★ At a Glance
ELIMINATED as Charles’s family · Konze surname hypothesis OPEN Active focus Apr 2026 · verdict 12 April 2026The Trendelburg researcher mapped the Joh. Friedrich Kontze line of Trendelburg and Deisel in spring 2026, when it was the project’s leading line for Charles, and noted the family's "unusual case" pattern (handicapped daughter, secret births, an abandoned father, Andreas Konze, who left in 1854 and died in Mainz). On 12 April 2026 he checked his Konze database against the Deisel emigration lists and concluded "Charles is not a legitimate Konze son": only one Konze appears in the relevant list, and it is not Charles. Every Konze man of Charles's generation has since been traced to a life in Germany, including Justus Ernst (b. 1829), who married at Trendelburg in 1858. Charles is therefore not placed in this family. That does not settle his surname: Konze has more of the evidence, but no record yet proves either.
Kontze paternal-line family tree
The reconstructed Kontze line, anchored in Trendelburg burial records and extended into Deisel through the 1830s baptism breakthroughs. This is the German family the Trendelburg researcher mapped while the Konze hypothesis was leading. After the 12 April 2026 verdict, Charles is no longer placed inside this tree as a confirmed biological descendant — but the structure is preserved as the most thoroughly documented context to which the surname KONSEN (preserved in Erwin Carl Konsen's 1875 baptism) points.
Konze / Kontze paternal-line research (Trendelburg / Deisel, Kurhessen)
The reconstructed Konze / Kontze line, anchored in Trendelburg burial records and extended into Deisel through the 1830s baptism breakthroughs. This is the German family the Trendelburg researcher mapped while the Konze hypothesis was leading. After his 12 April 2026 verdict, Charles is no longer placed inside this tree as a confirmed biological descendant — but the structure is preserved here as the most thoroughly documented context to which the surname KONSEN points (in Erwin Carl Konsen's 1875 baptism).
Andreas Kontze's family relationships as recorded on FamilySearch (anchor profile PZF8-X19). Each card links to the live FS profile. The Trendelburg researcher's "Stammtafel Johann Friedrich Kontze" chart and the FS tree agree on Andreas's vital dates (b. 1 Oct 1795 Trendelburg, d. 6 Oct 1854 Mainz).
1st marriage · 23 Mar 1821 Friedrichsfeld · 1 child
2nd marriage · 16 Oct 1827 Friedrichsfeld · 4 children
The Grenadier branch: Trendelburg → Bremen → St. Louis
A second Trendelburg Konze family, separate from the Joh. Friedrich Kontze line above, is now documented across three countries. It descends from Johann Christoph Contze, a grenadier of the Kurhessian Leib-Grenadier-Bataillon (1804–08), later a discharged soldier, invalid and pensioner, who died before May 1839, and his wife Anna Catharina Pfeil (d. 7 Apr 1826). No record connects Charles to this family, and none of its men can be his father. It is recorded here because it shows a Trendelburg Konze household in the emigrant port of Bremen from 1839 and, by strong inference, a St. Louis branch from the 1850s. Charles’s own port and route are unknown, and the 1858 Ariel list has no passenger who could be him.
- Maria Elisabeth (b. 1799) — three illegitimate children 1825–30; married J. H. W. Enders 1831.
- Maria Wilhelmina (b. 1801), Maria Carolina Joannette (b. 1809), Anna Margaretha (b. 1811) — left the parish; whereabouts unknown.
- Johannes (1804–1808).
- Anton Wilhelm Conze (b. 12 Sep 1806) — full sibling of Johann Carl Ludwig (both baptisms read). By strong inference, not proof (no US record names Trendelburg), the St. Louis barber Anton W. Konze (d. 15 Sep 1887): filed his declaration 4 Apr 1856, naturalized 1859; returned from a visit to Europe on the steamer Ariel in October 1858, with no visible companion; married Henriette Louise Brennecke 1861; nine children. Listed as “Konze Wilhelm” among the barbers in the 1865 directory. His first crossing (hypothesis, moderate): the passenger “Willhl. Konze, 38, Kurhessen → St. Louis” on the Ernst Moritz Arndt (Bremerhaven–New Orleans, sworn 30 Nov 1853; read in image) traveled alone and fits his call name, his presence in St. Louis by 1856 and his 1859 naturalization. His stated age is nine years too low. The test is the restricted image of his 1856 declaration.
