Notes
65 notes
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Letters to the Heimatverein Deisel asking for help in finding a Konze or Gans male-line descendant for a Y-DNA test, sent 22 Oct 2026, and a Hofedietz male-line volunteer, sent 28 Oct 2026; emails to five Hofeditz men and three family researchers in Germany asking for a Hofeditz male-line volunteer for a Y-DNA test, sent 29 Oct 2026; the author’s email of 8 Nov 2026 to the Heimatverein Deisel, thanking it for finding a Hofeditz man willing to take a Y-DNA test and asking for his father’s and grandfather’s names (project correspondence). [YREC]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Blaine T. Bettinger, The Shared cM Project, version 4.0 (March 2020), averages and ranges of shared centimorgans by relationship, as presented in DNA Painter’s Shared cM Project tool (dnapainter
.com/ , accessed 6 November 2026). Autosomal DNA comes from every ancestor. The figures are those that testers of that relationship share in the Shared cM Project, which gives no figures for a great-great-grandchild. [SCP4]tools/ sharedcmv4 - Blaine T. Bettinger, The Family Tree Guide to DNA Testing and Genetic Genealogy, pp. 53–54. [BETT]
- A father passes his Y chromosome to his son almost unchanged, so the tester’s Y chromosome is, in effect, Charles’s, and the branch it falls on, I-Y38863, is Charles’s branch, if each father named in the records was the father in blood. At the usual rates there is about one chance in twenty that one of the four fathers in the line was not.
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- YFull, YTree v14.07.00 (2 November 2026), independent analysis of the same Big Y data, branch I-Y38863 (I-M223 > … > I-Y11261 > I-Y39743 > I-Y38863; formed about 750 years before 1950, 95% interval 1,150–400; common ancestor about 650 years before 1950, 95% interval 1,100–375; parent branch I-Y39743 formed about 1,750 and common ancestor about 750 years before 1950) (https://
www : accessed 4 November 2026); the larger branch I-Y11261, with its two sub-branches, I-Y39743 and I-Y52940, and its testers’ recorded origins (https://.yfull .com/ tree/ I-Y38863/ www : accessed 12 November 2026); Y-STR review, 6 June 2026. [YFULL].yfull .com/ tree/ I-Y11261/ - FamilyTreeDNA Discover, haplogroup report for I-Y38863 (common ancestor about 1450 CE, 95% interval 1096–1670) and for I-BY2640 (common ancestor about 950 CE, 95% interval 472–1270), public data, https://
discover and https://.familytreedna .com/ y-dna/ I-Y38863/ story discover (accessed 6 November 2026); YFull, YTree v14.07.00 (2 November 2026). [DISCOVER] [YFULL].familytreedna .com/ y-dna/ I-BY2640/ story - FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles; YFull, YTree v14.07.00 (2 November 2026). [BIGY] [YFULL]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- YFull, YTree v14.07.00 (2 November 2026); Shai Carmi, Ken Y. Hui, Ethan Kochav et al., “Sequencing an Ashkenazi Reference Panel Supports Population-Targeted Personal Genomics and Illuminates Jewish and European Origins,” Nature Communications 5 (2014): 4835, https://
doi (a recent Ashkenazi bottleneck of effective size 250–420, 25–32 generations ago, inferred from shared segments, Results and fig. 3c); PubMed Central, PMC4164776 (https://.org/ 10 .1038/ ncomms5835 pmc : accessed 4 November 2026). [YFULL] [CARMI14].ncbi .nlm .nih .gov/ articles/ PMC4164776/ - FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- Each box at the right is one tested man, shown only by the origin he gives for his earliest paternal ancestor. Dates are estimates of when each branch’s common ancestor lived.
