The "immigrated alone" hypothesis on this site rests on a structural claim: across seven baptisms over fifteen years, not a single named sponsor is a documented blood relative of Charles. This page turns that narrative into an auditable artifact — one row per baptism × sponsor, with the kin link to Auguste named explicitly and the absence of a Charles-side link logged in every row.
Legend
Per-baptism sponsor audit
| Baptism | Surname (parish clerk) |
Sponsor | Relationship to Auguste | Relationship to Charles | FS PID |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 · Friedrich Wilhelm 2 Sep 1866 Pastor Wall |
Gonnson | Friedr. Wm Pillmann (the elder) | St. Louis parish circle — written “Friedr. Wm Pillmann, & s. G. [seine Gattin] Wme geb. Ebeling”: a married man, so probably the father of Frederick W. Pillmann (b. 1846/47, married 1870), not Frederick himself; an 1858 deed shows a Friedrich and Wilhelmine Pillmann in St. Louis | — none documented — | L17N-WPJ (probable) |
| Wilhelmine Pillmann, née Ebeling | St. Louis parish circle — wife of the sponsor above (“s. G. Wme geb. Ebeling”); the 1866 sponsors were two married couples. An earlier identification with Wilhelmine Leue née Ebling (FS M6G9-FJR) is probably wrong. | — none documented — | — | ||
| Georg Andreas Kreichelt | Father — Auguste's father; 1861 Reserve Corps veteran (Charles's father-in-law; not a Battery B comrade — corrected Jul 2026) | — none documented — | LZXC-NH9 | ||
| Louise Henriette (Weiss) Kreichelt | Mother — Auguste's mother; Charles's mother-in-law | — none documented — | LZXC-NG7 | ||
| 2 · Maria Josephine 7 Jun 1868 Pastor Braschler |
Gonnson | Jacob Reck | St. Louis parish circle — Pfalz-born 1837 (Freinsheim, Bavaria), arrived NY Nov 1865; parish-circle bond formed in St. Louis, not a pre-emigration tie; buried Old St. Marcus alongside Charles | — none documented — | KLPB-52X |
| Josephine née von Delien | In-law (Reck side) — Jacob Reck's first wife; the child's middle name Josephine is her direct namesake | — none documented — | open | ||
| Maria Agnes Götz | St. Louis parish circle — Pälzer / Hessen-Darmstadt / Baden Götz network; possibly the “Anna Goetz” who witnessed the 1866 marriage. | — none documented — | open | ||
| Georg Kreichelt | Father — the only Kreichelt at this baptism; second of three Gannsen sponsorships | — none documented — | LZXC-NH9 | ||
| 3 · Katherine Carolina baptized Friedrike Catharina Carolina Amalia 1870 Pastor Braschler |
Gansen | Friedrich Pillmann | In-law (affinal) — newly married to Fredericka Albrecht (Catharina Albrecht's sister) 5 Apr 1870, seven weeks before this baptism; written “Friedrich Billmann”; probably the son of the 1866 sponsor Friedr. Wm Pillmann (his father cannot be excluded) | — none documented — | L17N-8Q6 |
| Catharina Albrecht | Affianced in-law — engaged to Auguste's brother Carl Kreichelt; would marry him 5 Mar 1871; the child's middle name Catharina is her direct namesake | — none documented — | L5FV-3Z1 | ||
| Carl Kreichelt | Brother — Auguste's brother (Clausthal-born 1846) | — none documented — | L5FW-5LD | ||
| Amalia Muenke | Possibly sister-in-law — possibly Maria Emma Mincke, wife of Auguste's brother August Kreichelt, but the pastor gives no married name or “geb.” (by 1870 she had been married at least a year), so more probably a Mincke relative; the child's middle name Amalia matches. The register adds “letzt[ere] abwes[end]”: she was absent and stood by proxy (read in the image). | — none documented — | L52N-1PL | ||
| 4 · Auguste 23 Jun 1872 Pastor Braschler |
Gonsen | Georg Kreichelt | Father — third Gannsen sponsorship; the most frequent of four recurring sponsors across the seven-baptism series | — none documented — | LZXC-NH9 |
| Louise Kreichelt (= Henriette) | Mother — Louise Friederike Henriette Weiss; recorded here under her formal first name "Louise" | — none documented — | LZXC-NG7 | ||
| August Kreichelt | Brother — Auguste's eldest brother; Battery B veteran (served alongside Charles); the child's first name Auguste is also a feminine echo of his "August" | — none documented — | L5FW-572 | ||
| 5 · Louise 1873 (bapt. 22 Feb 1874; p. 402, No. 8178/41) Pastor Braschler |
Jansen father written “Charles Jansen” |
Louise Henriette Kreichelt | Mother — recorded here under her full formal name "Louise Henriette née Weis"; the child's name Louise is a direct namesake | — none documented — | LZXC-NG7 |
| Barbara ("Babette") Kreichelt | Sister — Auguste's youngest sister Bertha Barbara (b. 28 Nov 1859), then age 14; would sponsor again 1881 | — none documented — | L5FH-BRP | ||
| 6 · Erwin Carl Konsen 27 Aug 1875 Pastor Hoffmann |
Konsen | Erwin Spraul | St. Louis parish circle — Baden-born ~1848; later Superintendent of the Anheuser-Busch Brewing Association; Soulard neighbor; the child's first name Erwin is a direct namesake | — none documented — | KLP1-N62 |
