← Charles Gannsen Research  /  Birth Date Across the U.S. Records

Charles's Birth Date Across the U.S. Records

Eleven American records, and almost as many different birth dates — from 1833 to 1841. Each one sourced, cross-checked against the original scans, and ranked by genealogical confidence.

A single, framing caveat governs this whole page: no independent birth or baptism record for Charles has ever been found — the German parish baptism remains the project's most-wanted document. Every figure below traces back to Charles's own testimony or, at his death, to his family's. None is a true original, firsthand record of the birth event. They are best read together as a cluster, not as competing facts.

10U.S. records
1833–1841spread of stated years
1record with a full date
26 Janthe only specific date; the year is uncertain

Birth date — year uncertain (c. 1833–41): 26 January 1835 by his burial register, November 1836 by the 1900 census. The full date comes solely from the posthumous St. Marcus burial register #3393, supplied by the family; the age at death was computed from it. His own sworn ages range from about 1833 to 1841, and the earliest (age 23 in December 1862) points to about 1839. Policy: 26 January (± a few days, in any year 1833–1841) is used to prioritize candidates; no candidate is eliminated on birth year alone; searches cover 1833–1841. 1835 is kept as the working year wherever a single year is required, flagged as uncertain. (Project decision, 8 Oct 2026; see errata.)

How these are rated — by genealogical standards

The confidence ratings here follow the evidence-analysis model used in professional genealogy — the Source · Information · Evidence framework — together with the Genealogical Proof Standard (GPS), rather than an ad-hoc scale. Three independent classifications are applied to each record, with respect to the birth fact specifically:

Source

Is the document an original (created at the event, or a contemporaneous register) or a derivative (a later copy, abstract, or compiled record)?

Information

Is the birth detail primary (from someone with firsthand knowledge of the birth) or secondary (reported second-hand)?

Evidence

Does it answer the birth-date question directly (states an age or date), indirectly (must be inferred), or as negative evidence (an expected record’s absence)?

The decisive point under these standards: not one of these records carries primary information about Charles's birth. No informant — not even Charles himself — witnessed his own 1835 birth; every figure is second-hand knowledge carried within the family. So all eleven are secondary, direct evidence drawn from original or derivative sources. They differ only in source originality, how close the informant stood to a knowledgeable party, precision (a full date vs. a round age), and how well they corroborate one another.

Because the date can be built only from a body of conflicting secondary evidence, the GPS requires the conclusion to rest on correlation and the resolution of those conflicts — and on reasonably exhaustive research. That last test is not yet met: the one record class that would supply primary information, the German baptism register, has never been found. That is exactly why the project holds 26 January 1835 as ★ Working, not Proved. The confidence pills below therefore rank relative reliability within an entirely secondary-information set — not against an absolute standard any of these records could meet on its own.

Standard used

This page applies the two standards in general use in professional U.S. genealogy:

• The Genealogical Proof Standard (GPS) and the source / information / evidence classifications — Board for Certification of Genealogists, Genealogy Standards, 2nd ed. rev. (Nashville: Ancestry, 2021).

• The evidence-analysis model (original vs. derivative source; primary vs. secondary information; direct, indirect, or negative evidence) — Elizabeth Shown Mills, Evidence Explained: Citing History Sources from Artifacts to Cyberspace, 3rd ed. rev. (Baltimore: Genealogical Publishing Co., 2017), ch. 1.

These align with the project's own source-rating taxonomy (Confirmed / Working) and evidence-grade chips (original-firsthand, original-secondhand, derivative, compiled).

