★ At a Glance
Charles's 1890 pension declaration claims he was injured by heavy lifting at Fort Wyman, Rolla, Missouri while detailed as drill sergeant for the 64th Illinois Infantry in Heavy Artillery tactics. The carded record places Charles at Rolla, Missouri from 27 March through 1 July 1865 (~3 months) under S.O. No. 82, Hd Qrs Dept of the Mo. Charles arrived at Rolla after his ~11-month New Madrid Tour 2 (24 April 1864 – 27 March 1865) ended. Fort Wyman was the main Union fortification at Rolla, so this is consistent with the pension claim's "Fort Wyman" wording — but the literal word "Wyman" does not appear on any muster card. On 1 July 1865 Charles transferred from Rolla to Department HQ St. Louis under S.O. No. 159; he was relieved 4 November 1865 by S.O. No. 92. The unit-being-drilled question is still open; the strongest candidate is the 49th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry (at Rolla 13 March – August 1865), which overlaps Charles's 27 March – 1 July Rolla window almost exactly.
Status as of 6 May 2026
Place: CORROBORATED with caveat. The cards explicitly place Charles at "Rolla, Mo." from 27 March – 1 July 1865 under S.O. No. 82, Hd Qrs Dept of the Mo. Fort Wyman was the main fort at Rolla, so the pension claim's "Fort Wyman" wording is consistent with the carded record. The literal word "Wyman" does NOT appear on any muster card — the previous "first verbatim Wyman hit anywhere" finding was a transcription error and is retracted.
Rolla detachment: 27 March – 1 July 1865 (~3 months), ordered by S.O. No. 82 from the battery's winter quarters at Franklin (the ~11-month “New Madrid Tour 2” once given here was a misreading, corrected 10 Oct 2026).
July–November 1865: Department HQ in St. Louis (NOT Rolla). Special Order No. 159, 1 July 1865, transferred Charles from Rolla to Department Headquarters in St. Louis. He served there until 4 November 1865, when S.O. No. 92 relieved him.
Reduction Sgt → Pvt: 15 March 1865 — twelve days before the Rolla transfer. Charles served the entire Rolla and Dept HQ details as a Private.
Date in pension declaration: still contradicted. Charles's declaration says "July 1862" — before his 2 December 1862 enlistment. The actual carded Rolla service is 27 March – 1 July 1865.
Unit being drilled: still unknown. 49th Wisconsin remains the strongest candidate (Rolla 13 March – August 1865, overlapping Charles's 27 March – 1 July Rolla window almost exactly).
The puzzle
Charles Gannsen's 1890 Declaration for Invalid Pension stakes his right-inguinal-hernia disability claim on a single sentence:
"… in the line of duty at Rolla, in the State of Missouri, on or about [July] 1862, while detailed as drill Sergeant to instruct the 64th Illinois Infantry in the tactics of Heavy Artillery, by heavy lifting in Fort Wyman he was injured on the right side."
The Pension Bureau awarded $12 / month on this claim in November 1891 despite an internal contradiction surfaced by their own due-diligence search: the 30 June 1891 War Department roll-check returned "the name Charles Gannsen has not been found on rolls of any Co. in 64 Ill Vol" (NARA Pension Page 36). Charles was awarded the pension anyway — but the question of who he actually drilled at Fort Wyman has remained open.
What's now confirmed (corrected May 2026 evening)
Place — "Rolla, Mo." (Fort Wyman by default), 27 Mar – 1 Jul 1865 (~3 months)
Verified verbatim across both packets — Fold3 PG 5/6 and NARA PG 11 Cards B/C: "On det. serv. at Rolla Mo. S.O. N° 82 H.Q. Dept of the Mo March 27, 65" — read identically on both scans (7 Oct 2026 image re-read; the earlier "S.O. No. 14, March 24/65" NARA reading and the "G.O." reading are withdrawn). Charles was at Rolla from late March 1865 through 1 July 1865 — about 3 months. Fort Wyman was the main Union fortification at Rolla, so the pension claim's "Fort Wyman" wording is consistent with the cards' "Rolla" reading — but the literal word "Wyman" does not appear on any muster card.
