Where the search stands: St. Louis has been searched in full, and the household is not found.
- Every 1870 St. Louis unit walked. All 18 city and county units were walked image by image: 8,893 images, 352,209 indexed persons, including the 3,366 records on 311 images (mostly institutions, boarding lists and hotels) that FamilySearch’s image data returns only as links beyond the first 12 records on an image. Loose tiers (any German-area birthplace; a wife 19–28 with a child 1–4 and an infant, husband optional), a strict test, a name score, the surname skeleton and the infant’s baptismal names were all negative. 149 thin images were checked and the 24 genuinely short ones read in the image; only Ward 1 p. 114, lines 1–27 (male college students), was unindexed (research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026).
- Where he lived in 1870 is less certain than it looked. The “Johnson, Charles, conductor, St. Louis R.R., r. 718 Gate” entry is in the 1871 Edwards directory, canvassed about the winter of 1870–71; the 1870 book, canvassed about January–March 1870, does not list him there. The pension letter’s “1869” for Gate Street is his own recollection. In early 1870 he very probably kept a bar at NW cor. N. Main & Bates (deeds of 18 Oct 1869 and 18 Jan 1870; residences). Both places were read in the image, every line: the Gate St. car-men’s house (Ward 1, 2–3 June 1870, pp. 1–28) and the Main & Bates block (Ward 10, 18th Sub-Division, pp. 349–364 and 388–391, 13–16 July 1870). No Charles, Auguste, Josephine or infant girl (research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026).
- The in-laws: “George Reichel” 51, Henriette 57, Chas 21, Julius 15, Barbara 10 (Ward 3, p. 344): Auguste and the children are not with them.
- “Johnson Charles, r. 1434 Collins” in the 1870 directory is the steamboat mate (“Johnson Charles, mate, r. 312 Madison” in the 1871 book, p. 352; Chas. Johnston, 50, born Illinois, in the census, p. 350). 1403 N. Main is the NW corner of Main & Bates (1869 street guide).
- Illinois: a sweep of St. Clair, Madison, Jefferson and St. Charles counties was negative. The family was in St. Louis in 1870, so no further out-of-county work is planned.
- What is left: a badly garbled name and garbled ages or sexes; an enumerator miss during the move from Main & Bates to Gate St. (June–Sept 1870); or a household headed by someone else. Cheap tests: an age- and sex-free fingerprint; the 1870 mortality schedule; a reverse look-up of 718/720 Gate in the 1871 directory. The 1860 St. Louis walks need re-checking for the same 12-record cap (research note, 9 Oct 2026).
★ What this record would tell us if found
The only census enumeration of Charles's young family with first-born children alive. Specifically:
- Household composition — whether Friedrich Wilhelm Gonnson (b. 1866, d. 1867) had been replaced by a second living child by mid-1870. The known surviving child by mid-1870 is Friedrike Catharina Carolina Amalia (Katherine Carolina), baptized 22 May 1870 — about ~3 months old at census time.
- Address on 1 June 1870 — would settle whether they were still at 1518 South 7th Street or had moved to 718 Gates Avenue. The pension file documents both addresses but not the exact transition date.
- Charles's 1870 occupation, real-estate value, and personal-property value — would establish his economic position in his fifth American year.
- Nearby households on the page — would reveal his immediate neighbors and witness-network anchors. The Battery B veteran cluster (Adam Herweck, August Derr, Christian Meyer, Henry Stoll, Michael Nolan, Theodore Gottlob) would surface if any of them were neighbors.
- Auguste's birthplace as recorded — would confirm or refute the canonical reading that she was born in Clausthal, Kingdom of Hannover, ~1840. The 1900 census records her as Missouri-born (likely transcription error), but the 1870 entry would be ~30 years closer to her actual birth.
What level of detail to expect on origin
The 1870 schedule had a free-text "Place of birth" column (column 11) plus the new "Father of foreign birth / Mother of foreign birth" flags (columns 11-12). For Charles, the place-of-birth field could read at any of three granularities:
- "Germany" — broadest. By 1870 the post-1871 unification language was already filtering down even though German unification wasn't quite complete; many enumerators wrote "Germany" by default.