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- YFull, YTree v14.07.00 (2 November 2026). [YFULL]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- St. Marcus Evangelical Church, St. Louis: marriage register 1866, p. 135, entry 676/4 (FamilySearch image group number (IGN) 007769184, image 381); baptism registers 1866–81 (FHL film 1503034); burial register, pp. 240–241, no. 3393, 19 Dec 1903; imaged, FamilySearch (https://
www : accessed 12 July 2026); citing “St. Marcus Evangelical Church records, 1847-1981,” microfilm of originals at the Eden Archives in St. Louis, Missouri. [RECS].familysearch .org/ ark:/ 61903/ 3:1:3Q9M-CSMZ-1NJC - FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- Blaine T. Bettinger and Debbie Parker Wayne, Genetic Genealogy in Practice, pp. 13 and 18, p. 32. [BETTWAYNE]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, Best. 18 Nr. 2631. [JEW]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- As in note 28. [AUTO]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). AncestryDNA ethnicity estimate; MyHeritage DNA, Ethnicity Estimate v2.5 (7 Jun 2026). [AUTO]
- As in note 30. [AUTO]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). AncestryDNA ThruLines (28 Jun to 21 Oct 2026); MyHeritage match list and Theory of Family Relativity (7 Jun to 22 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Blaine T. Bettinger and Debbie Parker Wayne, Genetic Genealogy in Practice, pp. 13 and 18, p. 147. [BETTWAYNE]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- As in note 35. [AUTO]
- Patricia Lee Hobbs, “Correlating Documentary and DNA Evidence to Identify an Unknown Ancestor,” in Advanced Genetic Genealogy, p. 252, pp. 252–53. [HOBBS19]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Blaine T. Bettinger and Debbie Parker Wayne, Genetic Genealogy in Practice, pp. 13 and 18, pp. 84 and 87. [BETTWAYNE]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- As in note 40. [AUTO]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). AncestryDNA father’s-side matches with trees in the villages of Kreis Hofgeismar, checked for shared matches among themselves, 28 October 2026. [AUTO]
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Blaine T. Bettinger, The Shared cM Project, version 4.0 (March 2020), averages and ranges of shared centimorgans by relationship, as presented in DNA Painter’s Shared cM Project tool (dnapainter
.com/ , accessed 6 November 2026); Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [SCP4] [AUTO]tools/ sharedcmv4 - Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Matches that share DNA with known Kreichelt, Hahl or Misch cousins are sorted to those lines; the six small matches that share with none of them are shown as open. In all the chart sorts 23 matches: 8 through Kreichelt cousins, 4 through Hahl cousins, 5 through Misch cousins and the 6 open.
- Blaine T. Bettinger, The Family Tree Guide to DNA Testing and Genetic Genealogy, p. 118. [BETT]
- Blaine T. Bettinger, The Shared cM Project, version 4.0 (March 2020), averages and ranges of shared centimorgans by relationship, as presented in DNA Painter’s Shared cM Project tool (dnapainter
.com/ , accessed 6 November 2026). [SCP4]tools/ sharedcmv4 - Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. For the branch I-Y38863 and the mutations found only in Charles’s line. [BIGY]
- Maarten H. D. Larmuseau, Joost Vanoverbeke, Anneleen Van Geystelen, no. 1772; Maarten H. D. Larmuseau, Koen Matthijs and Tom Wenseleers, no. 5; Maarten H. D. Larmuseau, Pieter van den Berg, Sofie Claerhout, no. 23. Studies of Flemish families found about 0.9 percent a generation (95 percent interval 0.41 to 1.75), and a study of a German population 0.94 percent. Across several European and South African populations the rate has stayed near 1 percent. A study looked at 513 pairs of men in Belgium and the Netherlands whose male lines were proved in the registers. It found an unrecorded father in about one or two children in a hundred in each generation. The rate was about four in a hundred among laborers and weavers. The author’s reckoning from the study’s rates, not the study’s own: five links from Ricus to each of the two men. At 1.6 percent a generation the chance of at least one break in ten links is about 15 percent; at the farmers’ 1.1 percent, about 10 percent; at 4.1 percent, about 34 percent. The Hofedietz men were linen weavers. The study is of the Low Countries, not Hesse. The link through Andreas, who was born before his parents married, is less certain than these rates assume, so the true chance of a mismatch is higher. [LARMUSEAU13] [LARMUSEAU16] [LARMUSEAU19]
- Jed Johnson, comp., “What would change the conclusion: criteria fixed in advance, 3 November 2026,” and “Amendment 1 to the preregistration of 3 Nov 2026,” both in the docs folder of “The data behind Charles Gannsen and His Family” (dataset compiled for this book, version of 3 November 2026; see the dataset’s README), written before the results of the lying-in, Ring 1, Marburg, Duisburg and DNA searches it names; their SHA-256 checksums are in CHECKSUMS.sha256. “Amendment 2 to the preregistration of 3 Nov 2026,” dated 11 November 2026 and made before any DNA result, in the docs folder of the same dataset, changes the Big Y rule. [PREREG]
