A reader who has come this far can fairly ask whether Charles was hiding something: who he was, where he came from, or why he left. He probably was not hiding where he came from: when an occasion called for it he gave his state and his village, and he handed the name he used to his son. Whether that was the name he was born with is still open. The way he left Germany was possibly quiet.
In this chapter
- Did he hide who he was in America?
- Did he leave Germany without permission?
- Did he change his age?
- Did the family forget Germany for ordinary reasons?
- Notes
There are grounds for asking: no record names his parents, no relative of his appears in any German record read for this book, and the age he gave moved by four years and more.1 No release from Hessian allegiance has been found for him, and no letter to or from home is known. Such silence was not unusual: one young man from Waldeck, which bordered Kurhessen, wrote home from Louisville for five years, associated only with men from his own district, and then let even those ties lapse.2
Did he hide who he was in America?
He probably did not hide who he was in America, because a man hiding his identity takes a false name and avoids saying where he came from, and Charles did the opposite. At his enlistment he signed a German name, “Karll Gannsen,” with a middle initial, and named Trendelburg in Kurhessen as his birthplace.3 He married at St. Marcus and had all seven children baptized there.4 He applied for his pension in that name and signed “Gannson” in 1890. In 1900 he signed “G[?]nnson.”5
His homeland is named each time a record asks: Kurhessen in 1862, Churhessen at his marriage in 1866, and Prussia when he became a citizen in 1868.6 Prussia had taken over Kurhessen in 1866, so that was the usual legal form by then. His son Erwin Carl grew up as Charles Jr., so Charles also passed his name on.7
Only his surname drifted, toward Johnson, while his forename stayed Karl, Carl, or Charles (see “The Name He Signed”), which is the pattern of a man fitting in, not of a man disappearing.8 Historians of immigration read a changed name the same way. Like learning English, it was often only a partial change, a fitting to the American style, and those who changed their names did not necessarily leave their own people.9 Charles was Johnson to the clerks and Gannson or Gannsen in his own hand, and the German church buried him, with a notice in the German paper.10
Johannes Köster of Deisel was hiding in St. Louis in the same years as Charles. He headed his letters “Louisville” although he lived in the city, he kept a second household there while writing home to his wife, and he kept away from men from home (see “St. Louis before the War, 1859–1862”).11 Nothing in Charles’s record looks like that. Most of the grounds for doubt are things missing from the record, not things he did.
All of this takes Gannsen as the name he was born with, and no record shows that it was. If he was born under another name, he kept his homeland and his village but not his name, and this answer changes.
Did he leave Germany without permission?
He possibly left Germany without permission, to avoid the army, and kept quiet about it. A young man of his age needed the state’s release to emigrate, and the state did not release a man of military age until his service was settled (see “Kurhessen: Deisel and Trendelburg, c. 1835–1858”). The historian Kurt Günther found that some men left first on a passport and applied for a release later, if at all (see “Leaving Hesse, c. 1858–1859”). The emigration returns show few who left without a release, although they include only the departures the officials knew about.12 Leaving that way would explain why no release has been found, why no family appears, and why he said so little about home.
Against this reading, the release files for his villages do not survive for 1859, the year he possibly left, so their silence proves nothing. Martina Lüdicke, who studied Deisel’s emigrants, names none who left in 1859 or 1860 (see “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” for an estimate of how many boys of these villages went overseas without a trace in the records).13 Many people who left legally also lost contact with home.
If he left in 1859 and was born in 1833–38, he left while liable for service under the 1848 law, and if he was born later, his service was still ahead of him. A man who stayed away was fined, and his property was put under a curator.14 In 1862 he volunteered for another army, in the country he had chosen.
Did he change his age?
The ages he gave disagree, and at his enlistment he possibly made himself younger. In December 1862 he gave twenty-three, which points to about 1839, and the muster-out roll three years later gave twenty-eight, which fits 1837.15 The 1900 census, taken in his lifetime, gives November 1836, and the burial register, from his family after his death, gives 26 January 1835.16 This book ranks November above 26 January, because the census was taken in his lifetime, but nothing yet explains 26 January (see “Where and When He Was Born”). He probably did not know his age to the year, however: his pension declarations of January 1890 and February 1891, thirteen months apart, give fifty-six and fifty-three.17
Did the family forget Germany for ordinary reasons?
Very probably. Ordinary causes explain most of it. His children grew up among their mother’s people, the Kreichelts of Clausthal in Hanover, not among Hessians (see “What His Life Tells Us”).18 Their mother died in 1896 and their father in 1903.19 They were already Johnsons: Bertha was probably confirmed under that name in 1894.20 In 1903 the daughters signed their father’s German notice “geb. Johnson” (née Johnson), and the son signed “Chas. Johnson jun.”21 The four children who survived him were all dead by 1959.22 Within a generation some of the family’s records even gave his country wrongly (see “Where and When He Was Born”).
These answers leave the main question where it was: no record yet names the family Charles was born into. The gaps in his story are gaps in the records, a missing baptism and a missing release. The way he left Germany stays open until the army and emigration files in the Hessian State Archives at Marburg are read. The chapters that follow look for that family. They begin with a table of the papers he swore to or signed and then take up where and when he was born, his name, the boys of his home villages, and his descendants’ DNA.