Every record, with its source

#RecordAs statedImplied birthSource (Doc / file)Confidence
1 2 Dec 1862
Civil War enlistment
"age 23" ~1839 Regimental Descriptive Book card — the card that actually records “Age 23 years” and “Where born: Freundburg, Kurhessen” (height 5′5″, occupation Farmer) — charles-research.netlify.app/evidence/card-3-civil-war-enlistment.html (Card 2). Not the Missouri AGO service card filed as “Doc O,” whose Age field is blank. Examine firsthand: NARA M405 Compiled Service Record (Missouri), file G11-422819443E — on Fold3 and FamilySearch’s “Missouri, Civil War Service Records of Union Soldiers, 1861–1865” — FamilySearch record ↗ (indexed age 23 / est. b. 1839; image via “View on Fold3”). The same age-23 figure re-enters the pension file via its embedded 1862 service record — the pension file's only account of where he signed up — so records ##1–2 and the pension file agree on his age at enlistment (noted by Jed Johnson, 2 Jul 2026). See row 2: the original, Charles-signed Volunteer Enlistment file carrying this same age was found 2 Jul 2026. LowDerivative source · 2° info (self-reported) · direct
2 2 Dec 1862
Volunteer Enlistment file (signed)
"aged twenty three years" (self-sworn, written out, signed) ~1839 New source, 2 Jul 2026 (found by a fellow researcher): Charles's original signed enlistment papers — Declaration of Recruit, Volunteer Enlistment, and surgeon's exam — FamilySearch, Missouri. Military Records 1861–1863, images 154–156, filed/indexed under the clerk's “Charles L. Johnsen/Johnson”. Both the Declaration and the Enlistment state “twenty three years”, sworn 2 Dec 1862, St. Louis, before John A. Hodgman — the only Charles-signed age statement in the record. Full analysis: Key Evidence Card 1. Examine firsthand: FamilySearch image 155 ↗ (login required); hi-res scans on Card 1. Agreement across files: the same age-23 appears on the Regimental Descriptive Book card (row 1) and in the pension file's embedded 1862 service record — every account of where he signed up carries the identical figure (match noted by Jed Johnson, 2 Jul 2026). He may not have known, or accurately reported, his own birth date (a fellow researcher). Convergence, then elimination: the self-sworn age-23 lands on the Deisel baptism of Karl Konze, b. 7 June 1839 (KB 218842, S.75, Nro 398, house Nr. 94; father Joh. Christoph Konze V.; Archion permalink) — baptism image-verified, but this candidate is now eliminated: an Ancestry Hesse Deaths record (verified 5 Jul 2026) shows Karl Konze died 23 Sept 1920 at Homberg/Efze, age 81 (Cert. Nr. 45; corroborated by the Trendelburg researcher) — he stayed in Germany. The age-23 still marks the ~1839 side. (Karl Meerkamm of Trendelburg, the lead that followed, was eliminated on 9 Oct 2026: a married laborer at Trendelburg in 1865–66. No named ~1839 lead remains.) ModerateOriginal source · 2° info (self, sworn) · direct
3 1880
U.S. Federal Census
"age 39" ~1841 1880 census, 2125 Jackson St. — "Charles Gonson" (Doc D) — charles-research.netlify.app/hub.html#doc-crosswalk. FamilySearch index (profile LZXC-6GB, ark M6N9-XYL): age 39, est. b. 1841. Examine firsthand: FamilySearch record ↗. LowOriginal source · 2° info (household) · direct
4 15 Jan 1890
Declaration for an Original Invalid Pension
"aged ~56 years" (reads mid-50s) ~1833–34 Pension file F41-523680269E, scan pp. 14–15 — charles-research.netlify.app/sources/pension-file.html#p14. Examine firsthand: NARA, Civil War Pension Application 684507 (file F41-523680269E) — not freely online; full page images hosted on this site. ModerateOriginal source · 2° info (self) · direct
5 9 Feb 1891
Declaration for Invalid Pension
"aged 53 years" ~1837–38 Pension file F41-523680269E, scan p. 11 — charles-research.netlify.app/sources/pension-file.html#p11. Examine firsthand: NARA pension file F41-523680269E (images hosted on this site). ModerateOriginal source · 2° info (self) · direct
6 1900
U.S. Federal Census
"Nov 1836; age 63" Nov 1836 1900 census, Peter Kuhn household, 170 Sidney St., Ward 9 (Doc B) — charles-research.netlify.app/hub.html#doc-crosswalk. FamilySearch index (profile LZXC-6GB): birth Nov 1836. Examine firsthand: FamilySearch record ↗. ModerateOriginal source · 2° info (boarder) · direct
7 ~1900
Soldiers' Home register
birth "about 1837" ~1837 U.S. National Homes for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers, 1866–1938 (Danville branch) — FamilySearch (profile LZXC-6GB). Examine firsthand: FamilySearch collection “U.S. National Homes for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers, 1866–1938” (record attached to FS profile LZXC-6GB; orig. NARA M1749). LowOriginal source · 2° info (self-derived) · direct
8 17 Dec 1903
Civil death certificate
"age 69 … born 1834" ~1834 City of St. Louis Certificate of Death no. 10619 (Doc A) — charles-research.netlify.app/hub.html#doc-crosswalk. Examine firsthand: Ancestry record image ↗ (Missouri, Death Records, 1834–1910, certificate image; orig. Missouri State Archives). LowOriginal source · 2° info (survivor, post-mortem) · direct
9 18 Dec 1903
Newspaper obituary
"at the age of 69 years" ~1834 St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 18 Dec 1903, p. 12 — FamilySearch Memories (profile LZXC-6GB); Newspapers.com. Examine firsthand: Newspapers.com clipping ↗ (St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 18 Dec 1903, p. 12); also saved to FamilySearch Memories ↗ (“Obituary for Charles L. Johnson”, profile LZXC-6GB). LowOriginal source · 2° info (family, post-mortem) · direct
10 19 Dec 1903
Church burial register
"born 26 January 1835; age 68 y 10 m 20 d" (entry records death 16 Dec, burial 19 Dec 1903) 26 Jan 1835 St. Marcus burial register, pp. 240–241, no. 3393 (Doc N) — charles-research.netlify.app/hub.html#doc-crosswalk. Examine firsthand: FamilySearch record image ↗ (entry dated 19 Dec 1903). High*Original source · 2° info (family, post-mortem) · direct

*"High" is relative to the other records on this page — see the ranking below. No record here is an independent birth source.