- State-level — "Hesse," "Hessen-Cassel," "Hessen Cassel," "Kurhessen," or sometimes "Prussia" (which had annexed Kurhessen in 1866). For Charles, this would be the highest-probability outcome by 1870 — he had been in St. Louis ~11 years and may have given the enumerator a more specific answer than in 1860.
- Specific town or village — rare but transformative. By 1870 Charles's English would have been good enough to communicate a place name like "Trendelburg" or "Deisel" to an English-speaking enumerator without it getting mangled (as it was in 1862's "Freundburg Kurhessen").
Equally informative: the same column for Auguste. The 1900 census records her as Missouri-born; if the 1870 entry says Hesse-Kassel or another German state, that would be the closer-to-truth record and would correct one of the wife-side biographical fields.
Adjacent record found — Georg Kreichelt (Charles's father-in-law)
The household of Charles's parents-in-law was located in the 1870 census, mistranscribed by the indexer. Documenting it here as the geographic anchor for the search.
found Georg Kreichelt household · St. Louis Ward 03 / Image 476
| Surname as transcribed | Reichel (mistranscribed — correct: Kreichelt) |
| Dwelling / family number | 1683 / 2873 |
| FHL film / image | 4263033 · image 476 of 600 |
| Members | Georg 51 (Huckster, Hannover, $650 personal estate) · Henriette 51 (keeping house, Hannover) · Chas 21 = Carl Kreichelt cigar maker · Julius 15 (errand boy) · Barbara 10 |
| Auguste present? | No — correctly absent (married Charles Gannsen Jan 1866; living elsewhere by 1870) |
| Source | Ancestry record 1216439 |
Search log — passes attempted
negative Pass 1 · Page-by-page walk around the Kreichelts
Walked 10 consecutive census images (pages 472–482, ~80 households) around the Kreichelt household, looking for a Charles + Auguste pair under any plausible mistranscription. Visually scanned every household head + spouse for a 35-year-old Hesse-born husband + ~27-year-old wife "Auguste" + small child(ren).
- Pages 474–478: closest neighbors to Kreichelt at family numbers 2855–2891 — no match
- Pages 472–473, 479–482: extended sweep — no match
- Closest near-misses by partial criteria: August Loeffel (Hesse Tagelöhner, but wife is Henrietta not Auguste); Chas Heas (Hesse Damust huckster, wife Eligah, four children too many); John C. Germer (Hesse Kassel Porter, wife Mary not Auguste, kids predate marriage)
negative Pass 2 · Auguste-side index search
Filtered Ancestry 1870 census on first name "Auguste" / "Augusta", birth year 1843 ± 5, lived in St. Louis Missouri, with spouse "Charles". Returned 310k+ broad results. Filtered further by birth place "Hesse-Cassel" / "Kurhessen". Top match was Augusta Gansman in Ward 4 — but the household is a separate Gansman family:
- Fred Gansman 33, Engraver, b. Brunswick (Braunschweig), $500
- Augusta 27, Keeps House, b. Hessen-Cassel
- Herman 4, b. New York
- Mina 2, b. New York
Wife profile matches our Auguste Kreichelt (b. ~1840 Clausthal, Hannover) but everything else rules it out: husband is "Fred" age 33 b. Brunswick (not Charles age 35 b. Hesse-Kassel); kids born in NY (Charles & Auguste have always been in St. Louis since 1859/1866 respectively); kids' names & ages don't match Charles & Auguste's known children. Recorded as a "name-twin" St. Louis Gansman family.
negative Pass 3 · Charles-side index search
Filtered Ancestry 1870 census on birth year 1835 ± 5, gender male, birth place "Hesse-Cassel" / "Kurhessen", lived in St. Louis Missouri. Top candidates examined:
- Louis Ploeser (Ward 3, Hesse-Darmstadt, Saddle Tree Maker, wife Augusta 33) — kids Frederick 11 / Louis 9 / Christian 7 / William 3 / Charles 9 mo predate Charles & Auguste's 1866 wedding. Different family.
- Charles Sommer (Ward 3, Hesse-Kassel) — wife Mary, not Auguste.
- Adam Seamen (Ward 1, Hesse, wife "Augustus" = Augusta) — wealthy brewer, $40K real estate, six children. Different family.
