What is known
Name
His own signatureCharles Gannsen, later Johnson. He signed “Gannsen” on 2 December 1862. The twenty-eight counted records of 1862 to 1900 spell the surname fourteen ways.
Surname recordsLife
Year uncertainBorn about 1835; the records give years from 1833 to 1841. The burial register gives 26 January and the 1900 census gives November. Neither date is proven. He died on 16 December 1903 at St. Louis.
Birth date recordsBirthplace
His own statementOn 2 December 1862 he swore that he was born at Trendelburg, written “Trennelburg,” in Kurhessen. Deisel, about a mile and a half (2.3 km) away, was probably his last home and possibly his birthplace.
Origin recordsGerman surname
Not provenThe name he used fits two German surnames, Gans and Konze. Konze has more of the evidence, and neither is proven. The leading candidate was born a Hofedietz, and a Konze family possibly took him in.
The surname puzzleIn America
From the recordsThe census of 1900 gives 1859 as the year he came to America. No passenger list or port record has been found for him. He enlisted at St. Louis on 2 December 1862 in Battery B, 2nd Missouri Light Artillery.
Read the bookStill missing
Not foundNo German baptism or confirmation has yet been tied to him, and no record yet ties him to a family in Hesse. DNA tests of his relatives, read with the records, or the court files at Karlshafen could answer the question that remains.
Every record searched
The leading candidate
Karl Ludwig Hofedietz
Parents: Ricus Hofedietz, coachman × Amalie Weller.
Charles was possibly Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, born at Deisel on 13 November 1837, who was orphaned at six and whom the court at Karlshafen summoned in 1900 as missing in America. He is the author’s leading candidate among the open boys, not the only one, and no record yet proves that he was Charles.
In 1858 he was a conscript who had missed that year’s muster: the local court at Karlshafen fined him in his absence on 21 January, and the district office at Hofgeismar summoned him on 6 February. So he was gone from home by early 1858, but the notices do not say where he went or tie him to Charles. He is the leading candidate, not the only one; the others stay open until a record closes them.
- Last record at home
- Confirmed at Deisel 1852
- What would settle it
- Karlshafen court, his guardianship file, 1843/44 (HStAM 275); a DNA test of a descendant of his sisters
The case for him: The Boy from the Goose CornerHis candidate page
How you can help
Hofedietz, Konze and Gans families
If your family is a Hofedietz (also Hofeditz or Hoffeditz), Konze (Kontze, Conze) or Gans line from Deisel, Trendelburg or the Hofgeismar district, please write. A family tree, old papers or a memory of a relative who went to America could help. So could DNA tests of relatives, read together with the records.
Researchers in Hesse
The list below names the record that would settle each boy. Most are files in the Hessian State Archives at Marburg or parish books not yet online. If you can read one, or know where a boy went, please tell us.
Anyone with old papers
Letters, a family Bible, a photograph with a name on the back, or a story about where “Grandpa Johnson” came from. Any of these could hold the place or the name that is missing.
Write to Jed Johnson. English or German is fine.
[address withheld]
What to look forsearch terms for a register or an index
- The leading candidate. Karl Ludwig Hofedietz (also recorded as Hofeditz and Hoffeditz), born at Deisel on 13 November 1837. Any record of him after his confirmation in 1852, in Germany or in America.
- The open boys named Carl. Eight boys named Carl of Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld, born 1833 to 1841, Karl Ludwig among them, with no later record. The list is below.
- The name in America. Charles, Carl or Karl, often “Charles L.” The surname in any of its spellings, which are listed on Surname records. Later Johnson.
- The name in Germany. Gans and Konze families of Trendelburg and Deisel still matter: the name he used fits both, and if he was Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, a Konze household possibly raised him.
- Birth window. 1833 to 1841. No candidate is ruled out on the birth year alone.
- Both churches, and boys born out of wedlock. Lutheran and Reformed registers. A boy born out of wedlock was usually entered under his mother’s surname, but in the Trendelburg register of the 1830s some have the father’s surname and some no surname at all, so read the entries by date.
The boys who could be Charles
Twenty-seven boys baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld in 1833–41 are still open, three of them probably traced, and eight of them are named Carl. The confirmation classes of those churches and of nearby Langenthal, Sielen and Stammen added boys born elsewhere or just outside those years; three of them are still open (the R1 rows). That makes 30 open boys in all.
How to read the listrank, file numbers and references
The ranking only sets the order of work. It counts the points that fit Charles best: the name Carl, a family in the three parishes, a birth in 1833–41, a birth out of wedlock, a trail that ends in the 1850s, and a tie to a Konze or Gans family. High, Medium and Low are the ranks of the table in the book chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out”. None of these boys has yet been linked to the name Gannsen.