- Jed Johnson, comp., “DNA decision plan, fixed 10 November 2026,” blind setting. [DNAPLAN]
- Letters to the Heimatverein Deisel asking for help in finding a Konze or Gans male-line descendant for a Y-DNA test, sent 22 Oct 2026. The author’s email of 8 Nov 2026 to the Heimatverein Deisel. [YREC]
- Letters to the Heimatverein Deisel asking for help in finding a Konze or Gans male-line descendant for a Y-DNA test, sent 22 Oct 2026; Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). Emails to five Hofeditz men and three family researchers in Germany, sent 29 Oct 2026; the close relative’s AncestryDNA match list searched for the sisters’ families and villages, 29 Oct 2026. [YREC] [AUTO]
- Blaine T. Bettinger, The Shared cM Project, version 4.0 (March 2020), averages and ranges of shared centimorgans by relationship, as presented in DNA Painter’s Shared cM Project tool (dnapainter
.com/ , accessed 6 November 2026); Blaine T. Bettinger, The Family Tree Guide to DNA Testing and Genetic Genealogy, pp. 29–30, 67. On the difference between finding no match and evidence against a hypothesis, see Mills, “QuickLesson 24.” Elizabeth Shown Mills, “QuickLesson 24: Evaluating DNA as Evidence,” Evidence Explained (https://tools/ sharedcmv4 evidenceexplained : accessed 1 November 2026). [SCP4] [BETT] [QL24].com/ content/ quicklesson -24 -evaluating -dna -evidence - European Network of Forensic Science Institutes, p. 17. Pages 7 (section 3.3) and 22. [ENFSI15]
- Jed Johnson, comp., “DNA decision plan, fixed 10 November 2026,” blind setting. [DNAPLAN]
- FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- Letters to the Heimatverein Deisel asking for help in finding a Konze or Gans male-line descendant for a Y-DNA test, sent 22 Oct 2026. Letter to the Heimatverein Deisel asking for a Hofedietz male-line volunteer, sent 28 Oct 2026; the author’s email of 8 Nov 2026 to the Heimatverein Deisel. [YREC]
- Blaine T. Bettinger, The Shared cM Project, version 4.0 (March 2020), averages and ranges of shared centimorgans by relationship, as presented in DNA Painter’s Shared cM Project tool (dnapainter
.com/ , accessed 6 November 2026). [SCP4]tools/ sharedcmv4 - FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [BIGY]
- The full reads were made on 22 and 23 October 2026, with checks of particular matches on 28, 29 and 31 October and of the Hofedietz line on 2 and 3 November.
- Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles: FamilyTreeDNA Family Finder match list and segment export (7 Jun 2026; match list searched again 10 and 18 Oct 2026; close-relative link 18 Oct 2026; compared with a close relative of the tested descendant, 21 Oct 2026). [AUTO]
- Letters to the Heimatverein Deisel asking for help in finding a Konze or Gans male-line descendant for a Y-DNA test, sent 22 Oct 2026. [YREC]
Also on this page
More of the chapter, as printed until 28 October 2026
The tests and the Y result, as printed until 28 October 2026
This passage of the printed chapter “What DNA Can and Cannot Say” was shortened on 28 October 2026 so that family readers can get through Part Four. The text that stood in the book is kept here. No living person who matched the tests is named.
The records reconstruct who Charles was. DNA can test whether the biological line agrees with them, and in the best case it can point to relatives the records have not found. Two kinds of test have been taken. The compiler, a descendant in Charles's direct male line, took a Big Y-700 test at FamilyTreeDNA, which reads the Y chromosome passed from father to son. The compiler's autosomal DNA has also been compared at FamilyTreeDNA, AncestryDNA and MyHeritage, using the companies' standard tests. These are called microarray tests, and they read several hundred thousand points on a person's DNA. [BIGY] [AUTO] This chapter reports what those tests show and what they cannot. No living person who matched the tests is named here.
The I-M223 branch as a whole is old and widespread across Europe. Charles's own small branch is not. On both the FamilyTreeDNA and the YFull trees, the other men on and just above I-Y38863 trace their documented male lines to east-central Europe, naming Poland, Russia, Lithuania, Belarus and neighboring lands. Their families appear to be Ashkenazi Jewish, by their documented ancestors, surnames and given names. That description is drawn from what the testers record about their own ancestors, not from a label assigned by the testing company. [BIGY] [YFULL] Four men match Charles's line at the Big Y level. Three name an earliest paternal ancestor in a Jewish family of Poland, Russia or Lithuania, and the fourth lists only Belarusian and Polish Jewish family names. [BIGY] (This is the match list as it was read again on 23 October 2026, unchanged.)
The autosomal results, as printed until 28 October 2026
This passage of the printed chapter “What DNA Can and Cannot Say” was shortened on 28 October 2026 so that family readers can get through Part Four. The text that stood in the book is kept here. No living person who matched the tests is named.
