fletcher sued William for divorce and asked for custody of Helen.2
The full study tells the story from 77 newspaper items, 1915–1919, and from the census and marriage indexes. It is kept with the project's files and is not printed here. Louise's life is told in the chapter Louise: Mrs. Foster and Mrs. Fletcher.
Helen's later life, as far as known
- 1920. In the 1920 census Helen L. Fletcher, aged 10, lives in Tacoma in the household of William and Louise Fletcher. Her birthplace is given as Washington, which is probably wrong, and her parents' birthplaces as Missouri, which are the adoptive parents'.
- 9 March 1919. Louise Fletcher filed for divorce from William Fletcher. She alleged that she had done "the lion's share of work on the farm" while he spent the money, and she asked for custody of "the child, Helen Louise Fletcher, whose adoption a couple of years ago caused controversy in court."2 The outcome is not known. William and Louise were again together in 1930 at O'Neal, California, without Helen, who was then about 20.
- Unknown. Helen's marriage, death, and adult names have not yet been found. Search under Fletcher, Barr and Darst.
- The birth mother. An online family tree says that Elizabeth (Bowdon) Barr Darst married a Runyan in Spokane in 1919. This is not verified here. The 1920 census index has an Elizabeth J. Runyan, born in Alabama, at Deer Park, Spokane County.
Adult life (searched 10 Oct 2026)
- Last record: 1930. The 1930 census lists “Helen L. Fletcher”, 20, single, as an inmate of the State School for Girls at Grand Mound, Thurston County, Washington. Both parents are given as born in Missouri, as in 1920. The identification is probable, not proved.
- Louise's death notice names no daughter. Louise J. Fletcher died in St. Louis on 17 February 1947. Her death notice names only her sisters Kate Ruddy and Bertha Polkinghorne and her brother Charles Johnson (St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 18 Feb 1947, p. 21, read in image). So by 1947 Helen was dead, estranged, or not counted as family by the St. Louis relatives.
- No adult record found. Helen's marriage(s), adult surname, death and burial have not been found. These were searched without result:
- the Social Security claims index, the California Death Index and the SSDI, under Fletcher, Barr and Darst and by the birth date 19 Nov 1909;
- the Washington marriage records;
- the 1930 and 1940 censuses;
- Find a Grave and Newspapers.com.
- Other women eliminated.
- Two Washington marriages of a “Helen Fletcher,” in 1928 and 1935, belong to another woman, a Fletcher by marriage from Walla Walla.
- No record links Helen to the surname Beck. The only Washington marriage of a Helen to a Beck in the period (1934) is a different woman.
- Still open. These records have not yet been searched:
- the Washington State Digital Archives indexes;
- the State Training School for Girls case files;
- the 1919 divorce file, which should settle her custody.
Significance for the Johnson and Gannsen family
- Helen was adopted. She is an adopted granddaughter of Charles Johnson Sr. through his daughter Louise (Johnson) Fletcher, not a blood descendant. On FamilySearch her links to William and Louise should be marked "Adoptive."
- Louise had no children of her own. This explains why Louise reported 0 children born in the 1910 census. Elizabeth Goerger's affidavit independently says William Fletcher was "glad they had no children of their own."2322
- New facts about the Fletchers:
- South Tacoma residence, 4837 South M Street (1916);24
- a stay at Harlowton, Montana, c. 1915–16;44
- a peace bond against Louise in Tacoma, issued by former Police Judge Magill;23
- a peace bond against William at Harlowton, for threatening John Helman (October 1915);44
- William's work at the Milwaukee railroad car shops;22
- the 1919 divorce suit.2
- Use of these articles. The newspapers are evidence of the adoption and the litigation. The Pierce County adoption decree itself (1915) and any supreme court file remain to be found. Several statements in the articles are partisan; examples are the cruelty affidavits and Mrs. Darst's claim to be "the daughter of a United States senator." Treat them as claims, not findings.
Notes
- Art. 68. Tacoma Times, 10 Mar 1917, p. 1, col. 1–2, "MOTHER CAN'T SEE HER CHILD, LAW'S DECREE — By Edgar C. Wheeler." https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn88085187/1917-03-10/ed-1/?sp=1 ↩
- Art. 77. Tacoma Daily Ledger, 9 Mar 1919, p. 7, col. 4 (est.), "SHE DID WORK, BUT HUBBY TOOK MONEY." https://www.newspapers.com/image/725167118/ ↩
- Art. 21. Tacoma Times, 25 Jun 1915, p. 1, col. 4, "[Banner:] MRS. DARST WINNING IN FIGHT FOR CHILD — GAINS THREE POINTS." https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn88085187/1915-06-25/ed-1/?sp=1 ↩
- Art. 22. Tacoma Daily News, 25 Jun 1915, p. 1, col. 6 (est.), "[Banner:] Did "Home" Put Darst Baby in Profane Family? — HIT REPUTATION OF BABY'S NEW "PARENTS" — Neighbors Attack Folk Favored by Court. — After Judge Says Mrs. Darst, Mother, Is Unfit, Others Call Fletchers Improper Kind to Have Child.." https://www.newspapers.com/image/732859932/ ; https://www.newspapers.com/image/732860001/ ↩
- Art. 33. Tacoma Times, 28 Aug 1916, p. 1, col. 6–8, "[Banner:] TINY TACOMA GIRL KIDNAPED — MOTHER RUNS AWAY WITH MUCH FOUGHT OVER BABY." https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn88085187/1916-08-28/ed-1/?sp=1 ↩
- Art. 48. Tacoma Times, 16 Feb 1917, p. 3, col. 4–6, "Charge Fletchers Abused Darst Child; Mother Again Asks to Regain Little Girl." https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn88085187/1917-02-16/ed-1/?sp=3 ↩