- Johann Carl Ludwig Konze (b. 21 May 1814 Trendelburg, d. 10 Jul 1869 Woltmershausen) — on the 1839 Hofgeismar list of emigrants to Bremen; married Elise Henriette Eggers (c. 1814–1897; mother geb. Böhms) at Rablinghausen, 3 May 1839; innkeeper at Woltmershausen on the Weser. He never went to America. Their eight children, 1840–1852:
- Marie Christine (b. 22 Jan 1840) — married Gustav Woltmann, a Prussian-born commission merchant (G. Woltman & Co.; d. 1903), at St. Marcus, St. Louis, 8 Aug 1857. She was a minor; her witnesses and guardians were Eduard & Carl F. Eggers, her mother’s family (marriage register read in image). Children Julia (c. 1858–1918, schoolteacher) and Louis (b. c. 1861/62). In 1870 the Woltmanns lived in Ward 4 next door to Louise Wist and Louis Konze. She died 5 Sep 1911 and is buried at Bellefontaine. She is the cluster’s earliest documented St. Louis member. Her identity is confirmed by five agreeing facts. No link to Charles: no Woltmann, Eggers, Wist or Konze among his witnesses, sponsors or addresses; St. Marcus is a shared institution, not a shared event; Johanne Caroline Louise (b. 4 Mar 1841) — proved to be Louise Wist: married D. A. Wist at Holy Ghost, St. Louis, 14 Sep 1865; d. St. Louis 26 Aug 1924, buried Bellefontaine (Missouri death certificate 1924 no. 25013 gives the same birth date); Marie Wilhelmine (b. 1842) — proved to be “Minna”: married F. A. H. Hansen at Holy Ghost 31 May 1870, moved to Sioux City, Iowa, d. there 13 Apr 1917 (Iowa death certificate: father “Louis Johann Konze”; obituary: born Woltmershausen, Bremen). Neither was Charles’s sister, and no record links either to him;
- Marie Luise Henriette (1844), Caroline Friederike (1847) and Elise (1850) — probably died unmarried at Bremen 1918, 1921, 1916; Bertha Antonie (1849) — married J. H. C. Wille 1872, family later in Iowa;
- Johann Carl Ludwig “Louis” (b. 22 Jan 1852) — identified (plausible-strong: exact birth date, father “John”) with Louis Konze, bookkeeper of St. Louis, d. 7 Feb 1920; his death certificate’s “60 years in U.S.” conflicts with the 1867 arrival of “Louis K[a/o]ntze, 15”. The only son, born seventeen years after Charles.
Grades: the 1814 baptism, the 1839 marriage, the 1852 birth, the 1869 and 1897 deaths, Louis’s 1920 death certificate and the 1858, 1860 and 1867 manifests are read in image; the other children are from the Bremen civil-register index. A son of one of the daughters who left the parish, born c. 1835, would be a nephew of Anton and Johann Carl Ludwig — that is a hypothesis with no record behind it. Grades follow the independent verification of 7 Oct 2026. Charted in the family tree; every record is in the names database. Sources: research notes of 7 Oct 2026 (the Bremen family; manifests and St. Louis; the Woltmann marriage and the 1853 passenger); status on Open questions.
📂 Full research log
The Trendelburg researcher's chart — received via email

1. Joh. Friedrich Kontze line — Konze / Kontze / Konsen, Trendelburg & Deisel
The Trendelburg researcher's genealogical content
- Andreas Konze — grandfather a council member (Rathsverwandter) in Trendelburg, mentioned at Andreas's baptism. After his first wife died he married her sister.
- Andreas's second wife bore two children in 1834 (unusual — normal pause is 2 years); their son August was born October 1834 with Andreas himself listed as godfather (highly irregular).
