★ At a Glance
ELIMINATED Investigation: 17 October – 15 December 2025"People of Deisel call themselves 'Gänse'" — Joh. Daniel Gans × Karoline Haake of Lippolsberg (Christian, not Jewish). Eliminated on documentary grounds.
Why this matters for finding Charles: Eliminated. The Christian Gans family of Lippolsberg does not produce a candidate matching Charles's timeline. The "Gänse" nickname for Deisel residents is a folk-naming aside, not a surname connection.
📂 Full research log
The Trendelburg researcher's chart — received via email
17. Joh. Daniel Gans × Karoline Haake line — Gans / Lippolsberg, Christian (m. 1829 Deisel)
The Trendelburg researcher's genealogical content
- Johann Daniel Gans b. Lippolsberg 1787, m. 1829 Karoline Haake in Deisel.
- Daughter (1831) and son (1833) born in Deisel; family later returned to Lippoldsberg. Lippoldsberg Gans clan emigrated as the Hellmuth family (the unmarried Gans mother married a Hellmuth in the U.S.).
- Illegitimate Karl Gans b. 1844, mother a Gans, emigrated U.S. 1846 — too young.
- Naturalization analysis: Charles declared origin "Prussia" in 1868 (consistent with Hesse annexed by Prussia 1866).
- Godparent analysis of Charles's St. Louis baptisms: early baptisms used apparent strangers (Jacob Reck & Josephine née von Delian; Friedrich Wilhelm Pillman & Catharina Albrecht); later baptisms used Kreichelt in-laws.
- Erwin Spraul (1875 godparent) was born in Baden — likely a friend, not kin.
The Trendelburg researcher's working theory
"People of Deisel call themselves Gans (= goose) — and Charles calls himself Gans-son, son of Deisel." The surname could be a place-of-origin nickname rather than a true family name, which is why no Gans baptism shows up.
Why this line was rejected
The Lippoldsberg Gans clan resurfaced in the U.S. as Hellmuth, not Gannsen. The 1844 illegitimate Karl Gans is too young. The detailed Haake/Gans Deisel work was the closest fit but produced no specific named match. The godparent strangers (Reck, Pillman, von Delian) never produced a German origin link.