Confidence ranking — strongest to weakest, and why

"Confidence" here means how much weight each record deserves as evidence of Charles's true birth date. Two axes drive the ranking, per the project's source-rating taxonomy: originality / informant proximity (was the recorder present, and who supplied the fact) and precision (a full date versus a round age).

  1. Church burial register — 26 Jan 1835 Highest

    The only record carrying a full day–month–year. Its stated "68 y 10 m 20 d" back-calculates to the same late-January-1835 birth, but that is not a check: the pastor computed the age from the date the family gave him. It is an original parish entry written contemporaneously by the clergyman. Why not higher still: the birth fact is secondhand and post-mortem — supplied by the family after Charles died — not an independent birth record, and its 1835 year runs a year or two older than Charles's own later statements.

  2. 1900 census — Nov 1836 Moderate

    The only other record that fixes a month, and an original federal record taken in Charles's lifetime. Why mid-pack: he was a boarder in the Kuhn household, so the informant may have been the head of household rather than Charles himself; a stated month from a non-self informant is suggestive, not firm.

  3. 9 Feb 1891 pension declaration — age 53 (~1838) Moderate

    Charles's own sworn statement, under oath and penalty of perjury, on an original federal document — high informant proximity. Why not higher: age only, no month or day, and it conflicts with his own 1890 filing by three years, which shows he did not actually know his precise age.

  4. 15 Jan 1890 pension declaration — age ~56 (~1833–34) Moderate

    Also Charles's own sworn original statement. Ranked just below the 1891 one precisely because the two disagree: a man who swears 56 one year and 53 the next is estimating, not reporting a known date.

  5. 2 Dec 1862 signed Volunteer Enlistment file — “twenty three years” (~1839) Moderate New 2 Jul 2026

    The original signed enlistment papers (Key Evidence Card 1, found by a fellow researcher): Charles swore to “twenty three years” — written out in words, on two instruments, over his own Kurrent signature. An original source with the highest informant proximity possible (self, under oath), and it is not alone: the same age-23 sits on the Regimental Descriptive Book card and in the pension file's embedded 1862 service record — every account of the day he signed up agrees. Why not higher: age-only, and stated in the enlistment context where men routinely rounded or shaded their age; it also conflicts with everything Charles said in the 1890s. It is now the strongest witness on the ~1839 side of the question — on which a German paleographer's Deisel candidate Karl Konze, b. 7 June 1839 once sat; that candidate is now eliminated (d. 1920 Homberg/Efze, verified 5 Jul 2026), leaving Karl Meerkamm (b. 1839 Trendelburg) as the ~1839 lead. (Meerkamm was eliminated on 9 Oct 2026: a married laborer at Trendelburg in 1865–66. No named ~1839 lead remains.)

  6. 1880 census — age 39 (~1841) Low

    Original federal record, but age-only, household-reported (any adult could have answered), a round number, and the youngest outlier of the set.

  7. 2 Dec 1862 enlistment (Descriptive Book card) — age 23 (~1839) Low

    The Regimental Descriptive Book card recording “Age 23 years” — a derivative clerk’s abstract of the same enlistment event as the signed file ranked above, which now supplies the original behind this figure. Kept as a separate line because it is the record the project relied on before 2 Jul 2026, and because its independent agreement (card, signed file, pension-file service record) is itself evidence the age-23 was really what Charles stated.

  8. National Homes for Disabled Volunteer Soldiers register (~1900) — birth ~1837 Low

    The Danville Soldiers'-Home admission register indexes Charles's birth as “about 1837.” An original institutional record, but the birth figure is age-derived and almost certainly drawn from the same self-reported pension data — secondary, with no month or day. It re-states the mid-1830s self-report rather than adding an independent one.

  9. 17 Dec 1903 death certificate — age 69 / "born 1834" Low

    Lowest for birth precision. The informant was necessarily not Charles (he was deceased); a survivor gave a round "69," and "1834" is merely that age subtracted from 1903. Authoritative for the death; weak for the birth.

  10. 18 Dec 1903 newspaper obituary — “age 69” (~1834) Low

    The St. Louis Post-Dispatch death notice gives Charles's age as 69 (→ ~1834), agreeing with the death certificate. A contemporaneous newspaper record, but post-mortem, family-supplied, and age-only — it adds a second 1834 attestation, not an independent date. No calendar birth date appears in the clipping itself.