Three governing Special Orders (corrected)
S.O. No. 82, 27 March 1865 — Rolla detachment (Fold3 PG 5/6, NARA PG 11 B/C). NOT S.O. No. 14, NOT 24 March, and a Special (not General) Order — corrected 7 Oct 2026.
S.O. No. 159, 1 July 1865 — transfer from Rolla back to Department HQ in St. Louis (Fold3 PG 4, NARA PG 12 A/B). NOT to Wyman HQ at Rolla; the previous "Wyman Hd Qrs Rolla Mo July 15" reading was a transcription error.
S.O. No. 92, 4 November 1865 — "Relieving Priv. L. C. Gannsen, 2nd Mo. Lt. Art., from duty at Hd Qs Dept of the Mo," by command of Maj. Gen. John Pope, signed J. W. Williams, A.A.G. (Fold3 PG 23/24, NARA PG 04/05). Received at the 2nd Mo. L. Art. headquarters "Novbr 11/65" (re-read in the NARA image 7 Oct 2026; formerly given as "10/65"; this dates the order’s receipt, not Charles’s return). Note that this order relieves Charles from duty at Department HQ in St. Louis (where he had been since 1 July) — not from Rolla, where he had been earlier in the year.
Reduction in rank: 15 March 1865
Verbatim on Fold3 PG 3/4 and NARA PG 12 A/B: "Served as Sgt until Mar 15, 65 when reduced to Ranks Co. O. No. 1." The muster-out card (Fold3 PG 2 / NARA PG 12 C) repeats it: "Served as Sergt until Mar 15, 65 when reduced to rank." The reduction happened on 15 March 1865 under Co[mpany] O[rder] No. 1, a battery-level order. It is not the Department order that detached Charles to Rolla twelve days later (S.O. No. 82, 27 March 1865). (Review of 7 Oct 2026: an earlier version of this log read the authority as "Per [G.O.] No. 82" and concluded that one order covered both actions. The image does not support that, and it is withdrawn.) The "1–4 November 1865" reduction date previously inferred from S.O. No. 92 is wrong; that order described Charles already as "Private L. C. Gannsen" because the reduction had happened seven months earlier. Charles served all of his subsequent 1865 Rolla and Dept HQ St. Louis details as a Private, not a Sergeant.
What remains disputed
Date — pension declaration says July 1862
Charles's 1890 declaration places the injury "on or about July 1862," before his 2 December 1862 enlistment — geographically and chronologically impossible. His own 1898 handwritten address-history letter (Pension Page 28) writes the year as "July 1863" — also problematic (he was at the St. Louis garrison forts then). The actual NARA-documented Rolla service is March – November 1865 — almost certainly the period when the heavy-lifting incident actually occurred. A third version (7 Oct 2026, the note of 7 Oct 2026): the Danville Soldiers’ Home register of 1900 gives the disability (“G.S.W.[?] groin”, abbreviation uncertain) as contracted at “Jefferson City, Mo., 1864”. The War Department’s 1890 reply (“Absent in Reg’l Hosp. since Dec 22/62 … treated at Rolla”) also allows an early Rolla injury in the winter of 1862–63. The dates are best read as a one-to-three-year slip in memory, not as evidence of service before Dec 1862: the Missouri AGO “Old” regiment cards show one enlistment only, 2 Dec 1862.
Unit — the 64th Illinois was nowhere near Rolla
The 64th Illinois ("Yates Sharpshooters") served under Sherman in Tennessee, Georgia, and the Carolinas in 1865 — they marched to the sea, fought at Bentonville, and were discharged in Louisville. Never at Rolla. The Pension Bureau's 30 June 1891 negative reply on the 64th Illinois rolls is therefore correct on its terms — Charles was never attached to that regiment.
Heavy-lifting incident location
Charles's pension declaration locates the injury at Fort Wyman, Rolla. But the comrade affidavits sworn in 1890 (Meyer 5 May; Derr 14 May and 29 Sept) by 1st Sgt. August Derr and Pvt. Christian Meyer — both fellow Battery B veterans — locate the disabilities at New Madrid, Sept–Nov 1863: hearing loss from heavy cannonading, rheumatism from cold and exposure, and the rupture from heavy lifting at the same station. Two contradictory accounts of the same disability cluster, both inside the pension file. The carded muster cards do not adjudicate.