- Andreas's eldest daughter (b. 1822) was handicapped — confirmed at age 15 with poor grades "because of missing skills." She died in Stammen giving birth to an illegitimate child; the child died with her. She had hidden the pregnancy and never named the father.
- Andreas himself left his family secretly in 1854 and was found later in Trendelburg-Friedrichsfeld records as a factory-worker, dying in Mainz in 1854. His Mainz death record (verified on Ancestry) describes him as single with no family.
- Three of Andreas's grandchildren (children of the handicapped daughter) were recorded at baptism as "children of the lost-without-trace Andreas Konze."
- Daughter Maria Caroline Konze (from his second marriage) was godmother to her half-niece in 1850 — so she remained in the area.
- Confirmation records for Andreas's second-marriage children have a gap until 1880, frustrating tracing.
The Trendelburg researcher's working theory
The Trendelburg researcher felt the unusual circumstances of this family — handicapped daughter, secret births, abandoned father — fit Charles's "unusual case" pattern. His hypothesis: Charles may have been an illegitimate son of Andreas Konze, born somewhere outside Deisel, raised briefly in Deisel or Trendelburg, then emigrated.
Why this line is contested
On 12 April 2026 the Trendelburg researcher checked his Konze database against Deisel emigration lists and concluded: "Charles is not a legitimate Konze son." Only one Konze appears in the relevant emigration list and it is not Charles. The line is not closed — the 1875 St. Marcus baptism preserving the surname KONSEN remains unexplained — but Charles is no longer placed inside the Konze tree as a legitimate biological descendant. Every Konze man of Charles’s generation has since been traced in Germany; Justus Ernst Konze (b. 14 November 1829), once the closest-fitting individual, married at Trendelburg on 21 November 1858.
Children added to FamilySearch
Three previously Archion-only children of Andreas + Maria Sophia were added to the FamilySearch tree on 3 May 2026 — Justus Ernst Konze (P87Z-ZDC), Maria Sabina Kontze (P878-ZSG), and August Kontze (P878-BL1, the 2-day emergency baptism) — alongside the previously-existing Heinrich Wilhelm (PZFD-1X4). A research note documenting the Trendelburg researcher's account of Elisa Melusine's disability, Stammen death, and her three "lost-without-trace Andreas Konze" grandchildren has also been attached to her FS profile (PZF6-H42).
Entry 195 (KB 218842, 23 Jan 1835): not a Konze record
The Trendelburg researcher re-read the original Kurrent script and reports that Entry 195 (KB 218842, image 40, January 1835), which the project had been treating as the strongest single-record Konze candidate for Charles's birth registration, is in fact not a Konze record. Per the Trendelburg researcher's email of 4 May 2026: the child's surname was Küster / Kuester (Köster), Tagelöhner (day-laborer); the previously-transcribed "Justus" is actually the German word "männlich" (male) — used when an infant dies before baptism; the boy was born and died three days later without a baptism. The Section 7 Entry 195 ⇄ Entry 261 collision (the Justus Köster confirmation 1849) is also resolved: those two entries belong to different Deisel Köster households. Entry 195 is therefore eliminated as a candidate for Charles. See the corrected Section #6 on Key Evidence, the eliminated banner on Entry 195 source page, and the 4 May 2026 entry on the Trendelburg researcher's correspondence timeline.
Konze daughters who married out
Several Konze-born women appear in the Deisel registers under their married names, providing collateral evidence for the Konze family's residence and reproductive history in Deisel:
Wilhelmine geb. Konze × Ludwig Köster
Ackermann · children baptized ~1828–1831 · daughter Marie b. 1 Nov 1828, d. 1835 (burial entry 155)
Wilhelmine geb. Konze × J.H. Schildknecht
Possible remarriage of the above after Köster's death; child baptized ~1832
Maria Elisabeth geb. Konze × Christian Köster III
Ackermann · son Ludwig b. ~19 Sep 1832, d. 1835 (burial entry 157)
Konrad Konze × Anna Catharina Köster
b. 16 Oct 1780, buried 1841 · son of Andreas Konze × Maria Elisabeth Brandt (entry 358, KB 218851)