- John C. Germer (Ward 5, Hesse Kassel, Porter in Store) — wife Mary, kids predate marriage.
negative Pass 4 · Surname-variant exact searches
- Gansen exact + St. Louis Missouri + 1870 — 634 fuzzy results, none in St Louis matching Charles profile
- Konsen exact + St. Louis Missouri + 1870 — 305 fuzzy results, top hits in Maryland/Virginia/Ohio/Kentucky; only Frederick Kinzen in Saint Ferdinand St. Louis (b. 1853 Prussia, not Charles)
- Charles Gansen exact + birth 1835 ± 5 — three matches total: Charles Ganson (Ohio), Charles Genson (Michigan), Charles Gonson (NY/Sweden). None in St. Louis.
The first conclusion (April 2026)
After these passes the first conclusion was that the enumerator had missed the household, perhaps during a move. Two of its supports did not hold: the target wards were wrong (the family’s addresses fall in the Ward 1–3 zone, not Wards 4/5), and the spouse-anchored index searches above cannot work, because the FamilySearch 1870 index carries no household links. The June 2026 work below corrected both.
June 2026 — FamilySearch index sweep and method corrections
A fresh attempt on the FamilySearch indexed 1870 U.S. census (collection 1438024), driven by the address evidence. The household was still not located, but the work overturned several assumptions that had quietly invalidated parts of the earlier search, and it re-pointed the ward target.
★ Four corrections that change how the search must be run
- The 1870 federal census is NOT in FamilySearch Full-Text. Full-Text covers St. Louis city directories (715 "Kreichelt" hits) and a handful of census collections (e.g. 1929/1935 Oklahoma), but not the 1870 U.S. census. The "Full-Text when available" next-path is therefore closed for this record. (Directory full-text, however, is a live avenue — see below.)
- The 1870 index has no household / relationship links. The 1870 schedule recorded no relationships, and FamilySearch did not reconstruct them. Sanity check: "Charles" b.1828–42 in St. Louis = 3,279 hits, but "Charles + spouse Aug*" = 0. Every spouse-anchored query returns 0 regardless of truth — which voids the spouse-"Charles"/wife-pair logic used in the earlier Pass 2 & Pass 3. Households can only be reached by searching one person and opening the record to read the co-residents.
- On census day they were at 718 Gates, recorded as "Johnson," not at 1518 S 7th. The pension address-chain dates 718 Gates to 1869–1874, so 1 June 1870 falls there (the directories, though, place him there only from late 1870; see the top of the page); the 1871 Edwards' Directory lists the head as "Johnson, Charles, conductor, St. Louis R.R., r. 718 Gate." The 1870 enumerator may well have written a phonetic German surname (cf. 1880 "Gonson"), but the anglicized "Johnson" + occupation conductor is now an explicit thing to search.
- Auguste was Hannover-born, not Hesse. She was born ~1840 in Clausthal, Kingdom of Hannover. The earlier Pass 2 filtered her birthplace as "Hesse-Cassel," which would exclude the true entry. Her 1870 birthplace should read Hanover (or possibly Prussia).
Ward re-analysis (Edwards’ 1870 ward boundaries)
Using the 1870 ward boundaries from Edwards' Directory: Ward 3's south edge ran along Lafayette (east of Linn) and its north edge along Rutger/Hickory; Ward 2 lay just south of Lafayette. The family's south-side cluster (1518 S 7th and the Gates-area addresses) sits around Lafayette Ave — i.e. astride the Ward 2 / Ward 3 line — and the in-laws (Georg Kreichelt) were already confirmed in Ward 3. Wards 4 and 5 are ruled out as primary targets: Ward 4's north edge is Plum/Cerre and Ward 5 is the Market/Clark corridor, both well north of these addresses. The prior log's "Wards 4/5" guess should be replaced with Ward 2 + the unwalked majority of Ward 3 (the April walk covered only ~10 pages around the Kreichelts at image 476).
negative Pass 5 · Wife as principal (no spouse link), corrected birthplace
- Aug* female b.1836–45, St. Louis = 605; + birthplace Hanover = 388 (still includes males August/Augustus).