“Nr.” means a file of the district office of Hofgeismar in the Hessian State Archives at Marburg (HStAM 180 Hofgeismar). The release files list young men who were given leave to emigrate; no release file has been found for 1859–60, the years that matter most. Nr. 640, the district’s general emigration file for 1852–70, is the nearest, though it may hold only orders and not names. The list assumes Charles was right about his birthplace.
“Ref” is the boy’s number in the candidate ledger. For each boy’s full trail, see Open leads and The vanished Carls.
Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August Zollmann
Born 12 May 1836, Trendelburg. Johann Conrad Zollmann × Wilhelmine Bromm.
Carl; Trendelburg; Konze grandmother
Last recordConfirmed at Trendelburg 1850
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itBockenheim (Frankfurt) marriages 1856–66, where his brother lived
Carl Wilhelm Lucas
Born 25 May 1837, Trendelburg. David Lucas × Maria Sophie Wendel.
Carl; Trendelburg; a probable Konze link
Last recordConfirmed at Trendelburg 1851; orphaned
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itTrendelburg court, guardianship of the Lucas children, 1842–51 (HStAM 330)
Karl Ludwig Hofedietz
Born 13 Nov 1837, Deisel. Ricus Hofedietz, coachman × Amalie Weller.
Carl Ludwig; Deisel; November birth; orphan; missing in America by 1900; the leading candidate (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”)
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1852
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itKarlshafen court, his guardianship file, 1843/44 (HStAM 275); a DNA test of a descendant of his sisters
Karl Justus August Konrad Brandau
Born 11 Jul 1837, Deisel. Johannes Brandau, teacher × J. M. C. Stephan.
Carl, with the later name Konrad; Deisel; left 1856
Last recordProbably sailed Hamburg to New York, Nov 1856
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itA record of his life after November 1856, in America or in Germany; none found in the census, directory and pension indexes searched
Carl Ludwig Hundt
Born 25 Feb 1834, Langenthal. Maria Sophie Hundt, unwed mother.
Carl Ludwig; Langenthal; out of wedlock
Last recordConfirmed at Langenthal 1848
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itLangenthal marriages 1834–50: did his mother marry, and under what name did he go?
Carl Ludwig Martini
Born 1 Dec 1834, Trendelburg. Philipp Eberhard Martini, surgeon × Gertrude Schember.
Carl Ludwig; Trendelburg; left 1854
Last recordEmigrated to America, 1854
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itA record of his arrival or of his life in America after 1854. The 1860 census indexes show no Carl Martini born in Hesse (index only); a Charles Martini of about his age, a saloon keeper in St. Louis, was born in Saxony. The Karlshafen court’s files on his mother’s 1857 estate and on the curatorship of Julius and Eduard Martini (HStAM 275)
Heinrich Karl
Born 20 Apr 1836, Deisel. Charlotte Villmar, unwed mother; father Hellwig Karl.
Out of wedlock; Deisel
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1850
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 128 p. 426, his father's release of 1857
Franz Carl Gustav Kayser
Born 27 Oct 1838, Trendelburg. The same parents as Hieronymus Carl Kayser.
Carl; Trendelburg
Last recordBaptism
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itHis father's personnel file (HStAM)
Hieronymus Carl Kayser
Born 12 Jun 1837, Trendelburg. J. H. Kayser, customs controller × Dubois de Luchet.
Carl; Trendelburg; the family moved away
Last recordBaptism; the family moved away
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itHis father's personnel file, Kurhessian customs service (HStAM)
Philipp Kloppmann
Born 1 Dec 1843, Deisel. Adam Kloppmann × Charlotte Konze.
Konze mother; Deisel; trail ends 1858; born 1843
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1858
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 841 p. 1: is he in his family's release?
Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meier
Born 27 Nov 1838, Trendelburg. G. H. A. Meier, shepherd (d. 1842) × Regina Widdig.
Carl; Trendelburg
Last recordBaptism
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itTrendelburg court, guardianship of the Meier children, 1842 ff. (HStAM 330)
Heinrich Ludwig (no surname)
Born 28 Oct 1834, Trendelburg. Maria Caroline Fischer, unwed mother; later legitimated (Thöne?).
Out of wedlock; Trendelburg
Last recordBaptism
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itGrebenstein confirmations 1848–50
Theodor Thiele
Born 24 Jul 1839, Deisel. Samuel Thiele × A. K. Karl.
No Carl; Deisel; trail ends 1856; a Thiele left without release, 1861
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1856
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 841: the forename of the Thiele who left in 1861
Heinrich Koch
Born Dec 1838, Deisel. H. W. Koch, shepherd × Amalie Niemeyer.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1854
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 640
Friedrich Louis Albrecht
Born 12 May 1836, Trendelburg. J. G. or J. P. Albrecht, tailor × Wilhelmine Graff.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Trendelburg 1850
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itLiebenau marriages 1846–56 and burials 1846–80
Georg Carl Quentin
Born 30 May 1831, Friedrichsfeld. Maria Elisabeth Amalie Quentin, unwed mother.
