1The question
Charles Gannsen served three years in Battery B, 2nd Missouri Light Artillery, married in St. Louis in 1866, raised seven children there and died on 16 December 1903. His American life is well recorded. He never said who his parents were, and no record in Germany has yet been found that names him. Which boy of Kurhessen was he?
2The answer as it stands
PossiblyHe was possibly Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, born at Deisel on 13 November 1837.
Karl Ludwig is the author’s leading candidate among the boys still open. No record yet proves it. Conflicting evidence remains, so the case does not yet satisfy the Genealogical Proof Standard, and it remains a hypothesis until a record or a DNA test resolves it.
His surname
The evidence is divided. His own hand writes the a of Gans; the places he named and what others heard make Konze possible. Konze has more of the evidence, but no record yet proves either.
His birthplace
His oath of 1862 says Trendelburg. Deisel, the next village, was probably his last home and possibly his birthplace. That is the author’s lean, not a finding.
The book argues the case in full in “The Boy from the Goose Corner” and weighs the two names in “The Name He Signed.”
3The five records that carry the case
Three are American and say what Charles told others about himself. Two are German and say who Karl Ludwig was. Nothing yet joins the two sets except how well they fit.
-
His enlistment, St. Louis, 2 December 1862
He swore that he was born “in Trennelburg in the State of Kurhessen” and signed his name Gannsen. The clerk wrote him down as Charles L. Johnsen.
It is his own sworn statement of his birthplace, it carries his own signature, and it is the first of more than a dozen records that give him the middle initial L.
-
His marriage, St. Marcus Church, 7 January 1866
The pastor entered him as Carl Gonnson “aus Deiße, Kreis Caßel, Churheßen”: from Deisel.
It names Deisel, the village next to Trendelburg, and it is why the search treats Deisel as his probable last home.
-
The 1900 census, St. Louis
It gives his birth as November 1836 and his arrival in America as 1859.
It is the only record of his lifetime that names a month of birth. The person who answered the census taker is not named.
-
The Deisel baptism register, November 1837
Karl Ludwig Hofedietz was born on 13 November 1837 and baptized on the 26th, a son of the coachman Henricus (Ricus) Hofedietz and Amalie Weller. Both parents were dead by November 1844, when he was six.
It gives a Carl Ludwig, born in November, in the village Charles’s marriage entry names. The register belongs to the church archive and its images are not shown here; the citation gives the register and the image numbers.
-
The court summons in the Reichsanzeiger, 1 March 1900
The district court at Karlshafen summoned Karl Ludwig Hofeditz, born in November 1837, who had “emigrated to America at the beginning of the 1850s,” to come forward or be declared dead. His curator was the Deisel innkeeper Heinrich Konze.
It shows that Karl Ludwig went to America and was never heard from at home again, and it ties his affairs to a man named Konze, the name clerks and pastors in St. Louis gave Charles’s family.
Three points fit Karl Ludwig, and no other open boy named Carl has all three: his names, Carl Ludwig, fit the “Charles L.” of the American records; he was born in November; and the 1900 court summoned him as missing in America, with a Konze as his curator. Every statement in the book is cited: see the notes and the sources.
4What stands against it
- The name. Nothing yet explains how a Hofedietz became Gannsen. A Konze household possibly raised the orphan, which would account for the Kon- forms, but not for the a that Charles wrote himself. No foster record has been found.
- The birth date. The burial register of 1903 gives 26 January 1835, a date the family supplied after his death. Nothing yet explains it.
- The year he left. The court wrote “the beginning of the 1850s”; the census says Charles came in 1859. The two can be reconciled if he left the village years before he left Germany, but no record shows it.
- The silence. After his confirmation in 1852, Karl Ludwig appears only in notices that say he was absent: as a conscript who missed the muster of 1858, and in the summons of 1900. No American record of a Hofedietz who could be him has been found.
- The other boys. He is the leading candidate, not the only one. His own brothers Friedrich Wilhelm and Heinrich are untraced, and Charles was possibly born somewhere not yet searched.
5What was searched and found empty
The search followed every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld from 1833 to 1841, 426 in all, forward through the records. A boy was closed only when a record documented his later life. Twenty-seven are still open, three of them probably traced.
- The confirmation classes of the home parishes and their neighbors, and the baptisms of fifty-seven places. In the twenty parishes next to the home villages the baptisms of 1833–41 were read twice, boy by boy.
- The passenger lists, the Hessian emigration index, the court notices of 1900 and the Kassel civil marriage registers.
- The records of the lying-in hospitals at Marburg, Kassel and Göttingen for those years.
- The DNA match lists at three companies.
None of it produced a German record that names Charles, or a family of his American surname. What each search covered is set out in Every record searched and Parish registers, 1830–1858; the open boys are listed, with the record that would settle each, in Help find Charles and Open leads.
Gaps that remain. The Karlshafen court’s guardianship files cannot yet be used. The district’s release and emigration files have been searched by index only, and the army books of 1855–59 have not been copied. No cousin from Karl Ludwig’s own family has tested.
6What would settle it
- A DNA test of a descendant of one of Karl Ludwig’s sisters, or of a man of the Hofedietz male line. The DNA page sets out the DNA evidence so far.
- The Karlshafen court files on his guardianship in 1843–44 and on his absence in 1900, which would name the property held for him and could say where he went.
- A release notice for him in the provincial weekly paper, if his guardian ever asked for his release as a subject.
- A letter, a Bible entry or a photograph in a family from Deisel or Trendelburg that names a son or brother gone to St. Louis.
The book keeps the full list in “What We Still Do Not Know.” If you can read one of these records, or belong to a Hofedietz, Konze or Gans family of the district, please write.
The case as the book states it in November 2026. This page changes when the evidence does.