- Exact "Augusta" b.1837–43, birthplace Hanover, St. Louis = 316 (16 pages). With no family links to narrow by and a common given name, the pool is intractable to brute-force.
- Child "Josephine" b.1866–70, St. Louis = 1,942 — equally intractable for the same reason.
negative Pass 6 · Surname "Johnson" (the directory spelling)
- "Charles/Chas Johnson," St. Louis 1870 = 72; narrowed to b.1831–40 = 18 — birthplaces almost all U.S. Only two are German-born:
- Charles Johnson, 40, b. Germany — Ward 1, household 154 (M4XG-STX): wife "Minnie" 26, daughters Barbara 4, Louisa 3, Anna 1. Wrong wife, wrong children — eliminated.
- C P Johnson, b.1833 Prussia — the one remaining German "Johnson" male; low priority (initials "C P," Prussia) and not yet household-checked.
negative Pass 7 · Surname-variant sweeps on the FamilySearch full-text index
- Gonson exact, St. Louis 1870 = 0. Wildcard G*ns*n = 44 — all the known "Gansman" name-twin cluster (Val/Henry/Mary Gansman, b. Hesse/Hanover); no Gonson/Gonnson household.
- Jansen + given "C*" = 0 Charles (only a Cath and a Charlotte).
- K*ns*n = 8. Surfaced a tempting "Augusta Kransen," 30, b. Prussia (surname ≈ Konsen/Gonsen?; age right) — but she is a domestic servant in the Geo Schlosstein household (Bavaria; Ward 1) alongside a 17-yr-old Louise Krausen. Unmarried, no Josephine — eliminated.
surname-independent Pass 8 · Given name + true origin, ignoring the surname
- "Charles/Cha*" b. Hesse, St. Louis 1870 = 77 (surname-independent — would catch him under any mistranscribed surname if the given name read "Charles" and the birthplace read "Hesse"). Of these only ~2 city men are specifically Hesse-Cassel/Kassel (his real origin): Charles H. Dittmer (1836) and Chas Nuruberg (1833) — surnames bearing no resemblance to any Konzen/Gonson form. Not adoptable as matches; the 77 cannot be household-checked one-by-one without a ward filter, and the standardized place drops the ward, so the search cannot be restricted to Ward 2/3 — ward elimination requires opening each record individually.
★ Breakthrough — the city directories place "Charles Gonson" at 718 Gate, in a railroad-workers' building
A FamilySearch Full-Text sweep of "718 Gate" across the St. Louis directories (these are fully OCR-indexed) recovered the family's own entries and, crucially, their neighbors:
| 1876 directory | "Gonson Charles, driver, 718 Gate" — our Charles, under the same surname the 1880 census uses, at 718 Gate. |
| 1872–73 directory | "Johnson Charles, conductor, r. 718 Gate" (plus a second "Johnson Charles, conductor, T.W. & W.R.R.") — the anglicized rendering, streetcar conductor. |
| 1868–69 directory | 718 Gate housed a cluster of St. Louis R.R. (horse-car) men: McDonald Allan J. (driver), McDonald John D. (conductor), McDonald Joseph (driver), and William Chisholm (driver). Same building, same employer. |
| 1877–82 directories | 718 Gate continues as a working-men's address: Walter Mulligan (1877–78), brewer Adam Ehl & midwife Selina Ehl (1880), conductor William D. Hall (1880–82), conductor Jacob Rose (1872–73). |
Why this matters: 718 Gate was evidently a multi-tenant building tied to the St. Louis Railroad car service, and Charles — as a streetcar conductor/driver — lived there from ~1869 well into the 1870s. The 1870 census household is therefore almost certainly enumerated alongside other St. Louis R.R. families. Finding any 718-Gate neighbor in the 1870 census pins the exact page where Charles's mistranscribed/omitted household sits.