Investigation log
Round 1 6 May 2026 — Initial Fold3-only reading
Working from only the Fold3 download of the M405 carded service records, the spring–April 1865 detached-service muster card (Fold3 PG 11) was read as "Fort Madison Marines, since April 23/65." The destination was interpreted as either the U.S. Marine Hospital in St. Louis, the Marine Barracks at Jefferson Barracks, or possibly Fort Madison, Iowa. Fort Wyman did not appear on this card. Earlier project analysis concluded that the muster cards did not corroborate the pension claim's "Fort Wyman" detail.
Round 2 6 May 2026 (initial reading — partly retracted) — NARA mail-order packet (G11-422819443E) examined
A 13-page NARA mail-order Compiled Service Record packet, ordered in 2018 and previously misfiled in the project as a placeholder PDF, was re-identified and read page-by-page. The NARA scan is dramatically clearer than the Fold3 download on the spring–fall 1865 cards. Three cards resolved more cleanly than in Fold3, but the initial agent-transcription of two of them was wrong — corrected in Round 6 below.
What WAS correctly read in Round 2: NARA PG 04 reproduces Special Order No. 92 in full — 4 November 1865, by command of Maj. Gen. Pope, signed J. W. Williams A.A.G., directing Pvt. L. C. Gannsen to report back to his battery. That reading stands.
Round 3 6 May 2026 — Digit-drop hypothesis: 144th Illinois
First working hypothesis on the unit Charles drilled: a clerk on the 1890 declaration dropped the leading "1" of "144th", leaving "44th", which was then mis-recorded as "64th". The 144th Illinois Volunteer Infantry was a one-year regiment (organized Alton, 21 October 1864; mustered out 14 July 1865) — the right kind of green regiment to need an artillery sergeant's drill instruction.
Free-source check: Frederick Dyer's Compendium and the Illinois GenWeb regimental page agree the 144th was assigned only to "St. Louis District / Alton" on prison-guard duty — never Rolla. The Alton Jaeger Guards reenactor history specifies the regiment was "organized to guard the prisons in Alton and St. Louis." Reece's Report of the Adjutant General of the State of Illinois company-by-company rosters (Companies A–K) examined for any "Rolla" or "Fort Wyman" or "Detached: 2 Mo. Lt. Arty." annotation.
Round 4 6 May 2026 — Free-source unit-history sweep
Broader search: which units WERE at Rolla / Fort Wyman in March – November 1865? Sources consulted: NPS Soldiers and Sailors System battle-units pages; Frederick Dyer's Compendium; Illinois GenWeb regimental pages; FortWiki / hmdb.org Fort Wyman markers; civilwararchive.com Missouri / Indiana / Illinois pages. Candidate Illinois infantry regiments (46th, 64th, 47th, 24th, 17th, 144th, 146th) and cavalry regiments (4th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 17th IL Cav) tested individually. 64th U.S. Colored Infantry tested as the literal-number candidate. 64th Indiana / 64th Iowa tested as state-mis-transcription candidates.
Other candidates eliminated: 46th IL (Cumberland → Texas in 1865), 64th USCI (Vicksburg / Mississippi), 17th IL Cavalry (left Rolla January 1865), 64th IN (never fielded as infantry), 64th IA (no such unit; Iowa fielded only 48 infantry regiments).
Round 5 6 May 2026 — 49th Wisconsin roster check + Battery B location complication
Definitive free-source check: the official Wisconsin Adjutant General's Roster of Wisconsin Volunteers, War of the Rebellion, 1861–1865, Vol. II (Madison: Democrat Printing, 1886), pages 847–867, the 49th Wisconsin section. Searched the full ~8,300 lines of the regimental section for: "Gannsen / Gansen / Gonnson / Gannson"; "drill instructor"; "2d Mo." / "2nd Mo." / "Missouri Light"; "Fort Wyman."