AncestryDNA and MyHeritage each estimate the regional makeup of a descendant's DNA. The two companies draw their regions differently but agree on the main point. Roughly half of the tested descendant's DNA is assigned to Germanic and Dutch regions, with most of the rest British and Irish, from other lines of the family. [AUTO] This adds almost nothing about Charles. A descendant several generations down carries only a small fraction of his DNA, an eighth or less. The Germanic share also includes the DNA of Auguste Kreichelt, who was German too, and of every other German ancestor in the tree. The test cannot isolate Charles's contribution. And the regions are broad. "Southern Germanic Europe" or "Germanic" includes Hesse but cannot tell it from Bavaria, the Rhineland or Saxony. [AUTO] Neither company reports a European Jewish region, as would be expected. The Y result points to a Jewish ancestor of the Middle Ages, whose share of anyone's autosomal DNA today is far too small to measure. The estimates neither confirm nor contradict it. [AUTO]
The matches have been searched for both surnames proposed for Charles, Konze and Gans, in all their spellings, and for other surnames: Gannsen; Kreichelt, his wife's family; and Grandjot and Herwig, two families of the Trendelburg area possibly linked to the Konzes by marriage. The matches' trees have been searched for births at Trendelburg, Deisel and Hofgeismar. The few Gans matches are small and lead to Dutch, Scandinavian, British or Rhineland families, none to Kreis Hofgeismar. At FamilyTreeDNA, which since October 2026 sorts matches by parent, none of the six Gans matches falls on the father's side. On Ancestry, no father's-side match names Konze, Gans, Trendelburg, Deisel or Hofgeismar, and none of the father's-side trees opened shows a Hessian place. The handful of trees showing a birth at Trendelburg or Deisel appear, from the relatives they share with the family, to be related through its other lines. No match sharing a meaningful amount of DNA has an independently documented line from any of these families or places. [AUTO]
In July 2026 two small matches turned up that share one large German tree including a Kontze. They were examined and set aside. A few matches are named Kunze, a similar surname, and share 10 to 17 centimorgans (the unit of shared DNA, explained below). They lead to Baden, American or unplaced trees, none to Kurhessen. [AUTO] (The two Kontze-tree matches shared little DNA, and none of the relatives they shared with the family belonged to the Deisel–Langenthal group described above. That tree's principal family name belongs to the Gütersloh district of Westphalia, some fifty miles (80 km) west-northwest of Trendelburg.) In October 2026 the father's-side matches were also searched for the surnames of every other family proposed for Charles. No family had two or more matches of its own, and the single small match with a Deisel tree descends from several village families at once. [AUTO]
AncestryDNA's ThruLines proposes ancestors from other members' trees. It proposes no parent for Charles. The only matches it routes through him descend from his own son and are known cousins. MyHeritage's tree-based theories of relationship have proposed none at all. These tools work by finding a path through other people's trees to a shared ancestor. The ancestor needed here, Charles's father, is in no tree. [AUTO]
Close relatives on both sides of the tested descendant's family have also tested at AncestryDNA, so Ancestry can sort every match to the father's side or the mother's. Matches to known cousins show which of the father's grandparents a match descends through. Shared DNA is measured in centimorgans, and close cousins share hundreds or thousands. On the side that leads to Charles, no group of matches sharing 20 centimorgans or more points to any family not already known.
One small group of six matches, sharing about 9 to 20 centimorgans, sits on the side of Charles's grandson Frederick (Fred Johnson, the son of Charles Jr. and Katherine Misch, whose four grandparents were Charles, Auguste, Michael Misch and Christina Hahl). It matches no known relative of Auguste Kreichelt or of Christina Hahl, the mother of Charles's daughter-in-law Katherine Misch. It could descend from Charles's family or from that of Katherine's father, Michael Misch. In October 2026 Ancestry's ThruLines began to route five small matches, of about 9 to 33 centimorgans, through Michael Misch's father, by way of three of Michael Misch's brothers and sisters. They are the first tested cousins on the Misch side. None of the six in the group appears among these Misch cousins' shared matches. That leans slightly toward Charles's family, but small matches are often missing from those lists. Some of the new Misch-side matches also share DNA with known Hahl cousins, so they must be sorted themselves before they can settle the question. [AUTO]
First, several small matches are to people whose ancestral surnames are distinctly Ashkenazi, and many of them overlap one block on chromosome 17. They are single shared stretches of DNA (segments) of about 9 to 20 centimorgans. These matches are probably noise, of a kind common in any population. Small segments shared with many members of a population are common, most of all in stretches of the genome where matches pile up because of shared ancient ancestry rather than a recent common ancestor. These matches are not a second view of the Y result, and they are not evidence for or against it. The Y result concerns a medieval ancestor too remote to leave detectable autosomal DNA. [AUTO]
Second, the Deisel–Langenthal group described above lies in the same stretch of chromosome 17 as these small Ashkenazi-surname matches. A comparison with the tested descendant's father at FamilyTreeDNA in October 2026 showed that the Ashkenazi-surname matches in that stretch are on the father's side as well. Every one sharing 10 centimorgans or more there also matches him. That makes the stretch look like a pile-up region, where small matches are common and say little, and it is why the group counts as one link and deserves less weight than its size suggests. If it proves to descend from Charles's own family, it could lead to the first German relative found. If it descends from the Misch or Hahl families, it would add to what is known of them instead. [AUTO]
Supplements
Records, images and data on this website that go with this chapter.