Probably traced: New York 1853; Carl; out of wedlock; but born 1831
Last recordArrived at New York on the Adonis, 18 July 1853, as “Carl Quenten, 22, baker” [ADONIS53]; very probably the Cincinnati baker George Quentin of 1855–60
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itCincinnati records of George Quentin, baker, 1855–60. The Hansa’s George Quentin, baker, born 1826 at Göttingen (New York, Sep 1853), is probably a different man
Friedrich Wilhelm Hofeditz
Born 12 Jul 1841, Deisel. Konrad Hofedietz × K. Engelbrecht.
No Carl; trail ends 1856
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1856
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 841 or Nr. 640
Heinrich Wilhelm Albrecht
Born 24 Aug 1840, Trendelburg. The same parents as Friedrich Louis Albrecht.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Trendelburg 1854
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itLiebenau burials 1846–80
Heinrich Gräbe
Born 28 Jan 1839, Deisel. Ferdinand Gräbe, musician × W. Schildknecht.
No Carl; born 28 January
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1853
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 128 pp. 35–38, the Gräbe party of 1847; else Nr. 640
Philipp Meimbresse
Born 17 Feb 1835, Deisel. Andreas Meimbresse × K. E. Koch.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1849
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 640
Heinrich Köster
Born 29 Mar 1833, Deisel. M. E. Baumann, unwed mother, who married Nicolaus Köster in 1834.
Probably traced: New York 1854
Last recordProbably the tailor who reached New York in 1854
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNew York records of Henry Köster, tailor, 1854–70
Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Rode
Born 22 Apr 1839, Trendelburg. C. W. Rode × W. Grosbernd.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Trendelburg 1853
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 640
Friedrich Wilhelm Hofedietz
Born 17 Feb 1833, Deisel. [Ricus?] Hofedietz × Amalie Weller[?].
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1847
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itHis baptism re-read for the father; then HStAM 275 guardianship
Ludwig Bonhagen
Born 19 Jun 1835, Deisel. Friedrich Bonhagen × Elisabeth Bötte.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1849
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itNr. 128 p. 347, his brother's release of 1856
Friedrich Lauterbach
Born 13 Apr 1834, Deisel. Christoph Lauterbach × M. E. Schildknecht.
No Carl
Last recordConfirmed at Deisel 1848
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itDeisel burials 1848–80, page by page
Georg Christian Meier
Born 28 Sep 1840, Trendelburg. The same parents as Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meier.
No Carl
Last recordBaptism
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itThe Meier guardianship file (HStAM 330)
Friedrich Georg Käufer
Born Nov 1837, Deisel. Georg Käufer, shoemaker × Maria [Pütter?].
No Carl; family left
Last recordBaptism
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itKassel church baptisms 1837 and confirmations 1851–52
Johann Wilhelm Steitz
Born Dec 1837, Deisel. Johannes Steitz, baker × A. K. Koch.
Probably traced: Charleston 1854
Last recordProbably died at Charleston, 1854
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itSt. Matthew's Lutheran Church, Charleston, burials of Sep 1854
Ferdinand Klapp
Born 19 Feb 1835, Friedrichsfeld. Nikolaus Klapp × Sophie Charlotte Lotz.
Probably traced: New York 1854–60
Last recordProbably ‘Asmus Klapp’, naturalized at New York 1860
Found inthe baptism register only
What would settle itNr. 843 p. 17: his forename in the family's release
Johann Georg Flothe
Born 30 Dec 1839, Trendelburg. Heinrich Wilhelm Flotho, innkeeper of Hofgeismar × Sophie Gunkel.
No Carl; untraced (George Floether of Louisville was another man, baptized at Wilhelmshausen in 1839)
Last recordConfirmed at Hofgeismar Neustadt 1854
Found inthe baptism and confirmation registers
What would settle itAny adult record after 1854: emigration file, ship list, marriage or burial
No boy on the list matches. Clear the filter to see all of them.
Three charts of the open boyshow they compare



Where else to look
- Open leadsThe leads now being worked, and where each stands.
- Open questionsEach standing question, with the record that would settle it.
- The candidatesEvery boy considered, with the open ones marked.
- Every record searchedAll searches in Germany and the United States, with the terms used and what each found.
- The surname puzzleGans, Konze or another name: the evidence on each side.
- DNA evidenceWhat the family’s tests have shown and what they have not.
- What We Still Do Not KnowThe book’s own account of the open questions, in full.
- Contribute or correctHow to send a record, a lead or a correction.