Material complication: NPS battle-unit page UMO0002RAL for the 2nd Missouri Light Artillery places Battery B at Franklin, Missouri from 19 November 1864 through 1 June 1865 — not at Rolla. "Moved to Franklin November 19-21, and duty there till June 1, 1865. Ordered to St. Louis June 1 and equipped as Cavalry. Moved to Omaha, Neb., June 11-20." Franklin is ~60 miles east of Rolla. So Charles was personally detached away from his battery to Rolla — the simple "Battery B was at Rolla and Charles drilled the 49th Wisconsin alongside" picture is wrong. Charles was a singular detached private assigned to drill duty by departmental Special Order, not part of a battery presence at Rolla.
Round 6 6 May 2026 (evening), user re-read of Fold3 cards — Major transcription corrections
The user pointed out that the agent's earlier transcriptions of Fold3 PG 4, 5, 6, and 13 (and the parallel NARA PG 11 / 12 cards) contained multiple errors. A focused re-reading of the original PDFs, cross-comparing both packets, confirmed the user's corrected readings:
- The Rolla Special Order is No. 82, dated 27 March 1865 — not S.O. No. 14 dated 24 March (Fold3 PG 5/6, NARA PG 11 B/C: "On det. serv. at Rolla Mo. S.O. N° 82 H.Q. Dept of the Mo March 27, 65").
- The July Special Order detached Charles to Department HQ in St. Louis, not to "Wyman HQ Rolla." S.O. No. 159 is dated 1 July 1865, not 15 July (Fold3 PG 4, NARA PG 12 A/B: "On Det Serv at Dept Hd Qr St Louis Mo. S.O. No 159 July 1, 65"). The earlier "Wyman" reading was a transcription error; no card contains the word.
- The reduction Sgt → Pvt happened on 15 March 1865, not November 1865, per Co. O. No. 1 (a battery order — separate from the S.O. No. 82 Rolla detachment of 27 March; corrected 7 Oct 2026). Fold3 PG 4 / NARA PG 12 A/B: "Served as Sgt until Mar 15, 65 when reduced to Ranks Co. O. No. 1." Charles served all his subsequent 1865 details as a Private, consistent with S.O. No. 92's reference to him as "Private L. C. Gannsen."
- The promotion to Sergeant date is preserved on Fold3 PG 13, not just NARA — earlier transcription missed this (Fold3 PG 13: "Promoted from Corporal to Sergeant Nov 7, 1863.").
Hypotheses tested — current verdicts
| Candidate | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 49th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry | ★ Strongest candidate | At Rolla 13 March – August 1865 per NPS. Brand-new green 1-year regiment. Right administrative jurisdiction (2nd Sub-District, District of St. Louis, Dept. of Missouri). Co-location with Charles's NARA-documented detachment is exact. But: the regiment's official Wisconsin AG roster (Vol. II, 1886) carries zero mention of Charles, "drill instructor," or "2d Mo. Lt. Arty." Documentary link not yet established. |
| 64th Illinois Infantry ("Yates Sharpshooters") | Eliminated | Under Sherman in Tennessee, Georgia, Carolinas in 1865; never in Missouri. Pension Bureau's 1891 negative roll search is correct on its terms — Charles never attached to this regiment. |
| 144th Illinois Infantry (digit-drop candidate) | Eliminated | Assigned only to St. Louis District / Alton on prison-guard duty per Dyer's Compendium + Illinois GenWeb. Reece's full company-by-company rosters carry zero "Rolla" or "Fort Wyman" annotations. Reenactor history specifies "organized to guard the prisons in Alton and St. Louis." |
| 146th Illinois Infantry (parallel digit-drop) | Eliminated | Garrison duty at Camp Butler with detachments at Brighton, Quincy, Jacksonville — all in-state Illinois. Never went to Missouri. |
| 46th Illinois Infantry (digit-transposition) | Eliminated | Per ILGenWeb regimental page, 1865 movement: Cumberland → Texas. Battles terminate at Ft. Blakely, Alabama (April 1865), then Department of Texas in August. No Missouri assignment in 1865. |
| 64th U.S. Colored Infantry | Eliminated | At Vicksburg, Mississippi until April 1865, then at Davis' Bend and in Department of Mississippi until March 1866. Never operated in Missouri. |