| "The father of the child" | Charles himself, listed by the parish clerk as a co-sponsor. An irregular self-sponsorship that doesn't establish a kin link in either direction. The two competing readings are cataloged on the child's profile page; neither posits a Charles-side blood relative. | — | |||
| 7 · Bertha 4 Sep 1881 Pastor Nollau |
Jansen father written “Karl Jansen” |
Bertha Barbara "Babette" Kreichelt | Sister — Auguste's youngest sister, then age 20; the child's name Bertha is a direct namesake; sole sponsor | — none documented — | L5FH-BRP |
Distribution by category
| Category | Sponsorship slots | Distinct individuals | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Auguste-side blood | 10 of 20 | 5 (Georg ×3, Henriette/Louise ×3, Carl, August, Babette ×2) | Parents (Georg, Henriette), siblings (Carl, August, Babette) |
| Auguste-side affinal | 4 of 20 | 4 (Friedrich Billmann/Pillmann 1870, Catharina Albrecht, Amalia Muenke [possibly August Kreichelt’s wife], Josephine von Delien) | In-laws or fiancés of Auguste's siblings; Reck's wife |
| St. Louis parish circle | 5 of 20 | 5 (Friedr. Wm Pillmann and his wife Wilhelmine née Ebeling, 1866; Jacob Reck; Maria Agnes Götz; Erwin Spraul) | Lutheran neighbors and parish-circle associates documented in St. Louis, not in Hesse |
| Father of the child (self) | 1 of 20 | — | Erwin Carl Konsen 1875 (irregular) |
| Charles-side blood | 0 of 20 | 0 | None documented across any of the seven baptisms 1866–1881 |
Wedding witnesses — the 1866 marriage
The same pattern holds at the wedding. The St. Marcus marriage register (7 January 1866, entry no. 676; Pastor G. W. Wall) names four witnesses (Zeugen): Adam Herweck, Philipp Weber, Anna Goetz, and Sophie Lehm. None of the four is documented as kin of either party; Auguste's father Georg and brother August Kreichelt are not named in the entry. Charles's side is represented not by a relative but by Adam Herweck, his Battery B comrade, sworn in on the same day, 2 Dec 1862 (b. 16 July 1831, Lampertheim, Hessen; FS K4DW-PXM) — a fellow soldier, not kin. Weber, Goetz, and Lehm are St. Louis parish-circle names with no documented blood tie to Charles. So across the wedding and the seven baptisms, not one of the ~two dozen named sponsors and witnesses is a documented Charles-side relative.
The next generation: Louise as godmother (1897, 1903)
Read in the register images: Charles’s daughter Louise, as “Louise Foster”, was the sole sponsor of her brother Charles Jr.’s first son, Wilhelm Thomas Johnson (born 23 Dec 1896, baptized 31 Jan 1897; St. Marcus p. 210, No. 15064), and co-sponsor with Henry Misch of his second, Henry Charles Johnson (born 3 Apr, baptized 30 Apr 1903; p. 306, No. 16385). That is two of the three sons, not all three: the third, Frederick Charles (1905), had Frederick W. Gottlob and an unidentified “Louise Beck”, who is not Louise. Charles himself appears in neither entry.
Counterarguments considered
Confidence status
The structural "immigrated alone" reading is held in the project's Working state per the source-rating taxonomy: the sponsorship pattern is convergent indirect evidence rather than a single dispositive record. Promotion to Confirmed would require a positive identification of Charles's German baptismal entry, his 1859 passenger manifest, or a Hessian Auswanderer-Beleg / Stammrolle entry — any of which would directly establish whether Charles had surviving kin in Hesse and whether any of them ever joined him in America. Those four primary-source gaps are cataloged on Open Questions.
That no named sponsor or wedding witness is a documented Charles-side blood relative: High — a documented absence across ~24 sponsor/witness slots, seven baptisms plus the 1866 marriage, 1866–1881, under five officiating pastors, every identified name tracing to Auguste's kin or the St. Louis / Battery B circle.
That this proves Charles had no kin who ever joined him in America: Moderate — Working — convergent indirect / negative evidence, not a single dispositive record; a German baptism, the 1859 manifest, or a Hessian Beleg could still surface a relative.
How this table was built
The sponsor identifications come from the seven children's individual profile pages (children/), which in turn cite the St. Marcus baptism register entries by page and entry number plus the FamilySearch profile for each sponsor. Each kin-relationship-to-Auguste claim traces to a documented FamilySearch tree link or to a St. Louis civil-record citation; each absence-of-Charles-side-link claim is the absence of any such trace across the project's research sessions. Counterargument framing follows Mills, Evidence Explained, §1.31 on the structure of negative-evidence arguments.
Last updated . Changes to this page are recorded in the site's changelog.