Status of the neighbor-anchor: the only "Chisholm" in 1870 St. Louis is an unrelated Canadian family in Ward 9 (William Chisholm the railroad driver had moved on), so it does not pin the page. Adam Ehl (the 718-Gate brewer) is in the 1880 census at 1903 Linn Street, ED 100 (saloonkeeper) — i.e. residents of this cluster sit in the Soulard / Linn-Street district, the deep-south-central grid that in 1870 falls in Ward 1–2 (south of Lafayette). This nudges the likely 1870 ward south of the Kreichelts (Ward 3), toward Ward 2. "Gate" street still isn't placed on any period map (residents' directory vs. census addresses don't agree, so it may have been an alley or a renamed stub). The neighbor-anchor was then run to exhaustion and failed: Jacob Rose is not in St. Louis in the 1870 census (he reached 718 Gate only by 1872–73), and the McDonalds / Chisholm of the 1868–69 directory don't surface at 718 Gate in 1870 either. In other words, none of the documented 718-Gate neighbors was demonstrably co-resident in June 1870 except Charles himself — so there is no neighbor to pin the page. The sole remaining route is a manual image page-walk of the Soulard/Linn blocks of 1870 Ward 2 (and the south end of Ward 3), scanning for a railroad-worker household headed by a German "Charles/Carl" ~35 with wife Auguste and toddler Josephine.
First walk attempt: opened the 1870 Ward 1 image set on Ancestry to scope the walk. Two hard facts emerged. (1) The 1870 schedule has no street/house-number column (street addressing of the census only began in 1880) — so there is no way to jump to "Gate" or "Linn" street; the household can only be found by reading names line-by-line. (2) Scale: St. Louis Ward 1 alone is 678 images (~40 names each ≈ 27,000 people), and Ward 2 is comparable — so a blind name-by-name walk of the candidate area is a multi-thousand-page manual task, not completable in a single sitting. Conclusion: a productive walk needs the neighborhood narrowed first.
★ “Gate Street” located — Carondelet Avenue, Benton Park (1870 Ward 1)
A FamilySearch Full-Text search of the directory fire/police call-box lists (1875–76, 1880, 1882 St. Louis directories) repeatedly records the box at “Carondelet av. and Gate,” listed in sequence with “Carondelet av. and Pestalozzi,” “McNair av.,” “Lynch,” and “Cherokee and Lemp's Brewery.” An 1864–65 directory likewise has a “Gate av.” corner entry. This finally places the lost “Gate” street as a cross-street of Carondelet Avenue in the deep-south Benton Park / Marine Villa brewing district (~2700–2900 south) — not in Soulard proper. In the 1870 ward grid that block is Ward 1 (everything south of the Barton → Carondelet-av → Victor → Shenandoah line). The cast fits the place perfectly: a horse-car conductor/driver (Charles) and a brewer (Adam Ehl, later 1903 Linn) living in the Carondelet-Avenue / Lemp's-Brewery streetcar district, on the family's documented southward drift (1518 S 7th → 718 Gate → 2409 S Broadway).
Refined walk target: the 1870 Ward 1 images covering the Carondelet Av / Pestalozzi / Lynch / Benton Park blocks (the enumerator walked street-by-street, so these cluster on consecutive sheets).
Anchor attempts (exhausted): tried to pin the exact Ward-1 sheets via a household known to be at/near Gate in 1870 — Adam Ehl is not in the 1870 census (St. Louis), the 718-Gate McDonalds can't be isolated among ~12,000 Irish McDonalds, and no other Gate resident is both indexed and demonstrably present in June 1870. On Ancestry, filtering “Augusta b.1840 + spouse Charles” down to St. Louis Ward 1 surfaces only unrelated couples (the “Krausen” servant, Augusta Loutwick/spouse Louis, Augusta Renecke/spouse Nicholas) — confirming once more that our household is not indexed with “Charles” as the inferred spouse (his given name was mistranscribed too).
Two remaining routes, both manual: (1) a no-spouse scan of every German-born “Augusta” ~30 in 1870 Ward 1, opening each household to look for a streetcar-worker “Charles/Carl” + a ~2-yr-old Josephine; or (2) a direct image walk of the Ward-1 Benton Park / Carondelet-Av sheets. Failing both, a handwriting-recognition index of the 1870 census (as already exists for the directories that cracked this case) remains the cleanest eventual route.
