Where it stands
The name he used fits two German surnames, Gans and Konze. Konze has more of the evidence, and neither is proven. The leading candidate was born a Hofedietz, and a Konze family possibly took him in.
The case for Gans
The case for Gans rests on what Charles wrote.
In the chapter: The case for GansThe case for Konze
The case for Konze rests on what pastors and his daughters’ families heard, and on where he came from.
In the chapter: The case for KonzeOr neither?
The name is possibly neither Gans nor Konze.
In the chapter: Or neither?
Gans has the better evidence for the spelling: his own handwriting, above all the 1862 signature. But the spelling a man writes is not always the name he was baptized under. Konze has the better evidence for the place and for what his family said. But other people recorded a spoken name from what they heard, and a pastor who knew Konze families could have spelled it that way.
His name with a K
In five of the twenty-eight counted records of 1862 to 1900 his name was recorded with a K or a C as its first letter. None of the five is in his own hand. All twenty-eight counted records are on the Name wall.
| Year | As recorded | Record | Recorded by | Name wall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1875 | Konsen | St. Marcus baptism of Erwin Carl, 3 October | Pastor Julius Hoffmann | On the wall |
| 1890 | Konzen | St. Marcus death register, 5 May: his daughter Maria Josephine Herr, “geb. Konzen” | Register keeper, from the family | On the wall |
| 1890 | Konzen | St. Marcus death register, 31 December: his daughter Auguste Somers, “geb. Konzen” | Register keeper, from the family | On the wall |
| 1896 | Conson | St. Marcus death register, 19 December: his wife Auguste | Pastor E. H. Eilts | On the wall |
| 1900 | Koncen | Gould’s St. Louis directory, 168 Sidney Street | Directory canvasser | On the wall |
Evidence for each name
This table was in the printed chapter until 28 October 2026. It does not repeat the twenty-eight attestations, which the chapter “The Name He Signed” lists; it shows what each main piece of evidence bears on and how much it weighs.
| Record and date | Form | Who supplied the name | Bears on | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Enlistment signature, 2 Dec 1862 [Paleographer's letters, 2026] | Gannsen, in KurrentOriginal | Charles, in his own hand | G; a | Strong for the spellingwritten before any clerk fixed a form |
| Marriage register, 7 Jan 1866 [MAR66] | GonnsonOriginal | Charles, spoken; Pastor Wall wrote it | G; o | Moderatehis own voice, another man's ear |
| Signature on his pension declaration, 15 Jan 1890 [PEN] | Gannson, Latin letters with the long sOriginal | Charles, in his own hand | G; a | Strong for the spellingbut written after the army's rolls had settled on Gannsen |
| Signature on a probate petition, 15 Sep 1900 [GUARD] | GannsonOriginal | Charles, in his own hand | G; a | Moderaterepeats his 1890 form |
| Kreichelt family notices, 1883 and 1894 [SURN] | GansenOriginal (print) | His wife's family | G; a | Moderatepeople who heard him for decades |
| Voter register, c. 1899–1900 [VOTE] | GansenOriginal | Charles, to the registrar | G; a | Moderatehis own statement late in life |
| Daughters' deaths, St. Marcus, 1890 [DTH90] | Konzen, twiceOriginal | The family, reporting the deaths | K; o; the z fits Konze | Moderate for Konzethe only z forms |
| Directory 1874, baptism 1875, directory 1900 [D1874] [BAP75] [D1900] | Konsen, KoncenOriginal | The householder, to canvassers; a parent at the font (Pastor Hoffmann wrote it) | K; o | Weakstrangers’ hearings of what the household said |
| Wife's death, St. Marcus, Dec 1896 [AUG96] | ConsonOriginal | Probably Charles; Pastor Eilts wrote it | K; o | Moderate |
| Konze surname survey, 36 parishes, June 2026 [SWEEP] | KonzeDerivative: a survey of the registers | Not applicable | K; place | Moderate for the place; not independent of the choice of Konze |
| The Deisel Gans family, 1829–1835 [DBAP] [OSB759] | GansOriginal register; published family book | Not applicable | G; place | Against Gansthe family had left for the Weser by 1835 |
| Y-DNA, Big Y-700 [BIGY] | NoneTest result | Not applicable | Neither name | Does not decide |
The table is from the chapter “The Name He Used: Gans, Konze or Another Name”.