| 17th Illinois Cavalry | Eliminated | Left Rolla January 1865 (two months before Charles's detachment) and only returned at year-end for administrative wind-down — not a drilling presence. |
| 64th Indiana / 64th Iowa (state-confusion candidates) | Eliminated | 64th Indiana never fielded as infantry (planned units consolidated as artillery batteries before mustering); 64th Iowa never existed (Iowa fielded only 48 infantry regiments). |
| Other Illinois infantry (24th, 47th, 17th) | Eliminated | All on Sherman / Mobile / Texas trajectories by 1865. No Rolla hits. |
| Transient regiments cycling through Rolla | Open — would require post returns | Rolla was a major Union supply depot during demobilization. Multiple regiments may have passed through being mustered out or redirected. Not testable from free regimental histories alone. |
| Confabulation (no actual drill detail) | Open | The "drilled the 64th Illinois" narrative could be a 1890 elaboration grafted onto a real but different detached service. The pension award itself stands on the comrade affidavits of Derr and Meyer locating disabilities at New Madrid 1863, not on the drill-instructor narrative. |
Definitive next steps
- Order the manuscript text of Special Orders Nos. 82 (27 Mar 1865), 159 (1 Jul 1865), and 92 (4 Nov 1865), Headquarters, Department of the Missouri — NARA RG 393, Part 1. The orders themselves will name the recipient regiment for Charles's drill detail (likely embedded in the body of S.O. No. 82). Available via NATF Form 86, ~$30 each. The most diagnostic single record possible. Note revised order numbers per the 6 May 2026 user correction.
- Order the post returns of Fort Wyman / District of Rolla, March – early July 1865 — NARA RG 393, Part 1, Entry 6232 (Returns from U.S. Military Posts). These list garrison units month by month and would name the regiments at the post during Charles's narrowed 27 March – early July 1865 Rolla window. Same paid-order path, ~$30.
- Order the post returns of Department HQ, St. Louis, July – November 1865 — same RG 393 series. Charles's NEWLY-IDENTIFIED 1 July – 4 November 1865 posting at Department HQ St. Louis is itself a 4-month detached service for which we have only the cards' summary remarks. The post returns would document daily / weekly assignments at Department HQ during that window, including any drill or instructor detail.
- HathiTrust browse of War of the Rebellion Series I, Vol. XLVIII, Part II (correspondence, March–November 1865, Department of Missouri) — search "Fort Wyman", "District of Rolla", "S.O. 82", "S.O. 159", "S.O. 92" for any published verbatim of the orders. Free.
- Missouri Digital Heritage / Soldiers' Records at sos.mo.gov/mdh — pull Charles Gannsen's Missouri service-record card image directly; check for any "detached" remarks not visible on the Fold3 or NARA scans. Free.
- FamilySearch image-only Missouri muster-and-descriptive rolls for Battery B, 2nd Mo. Lt. Arty., March–November 1865. Free; would be definitive evidence of where the battery and individuals were on a given date.
Sources cited in this log
- NARA mail-order Compiled Service Record packet (G11-422819443E) — 13 pp.
- Fold3 / NARA M405 Compiled Service Records — 25 pp.
- Civil War Pension File (F41-523680269E) — 40 pp., includes the 1890 Declaration for Invalid Pension and the 30 June 1891 War Department roll-search reply.
- NPS Soldiers and Sailors System — 49th Wisconsin Volunteer Infantry
- NPS Soldiers and Sailors System — 2nd Missouri Light Artillery
- Roster of Wisconsin Volunteers, Vol. II (1886) — 49th Wisconsin section, pp. 847–867
- 144th Illinois Infantry Regiment (ILGenWeb)
- 144th Illinois entry, Dyer's Compendium
- Alton Jaeger Guards — 144th Illinois reenactor history
- 46th Illinois Infantry (ILGenWeb)
- Fort Wyman Historical Marker (HMDB)
- Fort Wyman (FortWiki)
- Civil War Archive — Missouri Cavalry, Pt. 2
- Battery B, 2nd Missouri Light Artillery (Wikipedia)