Image walk around the Lemp anchor. The decisive anchor for the walk is William J. Lemp (the Western/Lemp Brewery owner), enumerated in 1870 Ward 1, NARA roll M593_810, page 92B, dwelling 139, image 4273861_00192 (occupation “Brewery,” $225k real estate) — his brewery sat at Cherokee & Carondelet, ~two blocks from Gate (Carondelet Av & Pestalozzi), so Charles should be in the same enumeration. Using Ancestry's per-sheet index panel (which lists every person's name/age/birthplace/occupation without handwriting-reading), the walk covered pages 91–99 (dwellings 134–200, ~360 households) straddling the brewery. Every household is a German/Swiss/Irish/Scandinavian working family — laborers, stone-cutters, masons, coopers, butchers, brewery hands — but no Charles + Auguste + Josephine cluster appears.
Key tell from the walk: across the whole Carondelet-Av/brewery stretch there is not a single streetcar conductor or driver — yet 718 Gate housed a whole cluster of St. Louis R.R. men (the McDonalds, Rose, Chisholm, and Charles himself). So 718 Gate's railroad-worker building is not in the brewery blocks beside Lemp; the streetcar cluster — and Charles — sits beside the St. Louis Railroad horse-car barn/stables.
Car-barn located: the 1866–67 St. Louis directory lists “St. Louis Railroad Co. Stables, W. Carondelet av. near Arsenal” (southern division) — i.e. north along Carondelet Av from Lemp's brewery, toward the lower dwelling numbers / earlier census sheets. The streetcar-worker cluster (and 718 Gate) should sit near there.
Walk extended toward the stables — 16 sheets cleared (pages 84–99, dwellings 95–200, ~640 households). Heading north/back from Lemp the trades shift (teamsters Grewoer/Baha/Gerhause/Krisner; a wagon-driver; then mixed English/Irish — policeman, physician, plasterers, cigar-maker) but still no streetcar-conductor cluster and no Charles + Auguste + Josephine. The only “Charles Johnson” reached is the previously-eliminated German laborer at dwelling 109 (wife Minnie; daughters Barbara/Anna/Louisa; record M4XG-STX).
Entire subdivision walked — 24 sheets (images 4273861_00175–00199, dwellings 37–200, ~900 households): complete negative. The full first enumeration subdivision of 1870 Ward 1 has now been read end-to-end via the index panel. It contains exactly the expected neighborhood — the Lemp brewery and its German workers; the wealthy Carondelet-Av merchant blocks (the DeMenil physician $400k, Anheuser the brewer, Bowman jewelers); and several scattered street-railway men (Frank Faggley “driver on light car,” — Conner “conductor,” Adam Shoer “car conductor,” John Sochrim “RR conductor”), confirming this is the right kind of district. But there is no Charles Gonson/Johnson with an Auguste and a Josephine anywhere in the subdivision.
What this means. The best-reasoned target subdivision — the one containing Gate Street's Carondelet-Av blocks, the brewery, and the only conductor cluster — does not contain the household. The remaining possibilities are: (a) the family sits in a different enumeration subdivision of Ward 1 (the roll runs to 678 images; this subdivision was only ~25 of them) or just over the line in Ward 2 near the Arsenal stables — i.e. a blind search of hundreds more sheets with no anchor to target; (b) the 1870 enumerator genuinely missed the household (the original “not in the indexed data” hypothesis); or (c) it is present but with given names mangled past recognition even in the images. Conclusion of the page-walk: the targeted, anchored walk is complete and negative; further walking is unanchored and open-ended. The clean finish remains a handwriting-recognition/full-text index of the 1870 census (the same tool class that cracked the directories), which would surface the household by content regardless of surname/given-name distortion. The case is documented to a precise, resumable state: man (Charles Gonson/Johnson, streetcar conductor), street (Gate = Carondelet Av near Pestalozzi, Benton Park, 1870 Ward 1), anchor (Lemp, dwelling 139, image 4273861_00192), car-barn (Carondelet Av near Arsenal, likely Ward 2), and the entire Ward-1 brewery subdivision (dwellings 37–200, 24 sheets) now cleared.