  11. Withdrawn: “18 Jan 1890, aged 65”

    Earlier versions of this page listed an 18 January 1890 pension filing giving “aged 65 years” (~1825). The full image re-read of the pension file (10 Oct 2026), which dates every page, found no such document and no age of 65: January 1890 holds only the declaration of 15 January (age 56) and the receipt of the claim on 20 January. The row was removed on 17 Oct 2026.

The German-side check — no 26 January 1835 birth in the regional database (a partial corpus)

The note of 16 Jul 2026 (16 July 2026) ran the first full computational pass over Mr. Dornette's regional birth database — 31,945 births, 1598–1951, across eleven parishes of the Trendelburg/Deisel complex (Gottsbüren, Sielen, Langenthal, Deisel, Eberschütz, Trendelburg, Gewissensruhe, Gottstreu, Friedrichsfeld, Weißehütte, Wülmersen). The result is a clean corpus-level negative: no record of any birth on 26 January 1835 exists in the database — any surname, either sex. January 1835 holds only thirteen births in all eleven parishes; every male among them is accounted for (two unnamed Söhnlein, the eliminated Wilhelm Heinrich Bonhagen of Deisel, the eliminated Johann Ludwig Wiegand of Gottsbüren, and Ludwig Friedrich Köster of a documented local family).

Under this page's own framework this is negative, direct evidence from an unpublished compilation of the original registers (the Dornette database; status unverified in the names database). It corroborates the register-level negatives already in hand (Trendelburg 220108 Jan 1835; Deisel 218842; the ~30 swept parishes) and formalizes them at corpus scale: but it is not a negative for Charles: the notes of 8 Aug 2026 measured the corpus’s birth coverage at only about 60 % (Deisel), 33 % (Trendelburg) and 26 % (Friedrichsfeld), so the corpus is a pointer, never a negative (corrected 8 Oct 2026; this paragraph previously read “if the 26 January 1835 date is literal, Charles was not born in any parish the Dornette corpus covers”). The register-level reads are what count: the note of 7 Oct 2026 read every January leaf 1833–1841 in image at Trendelburg, Deisel, Friedrichsfeld, Sielen, Stammen and Langenthal and found no Carl/Karl or “…Ludwig” boy born 25–27 January in any of those years. Since 8 October 2026 the year is treated as uncertain (c. 1833–1841), Trendelburg is graded Charles’s birthplace (his own signed statement), and the search runs across the whole 1833–1841 range, Trendelburg first.

The same pass cross-referenced every Carl/Karl born 1833–1841 against Mr. Dornette's death and marriage databases and produced a 36-name ledger of boys who vanish from the local records — independently recovering Karl Meerkamm, Carl Ludwig Martini, and the known emigrants. The full ledger, with each candidate's resolution, is on its own page: The Vanished Karls — candidate ledger. Detail: the research note of 16 Jul 2026.

Bottom line

The firm, multiply-attested conclusion is a birth in the mid-1830s in Kurhessen. The precise 26 January 1835 rests on a single post-mortem, family-supplied parish entry (Doc N). Since 8 October 2026 the year is held as uncertain (c. 1833–41): the day and month are used to prioritize candidates, the year is not used to eliminate anyone, and searches cover 1833–1841. The only independent month-level support comes from the 1900 census ("Nov 1836"), and Charles's own sworn ages range from about 1833 to 1841 — the earliest, age 23 in December 1862, pointing to about 1839.

The 1839 flag (2 Jul 2026). The discovery of the signed Volunteer Enlistment file changes the shape of the low end of the range: the age-23 figure is now attested by an original, self-sworn, Charles-signed document, and it agrees with both the Descriptive Book card and the pension file's embedded 1862 service record — three files, one figure, for the day he signed up. That self-sworn ~1839 sat almost exactly on the image-verified Deisel baptism of Karl Konze, b. 7 June 1839 (Archion permalink) — a candidate since eliminated (Karl Konze d. 23 Sept 1920 Homberg/Efze; verified 5 Jul 2026), so the ~1839 window now points to Karl Meerkamm (Trendelburg). (Meerkamm was eliminated on 9 Oct 2026: a married laborer at Trendelburg in 1865–66. No named ~1839 lead remains.) The 26 January date stands as the only full date, but the burial register’s age is computed from it and does not check it. Since 8 October 2026 the year is treated as uncertain across the whole range of Charles’s sworn ages (c. 1833–1841), not just two windows, and no candidate is eliminated on birth year alone.

Related. The full record images and transcriptions sit on the Pension File and Military Record source pages; the document framework is the Doc A–O crosswalk; the date (26 January 1835 by the burial register; year uncertain) and its Working status are tracked on the Claims Dashboard.