Full-text coverage: as of 1 August 2026 FamilySearch Full-Text did not cover the 1870 U.S. census (a “Kreichelt” search filtered to Record Type = Census returns only three Muskogee, Oklahoma records of 1929/1935).
negative Pass 9 · Ancestry's household-linked 1870 index (3-way)
- Unlike FamilySearch, Ancestry's 1870 index does infer household relationships and shows the ward per hit — so it can be searched by family member. All three anchorings were run, St. Louis, no surname:
- Head Charles (b.1835) + spouse Augusta — top match is "Charles Happlerheimer, spouse Augusta, Ward 12, Prussia"; no Ward 2/3 German "Charles + Augusta" couple resembling the family in the ranked results.
- Wife Augusta (b.1840) + spouse Charles — no St. Louis Augusta whose husband is Charles/Chas matches on ward + Hanover origin; nearest Ward-3 adjacencies are "Augusta Trumm / Chas, Ward 3, Prussia ~1839" and (childless) "Charles Muenchhausen, Ward 3, Hanover" — neither fits surname, birthplace, or children.
- Child Josephine (b.1868) + father Charles + mother Augusta — no Josephine ~2 in St. Louis has both parents Charles and Augusta (the Charles-fathered Josephines have mothers Catharine / Bridget / Amelia).
- The previously-rejected "Charles Sommer, Ward 3, Hesse-Kassel, wife Mary" reappears here, confirming it is the only Hesse-Cassel "Charles" couple in Ward 3 — and its wife is Mary, not Auguste.
Revised conclusion (two-platform negative)
The household is not retrievable from the indexed 1870 census on either FamilySearch or Ancestry — not as a Charles+Augusta couple (both spouse directions), not via the child Josephine with both parents named, and not under any recognizable surname variant (Gonson/Gonnson/Gansen/Konsen/Jansen/Johnson). Because Ancestry's household-linked, ward-aware index also fails to surface them, the earlier "given-name pools too large" limitation is no longer the whole story: the family is simply not present in the index as a recognizably-named St. Louis household. The two live explanations are (a) the enumerator missed the household (consistent with the 1869–70 move to 718 Gates), or (b) the surname and/or given names were mistranscribed into forms no name search reaches. Either way, the record is now recoverable only by a manual page-walk of the Ward 2 / Ward 3 images (or a fresh OCR/full-text index of the 1870 census if one is published).
The routes this pointed to — a page walk of Wards 2 and 3 and the directory cross-checks — were overtaken in October 2026 by the image walk of every 1870 St. Louis unit described at the top of this page. The “C P Johnson”, b. 1833 Prussia, was not household-checked here.
Directory-mining sweep (FamilySearch Full-Text, June 2026)
The 718-Gate breakthrough prompted a full sweep of the St. Louis city directories for Charles under every surname spelling and at every documented address. It produced his only contemporaneous original sources and re-dated three address spans. Recorded here so the address-trail work lives alongside the 1870 hunt that spawned it.
Directory address trail — what the sweep found
| 718 Gate | 1871 Johnson, conductor · 1872–73 Johnson, conductor (direct ↗) · 1874 Konsen, driver (direct ↗) · 1876 Gonson, driver. Four spellings; extends the tenure to 1876. |
| rear 2407 DeKalb | 1887 & 1887–88 Johnson, watch (direct ↗) · 1895 & 1895–96 Gannsen, watch (+ Charles Jr.). Extends the DeKalb/watchman residency back to 1887; 1888–94 are pension-only (the directory shows other tenants those years). |
| 1516 / 1518 S 7th | No entry for Charles found at either number in any 1860s–70s directory — both were large multi-family tenements (1870–71 lists the Schweikert tailors at 1518; the Reis/Reif/Gettelmann families at 1516). The 1865–69 first address rests only on Charles's c. 1898 pension recollection (“1516 So. 7th”); its number and dates are approximate. His earliest contemporaneous record anywhere in St. Louis is the 1871 directory at 718 Gate. |
All entries reproduce the n–s–n / n–z–n surname skeleton (Johnson / Konsen / Gonson / Gannsen). Full chronology, with verification links, is on the St. Louis residences page; the spellings are tabled on Surname across the records.
Cross-references in the project
- Konze family page — the Konze families of the Trendelburg area
- The Trendelburg researcher's correspondence timeline — the 1870 census search question first surfaced in Oct 2025 (the Trendelburg researcher: "Charles doesn't appear in U.S. records until 1861. Not in 1860 census.")